Best WrestleMania Elite 8: WrestleMania 21 vs WrestleMania XX

[Cwalker]

Well I think we got our next tournament

 

[Deezy]

forgot what I even voted for.

 

[Chris]

Well I think we got our next tournament

Someone beter post it in the thread before I make the poll or I'm gonna forget

 

[Chris]

20 moves on, makes my next round voting easier since I was really thinking about voting for 21 over X-Seven and you guys probably would have banned me for that : But now I get to vote X-Seven like everyone else until the finals so all is right with the world I guess.

 

[Smart Marx]

20 moves on, makes my next round voting easier since I was really thinking about voting for 21 over X-Seven and you guys probably would have banned me for that : But now I get to vote X-Seven like everyone else until the finals so all is right with the world I guess.

If you voted for 21 over 17 I'd have to consider it. 20 I'd be less conflicted about.

I have to be one of the only people that's very meh on 21. I don't get the appeal of it.

 

[Chris]

If you voted for 21 over 17 I'd have to consider it. 20 I'd be less conflicted about.

I have to be one of the only people that's very meh on 21. I don't get the appeal of it.

I mean I get the complaints about the main events which can def leave a bad taste in your mouth ending the show that way but you don't get the appeal of the MITB match, Angle/Shawn or Taker/Orton? Divas match sucked and Rey/Eddie was good but they've had wayyyyyy better. I also just like how it didn't have very many matches and just felt like a concise show that focused on what was good at the moment instead of trying to fit everyone on the card. I also don't mind super long cards but when comparing them, I usually go with the shorter card.

 

[Smart Marx]

I mean I get the complaints about the main events which can def leave a bad taste in your mouth ending the show that way but you don't get the appeal of the MITB match, Angle/Shawn or Taker/Orton? Divas match sucked and Rey/Eddie was good but they've had wayyyyyy better. I also just like how it didn't have very many matches and just felt like a concise show that focused on what was good at the moment instead of trying to fit everyone on the card. I also don't mind super long cards but when comparing them, I usually go with the shorter card.

Taker/Orton is soured in my eyes because Orton should have gone over. Don't @ me (I've had this debate so many times).

MITB is great, but I'm not going to rate this show particularly well for it when I've seen it done so many times in the past 15 years by now.

Angle/HBK is a good match, but there's just simply more going on in other Mania that trumps the one or two matches that I might fuck with.