Clock Tower Mafia II: Don't Cry Jennifer Game Thread

[Tweet]

unvote Smark

 

[Odo]

no ones asking you to retract your read on him tho

the part im saying youre wrong about is that its evidence of his scumminess that he didnt cop blaine - its usually better to cop someone under the rader where scum misdirection that you have to account for isnt likely to go

 

[Comrade Khan]

This is exactly where I'm at as well and if you read the thread even badly, JEFF, you'll know this to be true.

Like I don't think anybody says that you don't have a point wrt Haza but it's just not enough to lynch the claimed Cop.

and outside of exo spec, what do we really have in blaine? dont take this as me being opposed to getting rid of, but like, we objectively learn more from hazas flip than blaines flip no?

 

[Worst Player Ever]

unvote

 

[Comrade Khan]

no ones asking you to retract your read on him tho

the part im saying youre wrong about is that its evidence of his scumminess that he didnt cop blaine - its usually better to cop someone under the rader where scum misdirection that you have to account for isnt likely to go

meh i disagree. to me the obvious play was watch and cop blaine. watcher catches anyone who fucks with him , cop may gets exposed but its a bunch of confirm either way. maybe im just too BIG BRAINED

 

[Smart Marx]

I'm probably of the same opinion tbh but Odo should be confirmed off role and is obvious a much bigger asset than Blaine so its a no Brainer

I didnt really understand why you thought town protection would come and CC by saying finish them off though

Nobody would ever do this?

Not on day 2, but maybe a later on, but like never lynch cop or doctor without a cc of some kind.

And theoretically they might if we debated this another 20 hours and we almost no lynched.

I’d rather out being a whatever then have Blaine be the only real wagon for the third day in a row.

 

[Odo]

relies on a) there being a watcher, and b) the watcher being town

 

[Comrade Khan]

if anyone other than the claimed cop visits blaine wed have known they were scum too. like i dunno, maybe that shit is only obvious to me i guess

 

[Comrade Khan]

relies on a) there being a watcher, and b) the watcher being town

i mean fair, but i was expecting something. not a postive town result for someone who was town read by the currently most town read person (you) at thye time of usage. i guess its semantics and how my brain work and theres no point really explaining it any other way . i just hate it

 

[Odo]

and thats fair enough, theres nothing wrong with scepticism, but my problem begins when the line into berating people who dont want to gamble is crossed

 

[Comrade Khan]

like why not big man for example

 

[RDK]

If Blaine is scum we PROBABLY already have as good as a scum cop result on him in the form of a CC. I think it's really that simple tbh and think using a shot would have been a waste. Last time i'm gonna say it im getting super bored of this game very rapidly

 

[Odo]

anyway @Raidokken you can handle your own defence from here

 

[Comrade Khan]

and thats fair enough, theres nothing wrong with scepticism, but my problem begins when the line into berating people who dont want to gamble is crossed

well i felt people were blindly ignoring shit and being pedantic, esp last night. so i felt the need to defend my position. apologies if aggressive but if i think something is dumb i have a hard time of saying it any other way

 

[CraigPelton]

I cop CP 8/10 on day one tbh

cowardly and gay imo

Until someone else comes forward and says hi I’m the town jailkeeper or faith healer or something

no we should not have a protection role out themselves day 2 just to get someone lynched

There's not even a guarantee town can't have two protection roles or anything