Better Call Saul Mafia Game Thread

[Leon TrotSky]

I think tweet has cop as a safe fake

1) we had a desperado and if jeff is legit we have a lie detector. I assume he can't use it during day. that's already a good number of alignment confirming roles.
2) his strategy with a good role (watcher) last game was to ask for the watcher, he said this was to deter scum. he got janitored n1.
3) this game he softed a good role early, making him a n1 janitor target yet again. why do this tweet
4) his "plan" to look scummy made no sense and sounds like something he would've made up after realizing jeff was a lie detector and his safe wasn't so safe anymore and he might actually be in trouble

I raised points 1 and 2 earlier and he no-sold the post but was active at the time as he was replying to jeff

lynching him isn't as risky as it seems. saying this for reasons privy only to me at this time

If you're holding the reasons back, this better be good

 

[Doddsy]

ye but it wasn't the typical "show up as x aligned" miller iirc

Oh okay that changes thing. What kind has he said? Does it go with the lie detector?

 

[Doddsy]

Also did Tweet's soft come between him saying he was miller and then him giving more details about it?

 

[Rugrat]

Okay Doddsy:

Shawn claimed Miller stating that upon investigation he'd return an unfavourable result

Jeff claimed lie detector

Tweet claimed cop

The wording of Shawn's PM makes me more inclined to believe Jeff.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Who's a lie detector

Me

 

[Doddsy]

I can agree with that

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Who's a lie detector

Jeff claimed Lie Detector.

 

[Mitch Buchannon]

@Shawn I can’t divulge anything about my PR just that I have one


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Smart Marx]

If I wrote a miller fake, I'd probably say something like because I state Godfathers most of the time as always get a positive result.

It's to account for gunsmiths and things like that as well. So that miller wording could mean he'd have a false gun or whatever.

So entirely possibly they are both town, my only problem is why a second shot only if the first one is a true statement?

So if there's no cop, you get one guilty only, or three confirmed towns with the desperado?

 

[Doddsy]

I had a quick skim through Tweets posts, looks like the majority of his claiming cop came after Jeff claimed lie detector, but he was hinting at it much earlier than that. Is that right?

I also saw he was trying to get Jeff to lie detect him saying he's a cop, which I mean if he is actually a town cop then

 

[Rugrat]

If I wrote a miller fake, I'd probably say something like because I state Godfathers most of the time as always get a positive result.

It's to account for gunsmiths and things like that as well. So that miller wording could mean he'd have a false gun or whatever.

So entirely possibly they are both town, my only problem is why a second shot only if the first one is a true statement?

So if there's no cop, you get one guilty only, or three confirmed towns with the desperado?

So you'd write that claim if there was a gunsmith as the main town alignment checking role i.e. that would be your miller write up if there was no cop, the same as what's happening here.

 

[Rugrat]

I don't see the need for Jeff to claim the bizness about the second shot if he uses it correctly the first time (or at least I doubt he thinks about it), so I'm pretty sure he's legit.

 

[Smart Marx]

To assume that would be too assume scum was given a cop fake and I don't know if I like the idea of a host giving a cop safe fake.

 

[Tweet]

I wasn't exactly hinting at Cop in particular, I simply tried to avoid claiming outright by saying I'm not getting lynched in a bid to conceal my role at least for today. I mean when I say something like that the cat is already pretty much out of the bag but can't hurt to try. I was also trying to get Jeff to lie detect the statement that I am not the Cop to see if he was legit.

 

[Doddsy]

To assume that would be too assume scum was given a cop fake and I don't know if I like the idea of a host giving a cop safe fake.

I do disagree with that, nothing should ever not be given as a fake. If it's a real role it's up for grabs, nothing should be inherently confirmed town just based on role