Barry Presents: Whodunnit 2: The West Smithton Sagas GAME THREAD

[Odo]

Explain why the hammer makes you think i'm scum, please

Seems flimsy so I look forward to hearing your reasoning

you sure you wanna do this?

I mean, you’re poking the bear here

 

[Tweet]

Yay etc

 

[Comrade Khan]

The only reason to think Haza is town is the outrageous buddying he and Poyser did without ever really addressing one another

like it’s too obvious, that’s why I ruled it out. It wasn’t like anyone had to convince Haza to hammer either, and I don’t recall seeing any progression from ‘will not lynch’

this part, however, I do agree with

 

[RDK]

you sure you wanna do this?

I mean, you’re poking the bear here

why not,

If you're scum reading me I want to hear why.

If it's that my town read on Poyser was misplaced then that's something I recognize is in play now, if it's something else then I want to hear it.

 

[Odo]

Nah, idrc about you thinking Poyser was town, I care more about the point of mine Jeff bolded

 

[Odo]

Anyway Jeff, sky and smark move into the town column, Tweet gets no sympy as can easily see day 1 being some concocted distancing horseshit

 

[RDK]

Nah, idrc about you thinking Poyser was town, I care more about the point of mine Jeff bolded

the progression was fairly obvious and my town read on him became "who gives a fuck" as soon as he voted for himself

I asked if he could be repped before remembering we had to cut a spot from the game so there were none

No issues lynching someone that isn't playing to their wincon

 

[Leon TrotSky]

the progression was fairly obvious and my town read on him became "who gives a fuck" as soon as he voted for himself

I asked if he could be repped before remembering we had to cut a spot from the game so there were none

No issues lynching someone that isn't playing to their wincon

Why didn't you hammer before you did, in that case?

 

[Odo]

the progression was fairly obvious and my town read on him became "who gives a fuck" as soon as he voted for himself

I asked if he could be repped before remembering we had to cut a spot from the game so there were none

No issues lynching someone that isn't playing to their wincon

weak, no buys

 

[Odo]

@Alco @Big Man come on out lads

 

[RDK]

weak, no buys

cool bro

 

[Odo]

Oh ye OMB town too

 

[Comrade Khan]

I literally just won a scum game 2 days ago from 10-2 because I bussed two of my four teammates. If you think my not voting Poyser is alignment indicative you just don't know me or my meta or you're ignoring it

Why would you think a game on perk would be relevant to anyone here? Also talking about your own meta is generally a bad defence.

Just dont see it. Poyser is active (invested), was slow to claim and is a tier 1 player. It wouldn't make sense for anyone to bus him and I dont think he would be supportive of that idea of a scummate doing it.

I think IF he is scum (I don't think he is) then it's likely everyone on that wagon is town.

If you are scum, this post makes you look like you are trying to hide the fact there is bus going on.

I'm not convinced in lynching poyser now for info on his wagon that will still be there if he flipped later. If you think he is scum then thats another thing

why is info later better than info now? Again this is bad reasoning to not lynch someone.

can we just get a rep for him then?

If he is town he can go fuck himself

vote: poyser

The "progression" , can also easily be explained by poyser saying fuckit I'm done, get some distancing. Or, maybe it is indeed banez and you, and Poyser just said fuck you guys I'm going home in frustration because he couldn't make reasonable/beleivable interactions with either of you....

Actually I think I want a claim from Poyser, I got a theory of what might be going on.

vote Poyser

@Mr.Tweetums care to share now (if you haven't already)

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

Def feel like Smark is maf now maybe feel little better on mitch for rn

 

[Comrade Khan]

Def feel like Smark is maf now maybe feel little better on mitch for rn

has smark not been on Poyser all day? In that case, I'm assuming you think he was bussing him?