Better Call Saul Mafia Game Thread

[Dance Hall Days]

It wasn't really an attempt to get Poyser's lynched or wagoned though was it? Just general, nebulous shade to both Poyser and Jeff. You're right that I wouldn't pick you as a power scum going for Poyser, but I can see that being a bad scum post more easily than a weird town post. As for my reads, it's mostly just players I've agreed with mostly being town and guys who's posts I've found a bit awkward and who's directions I'm not agreeing with as scum.

 

[Lethal]

This should be good. Why the vote on me?

Paranoid Smark is a town Smark, I hope

 

[Lethal]

Vague unease for Barry. Jeff going at it like crazy makes no sense as scum, but the "maybe I'll push her maybe I won't" attitude seems like something a scum would do to put a reasonable amount of suspicion on what should to all rights be a solid town read.

also there's a delightful bit of role spec between his DV and my role that makes me dislike him

Setup spec as opposed to examining game play. I question your motives, but refuse to tunnel Player X

 

[Lethal]

8 players haven't posted at all which is worrying

This, and the colour deal, seems like your efforts could be placed better.

 

[Poyser]

Hey tweet if you’re still awake give me a min

 

[Lethal]

Rugrat What a garbage vote

Unvote
Vote Rugrat

Why wouldn't you look, you know, in your role PM, where it would tell you the colour of the alignment you show up as?

How would you know?

"nah, I'm obvtown, you're just bad" is a bad defence

Unvote
Vote Shawn

Nice cop out. Where did the orange come from?

You still haven't explained where you got the orange from. One of your colours was dead on. What about the other?

I never said only town reads

I just said it feels good to be able to make town reads at all

I'm REALLY not wanting to suss you, but fucking hell

 

[Lethal]

Unvote
Vote Big Man

Make super sure he's in claim zone

This vote stinks

 

[Lethal]

Speaking of racial slurs, isnt uncle lethal supposed to b playing?

Surprised you showed up, Montel

 

[Dance Hall Days]

This is needling at me, @Jeffatron @Pepé Le Quagmire , how did you guys both come away with Smark being town from colour-gate but then later go after Sky as potentially being scum. Makes no sense to me.

 

[Lethal]

workout was great Rugrat, it was chest shoulders triceps day

reading back

yeah jeff is reading exactly the same as last game to me and I caught him twice lmao

vote jeff

What about his play last game is so 'exactly the same' here. I've actually seen a complete 180, he's hunting, questioning, putting a lot of pressure on.

 

[Lethal]

I actually don't believe the lie detector claim because we had a desperado. a lie detector is basically a desperado without the downside

so if chimp is saying that's his role I'm down to lynch

You are one who possesses a great attention to detail, so to have such an oversight as to miss who claimed this role is unsettling

 

[Poyser]

You’re being pretty disingenuous about why I’m voting you. Yes I said I don’t have a reason to read you town yet, but that’s literally just one thing that I said, we’ve interacted a fair amount where I quite clearly have other problems with you

First off, trying to dissuade town reads from me and then LYING about what your intentions with this were. You lied, straight up, because your defence is that you weren’t disagreeing with giving me town reads but didn’t believe the town reads from certain people, yet you literally said you disagree with giving me early town reads and that wasn’t to suss jeff, it was actually a caveat to you joining my big man wagon, which makes that look even worse now we know big man is town because it smacks of trying to set me up as an avenue once the big man wagon goes bad which if you’re scum you’d know it would.

Then your play around big man itself again nowwe know he’s town is also shady. You’re disingenuous about why I’m voting him, getting my case completely wrong whilst joining it, saying I’ve got a good idea to try and get activity out of him. You defend this by saying you misread my post but again this is a lie because I never said anything of the sort of trying to get activity out of him, or that he coasts as scum or anything like that, which just shows your thoughts to not really be genuine. To make it worse you joined my wagon thinking that was the only reason for it (and adding a caveat to you joining) when that’s a fucking terrible reason to be wagoning somebody after the initial first couple pages stages of the game. You were putting big man’s wagon deep into claim territory like 20 odd pages into the game because.... you wanted to prod activity out of him?

 

[Poyser]

This is needling at me, @Jeffatron @Pepé Le Quagmire , how did you guys both come away with Smark being town from colour-gate but then later go after Sky as potentially being scum. Makes no sense to me.

I got the heebie jeebies from this too haha. Wrt barry I actually read back and he never says town is smark from the colour deal. I thought the same as you here tho. Did jeff give smark a town read due to the colours?

I will say that I’m not exactly 100% sold on the lie detector claim and CP makes a good point about that and the desperado. It will be interesting to see if we have a cop and if so how limited they are. However jeff did indeed try to get me to say I am town earlier on, tgo that was a couple hours into the game and he says he hinted at it very early, so I’d like to see that post if you would @Jeffatron

 

[Lethal]

Current Reads

Town: Poyser, Smark, Sky, Mr Porter, Shawn

Fence: Rugrat, Tweet

Scum: RedPrince, Barry

Rest are null

A town Poyser is fantastic. Tweets' attitude to the wagon seems to hold some frustration as I know he was rather annoyed to be killed N1 in my game and may be annoyed that it's a possibility here again (early death). However, the refusal to claim attitude grew tiresome on WF and I still hate it.

Torn between a vote on Tweets as Poyser is a great read of him, or going rogue and putting pressure on the lizard. *Sigh*

 

[Poyser]

Btw now im confirmed I feel more comfortable saying this which is that I feel like I also saw scum as an orange somewhere. Like I feel like I’ve seen town teal and scum orange before, so when Shawn said it and people said he was wrong, I went to check my PM to see if the scum alignment is in there somewhere (it’s not).
Like idk where the fuck I seen it, but I wasn’t shocked at all when Shawn said it lmao, as I already felt like i knew the info

which is to say I’m probably not gonna lynch Shawn even if scum are orange. Also, his wording of his pm kinda makes the lie detector more believable. Could be worded that way for the desperado of course, but it makes more sense to cover a lie detector role or similar. That said if we have a decently strong cop (2x or more), we should lynch jeff

who is Shawn btw? Is he a WFer or a WSer?