Castlevania Mafia - Game Thread

[Showtime]

But I feel like you're operating under the assumption that Wang is the QT leader here? Does that seem likely lmao

^^^

@Showtime thoughts on Big Man & Haza's counter points?

i think yall went on way too fucking long.

i still think big man is town and if poyser's info is true big man is probably town and even if poyser is scum it still probably makes big man town(altho ive seen poyser do stupid shit as scum before with the idea that town wouldnt consider it so that's kinda bleh).

IT'S FUNNY YOU ASK!

I'm not at all familiar with him as a player.

I found his interaction with Barry in his first few posts a bit weird, almost like he was looking for acknowledgement from him. Might have been his 2nd post? Where he mentions Barry bodying people.

What I did notice, is that here:



He says he's seen Barry mention about bodying people a couple of times. Barry has only threatened to body people twice in this game.

1st occurrence: 12:28am



Wangs 2nd post of the game follows as this at 12:41am.

The 2nd bodying soft didn't come until 2:30am

evans i like the way you make cases, but please remember when you are focusing in on people consider both sides. consider why they might be town and what potential town motivations could be. you sometimes get lost in just zoning in on people completely without consider the idea they might be town. i know in your head it weakens your argument or whatever, but it is more likely to result in a correct read.

poyser probably the SK then and went for the 2-for-1

idk why you suggested this.

Any excuse to bring it up

Also I’ve no reason to troll or vote Banez if he’s defending me - if other people are voting me and I’m town with him being scum, there’s no reason for him not to follow.

additionally, my great record on reading Banez isn’t what it once was.

are you just lurking and not adding stuff?

magic pls stop mentioning me it looks sus

imagine if we were scum together, WE COULD DO ANYTHING AND TALK OURSELVES OUT OF ANY SITUATION.

or so they say.

how does that make him town

someone not going anywhere=not likely to have a scum role that would be used.

depends on the sort of roles scum have tho as certain x-shot roles you dont want to use night 1.

Why wouldn't you track me after I claimed VT (and def wouldn't be going anywhere) when you were sus of me all day Poyser?

I agree it makes it likely Big Man isn't scum if you're telling the truth though bc scum most likely would have used most roles D1 depending on what they had, but this is odd usage to me

i wasnt aware you claimed vt until now lel.

chris what do you think of rugrat?

You're reading too much into the point I am making.

His role PM was given as scum. He knew he was scum and he knew he was a traitor. Comparing how he approaches his games as a traitor vs how he approaches games where he is town should definitely be considered, no?

sure i agree, but only to an extent. having teammates and knowing who they are is what influences your game to change more than anything else as scum. in that traitor game he got his teammate lynched on day 1. as scum he would not have gotten his teammate lynch day 1 as he wouldnt have made a big case on them, you feel me?

 

[Poyser]

Evans’ cases are pretty much copy pasta of my cases back in the day lol

 

[Chris]

@Showtime I don't hate the Rugrat direction, if he's town then it seems like he's just not into the game at all (which I think he may have mentioned being busy) but he also got mad a couple games ago when he was pushed for inactivity and criticized that strategy. I believe he was town that game (I can't even remember which one it was though, fairly recent), so I'd expect him to have similar thoughts on it here but he hasn't which I thought odd since it's a similar situation.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Evans’ cases are pretty much copy pasta of my cases back in the day lol

meaning?

 

[Comrade Khan]

^^^


i think yall went on way too fucking long.

i still think big man is town and if poyser's info is true big man is probably town and even if poyser is scum it still probably makes big man town(altho ive seen poyser do stupid shit as scum before with the idea that town wouldnt consider it so that's kinda bleh).



evans i like the way you make cases, but please remember when you are focusing in on people consider both sides. consider why they might be town and what potential town motivations could be. you sometimes get lost in just zoning in on people completely without consider the idea they might be town. i know in your head it weakens your argument or whatever, but it is more likely to result in a correct read.



idk why you suggested this.






are you just lurking and not adding stuff?



imagine if we were scum together, WE COULD DO ANYTHING AND TALK OURSELVES OUT OF ANY SITUATION.

or so they say.



someone not going anywhere=not likely to have a scum role that would be used.

depends on the sort of roles scum have tho as certain x-shot roles you dont want to use night 1.




i wasnt aware you claimed vt until now lel.

chris what do you think of rugrat?



sure i agree, but only to an extent. having teammates and knowing who they are is what influences your game to change more than anything else as scum. in that traitor game he got his teammate lynched on day 1. as scum he would not have gotten his teammate lynch day 1 as he wouldnt have made a big case on them, you feel me?

so whats your opinion on poyser now

 

[Ace]

Big Man is pretty much the most confirmed town r/n since Poyser's report would suggest Big Man is town or some weird Maf role with no night ability (unlikely).
This is true no matter whether Poyser is town or maf. [Yes I know this is largely what has already been said by Magic but just reiterating.]
I still like Poyser as town given his votes on me on d1 which seems unnecessary for a mafia to do and cos generally his play has felt town.
Haza is growing on me.
Still don't like Rugrat. He's continued talking largely about meta and shit which feels like easy maf copout.
I also don't like Craig being so trolly in his posting because this feels like he's trying too hard to act like a relaxed townie. Not sure I've ever played with him though so maybe this is standard.

 

[Showtime]

hold on guys my internet went down so I'm stuck on mobile

also scum roletracker is a thing for you JOKERS

^

also if there was a watcher on me and you have info it would be great to share that info

if you werent on me then obviously dont say anything

Poyser strikes me as a fellow playing his usual town game based off his usage and posting and play. Lethal can be town for now because he's actively looking to pursue people and feels like he's scumhunting. You can disagree, I don't really care.

breh why yall so hostile to questions that facilitate discussion

what do you think of rugrat?

if poyser is scum who would you look at?

I'd actually say to the contrary CP pushes Banez a fair bit after the claim, he questions some stuff he says as not making any sense. which looks better I think if you're trying to stay on Hider's good side which you would be as scum

Big Man does similar stuff which also looks decent

Actually Magic is the most antagonistic and seems to be straight up telling Banez what to do, I don't think you antagonize a hider like this if you're scum so that's town points for Magic although within his range as scum i'd say

what's the point in giving me town points and then saying they dont even matter?!

Haza is town

Poyser is fucking scum fucking liar piece of fucking oh man someone better hold me back

i still wanna get a claim from rugrat so can we do that yall?


vote rugrat


rugrat is also someone poyser kinda avoided to go in depth on unlike all his other votes. he voted him last phase then dipped iirc.

 

[Showtime]

so whats your opinion on poyser now

what do you mean now, nothing really changed. i still think he's scummy and a tracker claim doesnt really change that.

 

[Ace]

@Showtime I don't hate the Rugrat direction, if he's town then it seems like he's just not into the game at all (which I think he may have mentioned being busy) but he also got mad a couple games ago when he was pushed for inactivity and criticized that strategy. I believe he was town that game (I can't even remember which one it was though, fairly recent), so I'd expect him to have similar thoughts on it here but he hasn't which I thought odd since it's a similar situation.

It's not inactivity though, he's made a number of posts, he's just adding very little substance imo. Coasting.

I have absolutely no read on Magic ftr but tbf neither do any of you, it seems, as everything is 'seems town but in scum range' which is a nice way of saying y'all have nfi how to differentiate town magic from scum magic lmao

 

[Poyser]

meaning?

It’s just exactly what I used to do. Decide someone was scum and then go looking for reasons to prove me right

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Big Man is pretty much the most confirmed town r/n since Poyser's report would suggest Big Man is town or some weird Maf role with no night ability (unlikely).
This is true no matter whether Poyser is town or maf. [Yes I know this is largely what has already been said by Magic but just reiterating.]
I still like Poyser as town given his votes on me on d1 which seems unnecessary for a mafia to do and cos generally his play has felt town.
Haza is growing on me.
Still don't like Rugrat. He's continued talking largely about meta and shit which feels like easy maf copout.
I also don't like Craig being so trolly in his posting because this feels like he's trying too hard to act like a relaxed townie. Not sure I've ever played with him though so maybe this is standard.

Or he just didn't use a power last night..

 

[Poyser]

^

also if there was a watcher on me and you have info it would be great to share that info

if you werent on me then obviously dont say anything




breh why yall so hostile to questions that facilitate discussion

what do you think of rugrat?

if poyser is scum who would you look at?



what's the point in giving me town points and then saying they dont even matter?!

i still wanna get a claim from rugrat so can we do that yall?


vote rugrat


rugrat is also someone poyser kinda avoided to go in depth on unlike all his other votes. he voted him last phase then dipped iirc.

I never voted rugrat

 

[Poyser]

Also quite funny that CP started randomly accusing me of SK for ?? Reasons and then pivoted to Roletracker

 

[Showtime]

It's not inactivity though, he's made a number of posts, he's just adding very little substance imo. Coasting.

I have absolutely no read on Magic ftr but tbf neither do any of you, it seems, as everything is 'seems town but in scum range' which is a nice way of saying y'all have nfi how to differentiate town magic from scum magic lmao

i can read me, im town.

 

[Evans]

^^^


i think yall went on way too fucking long.

i still think big man is town and if poyser's info is true big man is probably town and even if poyser is scum it still probably makes big man town(altho ive seen poyser do stupid shit as scum before with the idea that town wouldnt consider it so that's kinda bleh).

evans i like the way you make cases, but please remember when you are focusing in on people consider both sides. consider why they might be town and what potential town motivations could be. you sometimes get lost in just zoning in on people completely without consider the idea they might be town. i know in your head it weakens your argument or whatever, but it is more likely to result in a correct read.

sure i agree, but only to an extent. having teammates and knowing who they are is what influences your game to change more than anything else as scum. in that traitor game he got his teammate lynched on day 1. as scum he would not have gotten his teammate lynch day 1 as he wouldnt have made a big case on them, you feel me?

I appreciate this, will take it on board - thanks dude.

Re: the last part, yeah absolutely. I think sometimes that when I try to explain things, I make them very wordy and it skews the intention of the post. My consideration of the traitor game was simply meant to be "he was a traitor here, he would have been operating a town meta until he is recruited or he's the last scum left alive. How does this compare to games when he is town and his town meta is natural?"