True, he's not great on the mic, especially when he's a face. But, he shines in every way when he's a heel.
He just oozes charisma and his in-ring work is top notch.
He is one of the best wrestlers on the planet right now.
Check his ROH and NJPW matches and I'm sure your opinion of Styles being overrated will change. The dude is fantastic.
...yeah yeah, I know it's the cool thing to say man lol, but I've seen alot of his stuff.
His claim to fame is the matches in Japan but almost anybody can have a good match with those guys over there, they're like HBK + Taker + Sting + Eddie Guerrero then multiply that by about 100 times. Before that in TNA he was just a guy that did some tricks.... Don't get me wrong, he's been around, so he has lots of experience but so do alot of guys. He's good, just not as good as everyone says, he's not the best on the planet by far, especially if you factor in those guys in Japan & Mexico. Actually even the UK has some amazing talent that WWE never batted an eye at until the CWC.
Also, I don't see alot of charisma to be honest other than his hand gestures when he comes to the ring lol.... It's not like he's Jericho, HBK or Mr. Perfect.... or even for this generation it's not like he's Bray Wyatt, Enzo, Shinsuke, Breeze or Owens.