Castlevania Mafia - Game Thread

[Comrade Khan]

@CraigPelton I will assume your final analysis is you think poyser is the GF rolecop ?

 

[Evans]

Also, Isaac is a servant of Dracula in the Castlevania lore

 

[Chris]

Why wouldn't you track me after I claimed VT (and def wouldn't be going anywhere) when you were sus of me all day Poyser?

I agree it makes it likely Big Man isn't scum if you're telling the truth though bc scum most likely would have used most roles D1 depending on what they had, but this is odd usage to me

 

[Chris]

Oh wait I guess if Poyser forgot I was a VT then that first point doesn't matter

 

[RDK]

Why wouldn't you track me after I claimed VT (and def wouldn't be going anywhere) when you were sus of me all day Poyser?

I agree it makes it likely Big Man isn't scum if you're telling the truth though bc scum most likely would have used most roles D1 depending on what they had, but this is odd usage to me

He didn't know you claimed VT remember

 

[Comrade Khan]

Also, Isaac is a servant of Dracula in the Castlevania lore

Hector and Isaac are both demon forgers who worked for Dracula in Curse of Darkness. Isaac turns heel on him and is the main antagonist to the game. this one ive played. Hector is the protagonist of the game.

 

[Evans]

I'm gonna hedge bets on Big Man b

Hector and Isaac are both demon forgers who worked for Dracula in Curse of Darkness. Isaac turns heel on him and is the main antagonist to the game. this one ive played. Hector is the protagonist of the game.

Indeed.

What are your thoughts on Poyser claiming this character?

 

[Evans]

I'm gonna hedge bets on Big Man being aligned with Poyser

 

[Showtime]

Comparing Big Man's traitor game vs his town games is an excellent point of reference as we are able to identify where he's just playing as town compared to where he is actually town.

evans he caught scum in his traitor game and was shot because he basically bothered me. that isn't that great of a reference, he didnt look scum at all and didnt know his team. knowing your teammates is the biggest difference between mafia and town.

 

[Poyser]

Before you go - what were the "very specific" circumstances that would have to be in place to make Big Man scum?

How does tracking him to nowhere mean he's a strong blue town read for you?

Because 90% of scum players have a role and they tend to use them lol. The scenarios are either he’s a mafia goon (very rare in this section), a ninja (plausible but would be a huge coincidence) or he is scum and they didn’t use his role for whatever reason which is just really unlikely

 

[Poyser]

I mean, it's not at all improbable that if Big Man is scum that he has a non-killing role.

But if you could please clear up what these "specific circumstances" are?

He would still go somewhere if his role was non killing

 

[Showtime]

Also I’ve no reason to troll or vote Banez if he’s defending me - if other people are voting me and I’m town with him being scum, there’s no reason for him not to follow.

additionally, my great record on reading Banez isn’t what it once was.

see this is what i find bullshit


you legit troll to troll. you dont care about circumstance.

again, literally last game, you trolled me just to troll.

game before that when i was indy, you were trolling me well onto into the game and then, towards the end of that night phase, decided, "ok enough ya i dont think magic is actually scum".

 

[Poyser]

Why wouldn't you track me after I claimed VT (and def wouldn't be going anywhere) when you were sus of me all day Poyser?

I agree it makes it likely Big Man isn't scum if you're telling the truth though bc scum most likely would have used most roles D1 depending on what they had, but this is odd usage to me

I did forget but I wouldn’t have tracked you anyway because I’d rather get some insights on the inactives. I was originally on phenom but I changed once OMB repped in because OMB is an easy read and went for big man instead

 

[Poyser]

I'm gonna hedge bets on Big Man being aligned with Poyser

So I just tie myself to a teammate that is likely to get lynched for ??? gain?

 

[Evans]

evans he caught scum in his traitor game and was shot because he basically bothered me. that isn't that great of a reference, he didnt look scum at all and didnt know his team. knowing your teammates is the biggest difference between mafia and town.

You're reading too much into the point I am making.

His role PM was given as scum. He knew he was scum and he knew he was a traitor. Comparing how he approaches his games as a traitor vs how he approaches games where he is town should definitely be considered, no?