Barry Presents: Whodunnit 2: The West Smithton Sagas GAME THREAD

[Smart Marx]

vote tweet

vote tweet

Vote Tweet

I feel like I get why Odo jumped over to Tweet, but I’d like to hear Banez and Rugrat why they jumped on the wagon so fast. Why do you feel he’s the choice here?

 

[Smart Marx]

Why tho?

Good question. I’d like to hear some reasons.

 

[Smart Marx]

Oh I’m Big Man, I forgot about that

Good to know.

So you didn’t go anywhere?

 

[Smart Marx]

Yes, I think we should lynch tweet

I’m not overly a fan of his play this game, but in light of Poyser’s flip, you’re given pause to maybe Tweet just not being confident in his reads?

Or you got a gut feeling based on day 2 play as well?

 

[Smart Marx]

Heading swiftly towards a no lynch here i think we have an hour ? Votes on banez would be good

nvm just checked we have longer for some reason i thought day was 18 hrs, still should probably get some votes on given time zones

Why would day be 18 hours?

Any reason for a rush to lynch Banez if there had only been an hour?

 

[Smart Marx]

magic why claim under no pressure

Feels weird, but I’d like to think scum Magic is more careful.

 

[Smart Marx]

Hmm it does appear that the woe is me attitude is also a scum tell. will look at current game for evidence of this.

And he's provided it in spades. Also the sheep reference too

Didn’t we make this mistake a couple of games ago?

 

[Lethal]

Is there a frame of reference for this belief?

He's asking for a replacement, yet it was the janitor kill. Asking for a rep in the thread isn't something I see a scum Jeff doing, he could do it safely in a QT. Unnecessary call to attention on his part.

 

[Odo]

What do you think smark?

 

[Lethal]

That’s a pretty quick claim.

Not filled with confidence over a tracker claim.

I do like picking someone who’s not been playing to see if there role is being used, though.

Tracker claims always make me very cautious, and the usage seems very safe with BigMan not being around to post/dispute/suss him on it.

I'm almost wishing to get Rugrat to claim to compare apples and oranges, but I'm after the sweet raspberry of a wild Tweets in my sights.

 

[Odo]

Lethal, a tip:

you don’t town read folk for that stuff. Magic did it because he had role related reasons to read Rugrat town, but didn’t want to make it clear it was for a role so he had to go with whatever bullshit was at hand

 

[Smart Marx]

He's asking for a replacement, yet it was the janitor kill. Asking for a rep in the thread isn't something I see a scum Jeff doing, he could do it safely in a QT. Unnecessary call to attention on his part.

He could do it a QT, but I don’t think scum are incapable of simply asking for reps for people not playing in the thread. Just to look like they care.

 

[RDK]

Why would day be 18 hours?

Any reason for a rush to lynch Banez if there had only been an hour?

Could have sworn i saw it saw 18 hours when he posted the flip yesterday

Well I think he is scum and dont want a no lynch

 

[Odo]

@Showtime why do you think Tweet is scum?

@Mr.Tweetums you should claim

 

[Lethal]

Tweets distanced on Poyser, he's non-committal to anything of substance.

There's also this:

Magic is another guy we could wagon but it's sort of a fools errand since I'm inclined to believe he really is preoccupied with other stuff, plus there's been nothing scummy about his game that I could find, just a whole lotta nothing.

I mean, further distancing? He's got a nice comfy seat on that fence, pushing those papers.

Lethal, a tip:

you don’t town read folk for that stuff. Magic did it because he had role related reasons to read Rugrat town, but didn’t want to make it clear it was for a role so he had to go with whatever bullshit was at hand

He could do it a QT, but I don’t think scum are incapable of simply asking for reps for people not playing in the thread. Just to look like they care.

True, but from my experience with Jeff, he's not going to draw that radar to himself unnecessarily which is what that did when it was pretty quickly pointed out she was janitored.

Vote: Tweets