Crusader Kings II: A Mafia Tale GAME Thread

[Poyser]

Mostly how when Tweet replied with that joke about you voting Jeff P1 but not wanting to be pressured into voting. He specified it was just a joke but you still responded to defend yourself about it. Then I felt you got more defensive about your misunderstanding about the "O Rly" line than you needed to be. But I do think I was one pushing you in past games for seeming awkward when you were town, so that's noted

I’ve forgotten why you think sky is more scummy than him

 

[Chris]

I’ve forgotten why you think sky is more scummy than him

Because Sky's reasons for reading both Banez and Evans scum felt ridiculously forced and I've been a victim of misreading Evans early a couple of times so far

 

[Sky]

Mostly how when Tweet replied with that joke about you voting Jeff P1 but not wanting to be pressured into voting. He specified it was just a joke but you still responded to defend yourself about it. Then I felt you got more defensive about your misunderstanding about the "O Rly" line than you needed to be. But I do think I was one pushing you in past games for seeming awkward when you were town, so that's noted

Bolded part is big big. He does some shading, and then he immediately walks it back with "but you might be town". I'm fine with lynching both of them but I see Chris as D1 priority by a nose, just because of stuff like this

 

[Canadian Dragon]

This isn't a bad point, do you think maybe he didn't vote bc you had just said the 3rd one on a wagon is scum

agrees with sky shading ev

I thought Evans kind of danced around voting Banez in that interaction, but then when Sky explained her reasoning more I thought it was way off. She just applied "generic low tier mafia" player to Evans

explaining why moving to sky in shades. doesnt really actually give a read on ev here

Yes can I get a vote count tho you, Jeff, Sky, and Banez I think?

Null on you
Not a fan of Sky so far for reasons stated
lean town on Banez for reasons stated
Jeff I could go either way with, he's voted Banez and me so far just to "make things happen" but isn't pushing them hard himself like he normally does, seems odd but it could just be nothing has really pinged him yet

his read list that he was asked for.

He's seemed awkward twice to me as well. The first when Sky asked him to vote Banez, mostly after Tweet questioned him on it. And then that comment about your game and Jeff's "O RLY?" confusion.

Can't see him or Sky being aligned as scum at this point either

so he seems awkward twice, isn't alligned with sky per you own admission, but you want to vote sky. hmm.

 

[Sky]

agrees with sky shading ev



explaining why moving to sky in shades. doesnt really actually give a read on ev here



his read list that he was asked for.



so he seems awkward twice, isn't alligned with sky per you own admission, but you want to vote sky. hmm.

This is a very good post, and actually quite funny in demonstrating how Chris' attempt to shade me seems to have fallen at the first

 

[Chris]

agrees with sky shading ev



explaining why moving to sky in shades. doesnt really actually give a read on ev here



his read list that he was asked for.



so he seems awkward twice, isn't alligned with sky per you own admission, but you want to vote sky. hmm.

Yes because Sky's reasoning for scum reading Evans and Banez look more off to me than any of Evans' awkwardness which I've already stated as why I hadn't pushed Evans anymore after I agreed with Sky on him because her comments came fairly soon after.

I'm by no means town reading Evans but two people that I think could be scum jumping on him right after Poyser votes makes him seem better by elimination

 

[Odo]

This is encouraging

 

[Poyser]

Would rate it quite highly if sky was scum and the other two town tbh

 

[Odo]

Yes because Sky's reasoning for scum reading Evans and Banez look more off to me than any of Evans' awkwardness which I've already stated as why I hadn't pushed Evans anymore after I agreed with Sky on him because her comments came fairly soon after.

I'm by no means town reading Evans but two people that I think could be scum jumping on him right after Poyser votes makes him seem better by elimination

So how are you reading him? Gun to head like

 

[Tweet]

Is it bad that I got no idea what anyone is talking about rn?

 

[Sky]

Would rate it quite highly if sky was scum and the other two town tbh

Very odd combo. How would that work?

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Would rate it quite highly if sky was scum and the other two town tbh

intresting, not really where I was going in my head. care to entertain me through the thought?

 

[Sky]

Is it bad that I got no idea what anyone is talking about rn?

Welcome to how I feel every game. I like to think you and I both have enough horse-sense to get by

 

[Poyser]

Is it bad that I got no idea what anyone is talking about rn?

Ich spiele mit deiner mutter

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Ich spiele mit deiner mutter

Didn't know she played mafia