Barry Presents: WS Mafia 3 "The Revival" Game Thread

[CakeWalker]

not sure what the problem is really. day 1 has minimal content and mostly just word salads - but from what i was able to dechiper i was confident Mando was town. Y'all can look back at countless game where I've refused to hammer - and someone has flipped town when I've also been town.

Its more comical that I was anyone's scum reads, when I only had one post. But I don't see the point of going into that, because Day 1 is just a workshop for everyone to explore on Day 2.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Ok juice , wtv then keep being cagey

 

[CakeWalker]

if you don't like my playstyle thats just a preference. Countless time my Day 1 spec has come off correct.

 

[The Gipper]

Shit. Alright, okay. I went back and took times for each vote on Day 1, just to see if there were potential trains/patterns and stuff. Separated the ones that happened in the same hour.

Spoiler: Day 1 vote times

Day 1 starts at 12:28am (my time so BST, convert it to your time if you want

T-Pein votes Sky at 5:07am
T-Pein unvotes and votes Jeff at 12:59pm

CP votes Jango at 4:45pm
Sky votes Juice at 4:48pm
CP unvotes and votes Man at 4:52pm
Tommy votes Juice at 4:54pm

Vote Count:
Jeff (1) - T-Pein
Juice (2) - Sky, Tommy
Man (1) - CP

Tommy unvotes and votes Blaine at 5:02pm
CP unvotes and votes Tommy at 5:06pm
Sky unvotes and votes Tommy at 5:08pm
Pendex votes Sky at 5:18pm

Gip votes Tommy at 6:11pm
Jeff votes Tommy at 6:57pm

Vote Count:

Jeff (1) - T-Pein
Blaine (1) - Tommy
Tommy (4) - CP, Sky, The Gipper, Jeff
Sky (1) - Pendex

Jeff unvotes Tommy and votes Man at 9:08pm
CP unvotes and votes Man at 9:34pm
Man votes Tommy at 9:42pm

Tommy unvotes and votes Man at 10:56pm
Sky unvotes and votes Man at 11:07pm

T-Pein unvotes and votes Tommy at 4:25am
T-Pein unvotes at 4:26am
Gip unvotes and votes Man at 4:47am
T-Pein unvotes and votes Tommy at 4:25am
T-Pein unvotes at 4:26am

T-Pein votes Tommy at 7:39am

Juice votes Blaine at 11:14am
Pendex votes Man at 11:17am


Vote Count:
Tommy (2) - Man, T-Pein
Sky (1) - Pendex
Man (6) - Jeff, CP, Tommy, Sky, Gip, Pendex
Blaine (1) - Juice

CP being near the start of both Tommy and Man lynch trains does bother me a small bit ngl.

 

[CakeWalker]

so i two votes after i had just one post. Interesting. good post. very town

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Not sure if I look like anything - I didn't want to hammer town.

How would you know he was town in advance

 

[T-Pein™]

You may post at night.

Please no night talk.
I want breaks.

 

[CraigPelton]

Shit. Alright, okay. I went back and took times for each vote on Day 1, just to see if there were potential trains/patterns and stuff. Separated the ones that happened in the same hour.

Spoiler: Day 1 vote times

Day 1 starts at 12:28am (my time so BST, convert it to your time if you want

T-Pein votes Sky at 5:07am
T-Pein unvotes and votes Jeff at 12:59pm

CP votes Jango at 4:45pm
Sky votes Juice at 4:48pm
CP unvotes and votes Man at 4:52pm
Tommy votes Juice at 4:54pm

Vote Count:
Jeff (1) - T-Pein
Juice (2) - Sky, Tommy
Man (1) - CP

Tommy unvotes and votes Blaine at 5:02pm
CP unvotes and votes Tommy at 5:06pm
Sky unvotes and votes Tommy at 5:08pm
Pendex votes Sky at 5:18pm

Gip votes Tommy at 6:11pm
Jeff votes Tommy at 6:57pm

Vote Count:

Jeff (1) - T-Pein
Blaine (1) - Tommy
Tommy (4) - CP, Sky, The Gipper, Jeff
Sky (1) - Pendex

Jeff unvotes Tommy and votes Man at 9:08pm
CP unvotes and votes Man at 9:34pm
Man votes Tommy at 9:42pm

Tommy unvotes and votes Man at 10:56pm
Sky unvotes and votes Man at 11:07pm

T-Pein unvotes and votes Tommy at 4:25am
T-Pein unvotes at 4:26am
Gip unvotes and votes Man at 4:47am
T-Pein unvotes and votes Tommy at 4:25am
T-Pein unvotes at 4:26am

T-Pein votes Tommy at 7:39am

Juice votes Blaine at 11:14am
Pendex votes Man at 11:17am


Vote Count:
Tommy (2) - Man, T-Pein
Sky (1) - Pendex
Man (6) - Jeff, CP, Tommy, Sky, Gip, Pendex
Blaine (1) - Juice

CP being near the start of both Tommy and Man lynch trains does bother me a small bit ngl.

Looking at votes without context isn't very useful. I was the first to suspect and push Mando, it's not like I just voted him because someone else did. He was a scum read.

 

[CraigPelton]

why are you preflipping Mando as town?
what the....

Why no issue with Juice assuming Mando is town before his flip?

 

[CraigPelton]

Aight I gotta step out

Vote: Mando

In case I'm dead tomorrow, kill Sky first, pressure Juice. I don't want to lynch Jeff, look into Blaine/T Pein etc before there.

So no matter what Mando flipped you wanted us to lynch Sky next?

 

[CraigPelton]

My problem with this is it would require scum to pivot from their chosen course for short term gain at best - it buys sky maybe a day? Like I'm struggling to see how Sky justifies surviving Night 1 eith a scum tommy day 1 flip.

I think it's more plausible that tommy and yoh are town, and Sky is scum - it also fits the behaviour wherein she's trying to find mislynches. Like with how she handled Tommy, it reeks of looking for a lynch without giving the slot wider consideration.

@Jeff why have you took Sky off the board today. I appreciate that we don't have 6 votes for her currently anyway, but we're not *that* far off either. For the record, I didn't sum up the Mando case as what Sky says, but specifically my scum read is pivoting to a lynch that they should have no incentive for before actually confirming their first suspicion - that's the issue I have with it.

If Sky is scum for trying to find mislynches, why did you hammer Mando and say lynch Sky next? What if Mando flipped scum? Surely Sky would be town by your logic...

 

[The Gipper]

Looking at votes without context isn't very useful. I was the first to suspect and push Mando, it's not like I just voted him because someone else did. He was a scum read.

Alright.

 

[T-Pein™]

Anyway I'm gonna be gone most of today so will have to reread things later tonight

Why would I lynch the guy who I was pretty much agreeing on everything with?
And vote with my main susses?
This guy...

 

[T-Pein™]

Why no issue with Juice assuming Mando is town before his flip?

Because she wasn't saying he was scum and trying to lynch him?
Obviously town reading if she didn't wanna hammer.
What's with these dumb questions?

 

[CakeWalker]

Thinking someone is scum - for town reading someone is always confusing. Really quesiton - is why would people thinkg he was scum