Barry Presents: Whodunnit 2: The West Smithton Sagas GAME THREAD

[Kim Jong Umb]

I'm interested in this read, do tell.

call it a gut feeling I just dont like his post right now at all. I feel like while he may have voted for Poyser I dont think he is town granted I very easily could be wrong but, I think he isn't being genuine

 

[Comrade Khan]

huh

 

[Tweet]

I feel like Mitch did a good job of saying nothing in that reads list tbh

Can't say I agree, for one thing I think he has opinions on people, like clear opinions instead of caveated two-faced reads. They're not super well-reasoned reads but that's not something I expect out of Mitch anyway.

 

[NotBrutus]

Tbh @NotBrutus I can't really say but I wouldn't put it past him to do it if he is mafia personally I think Poyser/Smark/Mitch are high scum reads. I put Tweetums & Darth as slight leans as well.

I'm confused. I said who from his null reads do you think is scum, and then you proceed to name his indy reads

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Can't say I agree, for one thing I think he has opinions on people, like clear opinions instead of caveated two-faced reads. They're not super well-reasoned reads but that's not something I expect out of Mitch anyway.

Yeah his reasons were pretty much meaningless but he's not exactly sitting on the fence.

Still interested to know what is with scum reading KIF for just doing KIF things? Is Mitch able to translate his nonsense into actual mafia gameplay?

 

[Odo]

Indy reads

 

[Poyser]

Can't say I agree, for one thing I think he has opinions on people, like clear opinions instead of caveated two-faced reads. They're not super well-reasoned reads but that's not something I expect out of Mitch anyway.

Lol he had like half of the game yellow or red and another quarter of them null his town reads were literally just “seems Town”

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

I said I Couldn't really say on the null part I just wouldn't put it past him @NotBrutus but that is all riding on if he flips maf.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Thoughts on mitch @Odo now that we've gotten a bit more out of the lad

 

[NotBrutus]

I said I Couldn't really say on the null part I just wouldn't put it past him @NotBrutus but that is all riding on if he flips maf.

Hmmm okay, fair fair

 

[Odo]

I don’t really have any based on those reads? He’s opposed to Poyser so I’d say town but don’t really know what you’re expecting here lol

 

[Smart Marx]

I really feel like Mitch is the easy target and you're letting Poyser slip right through your palms.

Mitch never really does much as town, anyway, so to get a strong read on him at this stage is just deflection.

 

[Smart Marx]

Lol he had like half of the game yellow or red and another quarter of them null his town reads were literally just “seems Town”

Just to humor you for a minute, what are you expecting from Mitch on day 1 as far as a reads list goes?

 

[Odo]

I’d still be lynching Poyser and then seeing where we’re at. Going to trust my instincts

 

[Smart Marx]

Can't say I agree, for one thing I think he has opinions on people, like clear opinions instead of caveated two-faced reads. They're not super well-reasoned reads but that's not something I expect out of Mitch anyway.

On day 1 to have legit reads at all is pretty good to me.