Better Call Saul Mafia Game Thread

[Rugrat]

Even if I wasn’t feeling comfy in this thread, people remember I rarely claim on day 1 unless I believe the case has merit? I once took a day all the way to deadline and refused to claim.

I wasn’t after a claim, I was after a read

 

[Tweet]

This isn’t very good.

It’s six pages in. All reads will be somewhat weak so can be considered “token”.

Secondly if giving reads and pushing people for further reads is “scum Rugrat” what is “town Rugrat”?

My point is that trying to come up with reads during a time where you yourself admit there isn't really much on the table comes across as being for show. You never struck me as the kinda guy who cared too much about looking especially towny early on when you're actually town. Like I said, more of a gut thing.

 

[Smart Marx]

I wasn’t after a claim, I was after a read

Fair enough, but you need to see how I react to a half majority to get a read on me?

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

I don't think any of his reasoning is exactly lining up.

I think I'll stay on Rugrat for now.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Barry, smark, poyser. How do like tweets reasoning here?

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Barry, smark, poyser. How do like tweets reasoning here?

Better not ask questions like that or you'll be read scum! /s


For real, I think his reasoning makes sense. Rugrat isn't vain as town, he doesn't care enough to want to read hunt and do townie things.

 

[Poyser]

Even if I wasn’t feeling comfy in this thread, people remember I rarely claim on day 1 unless I believe the case has merit? I once took a day all the way to deadline and refused to claim.

This was as town tho, you wouldn’t do that as scum

 

[Tweet]

Also I think the early town reads for Poyser are very generous, Jeff in particular giving him a town lean this early on seems uncharacteristic, he's usually very careful around strong players and tends to mistrust them until he's got very good reasons to give them definitive town reads.

 

[Smart Marx]

This was as town tho, you wouldn’t do that as scum

Oh for sure, as scum I'd claim something. Maybe try to pretend I'm annoyed and bait for a minute first and then claim.

 

[Poyser]

Barry, smark, poyser. How do like tweets reasoning here?

Seems plausible from a town tweet, not sure I agree personally but it has merit. Rugrat’s early involvement as town is generally a case by case basis. I will say he’s active early when he’s scum pretty much every time he’s scum, but he’s been involved early as town plenty as well. The whole vote for a read is stuff I’ve seen countless times from him which is just why I’m not sold on it atm

 

[Rugrat]

My point is that trying to come up with reads during a time where you yourself admit there isn't really much on the table comes across as being for show. You never struck me as the kinda guy who cared too much about looking especially towny early on when you're actually town. Like I said, more of a gut thing.

“Never struck me as the kinda guy who cared too much about looking towny early on”?

This is nonsense to scum read me for. Odo caught me d1 because my scum meta was to actively not care about being town read. I haven’t been scum since I don’t believe.

Better not ask questions like that or you'll be read scum! /s


For real, I think his reasoning makes sense. Rugrat isn't vain as town, he doesn't care enough to want to read hunt and do townie things.

What? I don’t care to “read hunt” as town? I always make read lists lol. I also always play to my win condition which as town is to find the town and subsequently lynch the scum.

 

[Poyser]

Also I think the early town reads for Poyser are very generous, Jeff in particular giving him a town lean this early on seems uncharacteristic, he's usually very careful around strong players and tends to mistrust them until he's got very good reasons to give them definitive town reads.

Kinda agree with this, but also probably helped that I was reading him town which tends to make people wanna town read you back, especially early on

 

[Comrade Khan]

Also I think the early town reads for Poyser are very generous, Jeff in particular giving him a town lean this early on seems uncharacteristic, he's usually very careful around strong players and tends to mistrust them until he's got very good reasons to give them definitive town reads.

Im glad you mentioned it. You know what else poyser likes to do as scum though? Tear me apart and try to get me aggresively mislynched if he sees my case against someone is less than stellar. I also doubt he goes to bat for sky when she only has 1 vote on her tbh.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Right now my only town leans are Smark and Jeff.

Tweet and Poyser are null.

Sky is uneasy

And right now I'm trying to just figure out Rugrat.

Where I am right now. I know someone claimed miller, was it Mitch?

 

[Mitch Buchannon]

Currently leaning town on Jeff, Smark, Grim, Shawn, Poyser, and Tweet

Leaning scum on Sky

Big Man and Rugrat I'm undecided on