Better Call Saul Mafia Game Thread

[Doddsy]

I wasn't exactly hinting at Cop in particular, I simply tried to avoid claiming outright by saying I'm not getting lynched in a bid to conceal my role at least for today. I mean when I say something like that the cat is already pretty much out of the bag but can't hurt to try. I was also trying to get Jeff to lie detect the statement that I am not the Cop to see if he was legit.

I mean you could confirm you're legit by catching scum, not wasting a lie detect shot

 

[Rugrat]

I think Tweet is the role cop.

Vote Tweet

 

[Smart Marx]

I do disagree with that, nothing should ever not be given as a fake. If it's a real role it's up for grabs, nothing should be inherently confirmed town just based on role

Then I assume you are against it when people say miller can't be a fake, because I think a cop fake is worse than a miller fake.

Millers are designed to make you not trust them. Cops are trusted town roles. So I'd agree with you, if you literally mean any role.

 

[Rugrat]

We got a live one

 

[Doddsy]

Then I assume you are against it when people say miller can't be a fake, because I think a cop fake is worse than a miller fake.

Millers are designed to make you not trust them. Cops are trusted town roles. So I'd agree with you, if you literally mean any role.

I've no problem with a miller fake either, I wish we had them more often as people just assume a miller is confirmed at this point

 

[Comrade Khan]

Rugrat, now that im thinking about it. If i lie detected him n hes a role cop. It come back positive wouldnt it

 

[Smart Marx]

I've no problem with a miller fake either, I wish we had them more often as people just assume a miller is confirmed at this point

Miller's entire point is to make town think a townie is scum, not confirm him as town.

 

[Tweet]

I think tweet has cop as a safe fake

1) we had a desperado and if jeff is legit we have a lie detector. I assume he can't use it during day. that's already a good number of alignment confirming roles.
2) his strategy with a good role (watcher) last game was to ask for the watcher, he said this was to deter scum. he got janitored n1.
3) this game he softed a good role early, making him a n1 janitor target yet again. why do this tweet
4) his "plan" to look scummy made no sense and sounds like something he would've made up after realizing jeff was a lie detector and his safe wasn't so safe anymore and he might actually be in trouble

I raised points 1 and 2 earlier and he no-sold the post but was active at the time as he was replying to jeff

lynching him isn't as risky as it seems. saying this for reasons privy only to me at this time

Another guy playing setup spec with a new host, don't mind if I disregard point #1 and #4.

I didn't soft anything of my own volition, Big Man shot Poyser, Big Man flipped town, Poyser got confirmed, I debatably looked bad off of those interactions and the wagon was on its way, there's not much else I can do but either claim outright or attempt to hint at stuff from that point.

 

[Smart Marx]

Rugrat, now that im thinking about it. If i lie detected him n hes a role cop. It come back positive wouldnt it

This is the first point you've made on Tweet I find no fault in. That could be possible.

 

[Tweet]

I mean you could confirm you're legit by catching scum, not wasting a lie detect shot

I've been on defense ever since Big Man flipped, Jeff is the one who insists that I'm scum and need to have my claim checked.

 

[Doddsy]

I would also assume a GF would give a 'favourable result' in opposition to the miller

 

[Smart Marx]

I would also assume a GF would give a 'favourable result' in opposition to the miller

I was saying that as well. If the miller is written like that, I would say so as I have written my GFs like that many times.

 

[Tweet]

Oh now I'm the Rolecop, alright.

I am the Cop who is capable of finding out about people's alignments, not their roles.

Lie detect that tonight if you like.

 

[Smart Marx]

Oh now I'm the Rolecop, alright.

I am the Cop who is capable of finding out about people's alignments, not their roles.

Lie detect that tonight if you like.

That's better.

Though, you could be the GF.

 

[Doddsy]

Why are people voting Barry?