Barry Presents: Whodunnit 2: The West Smithton Sagas GAME THREAD

[Smart Marx]

This archaic, blood-thirsty pushing based on ? reasons is why town have fucked up so many times in the past, choosing not to actually analyse posts or play, but pushing their own selfish agendas and bias.

Also, I have zero biased reasons for this. The wagon on Poyser is 100% based on this game.

A town Poyser is worth having around if I felt that was a strong enough possibility, but I don't.

 

[Lethal]

Frst,

Secondly, post above yours.

* You don't need Poyser's flip to gain a read on Sky. You say it yourself here that it is suicide.

* Taking anything KIF says seriously

* He's not exactly wrong and it's something to consider. You know, past history of being able to nab people off one post. I speak from experience.

 

[Smart Marx]

* You don't need Poyser's flip to gain a read on Sky. You say it yourself here that it is suicide.

* Taking anything KIF says seriously

* He's not exactly wrong and it's something to consider. You know, past history of being able to nab people off one post. I speak from experience.

Poyser being scum changes that Sky point completely.

 

[Lethal]

I've taken Tweet's flip-flopping into consideration every time he's done it, but your flip gives it the proper contextual clues.

Mitch's push feel inorganic to me so I can't take it seriously if I feel you're the bigger threat at play rn.

What contextual clues does it provide?

Inorganic? How so? Sure, Poyser is a HUGE threat, but you're not even remotely entertaining anything he has said in regards to the case. Ok, we lynch Poyser and then what? he flips town and we're down a strong player on D1. Not the start I want.

 

[Lethal]

Poyser being scum changes that Sky point completely.

Fair, but I highly doubt she has the ovaries to try and pull that off knowing it'll turkey slap her if he's scum. I also doubt he lets it happen.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Skybox is a town lean. She's not trying to be the town leader or pushing her agendas. It's low-level interactions but I feel they are genuine. I stress the importance of lean before your tampon gets twisted and you have a rant when/if I modify this lean

I'm going to say it right now: Scum Lethal.

He gets his shots in, he seeks out reasons to sus me... then he gives me a town lean? That's not Town Lethal's MO. We established in a game earlier this year (don't remember which, but it was definitely a game from when things were still open) that he plays to his meta of shading me at every opportunity as any alignment, but as scum he really doesn't follow through with it.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Also... people thinking I'd bus Poyser if we were scum together.

 

[Lethal]

I have returned, let me catch up.

also why is Lethal saying I'm defending Mitch? I questioned the genuineness of Poyser's read on him, because he had one post at the time. That's hardly defending the guy lol

It just seemed very.....not Jeff like. At least not a town Jeff.

 

[Smart Marx]

* You don't need Poyser's flip to gain a read on Sky. You say it yourself here that it is suicide.

* Taking anything KIF says seriously

* He's not exactly wrong and it's something to consider. You know, past history of being able to nab people off one post. I speak from experience.

I don't feel his push on Mitch was genuine. It honestly seems like clutched at someone the first chance he got to relieve pressure and he saw Mitch's post. So he dived immediately on him off oe post and then didn't provide anything until called out on it. A town Poyser doesn't need to be pushed into providing a legit case on someone he thought needed to be pushed. I'm just saying, it fails the smell test for me.

 

[Lethal]

I'm going to say it right now: Scum Lethal.

He gets his shots in, he seeks out reasons to sus me... then he gives me a town lean? That's not Town Lethal's MO. We established in a game earlier this year (don't remember which, but it was definitely a game from when things were still open) that he plays to his meta of shading me at every opportunity as any alignment, but as scum he really doesn't follow through with it.

Fuck off you stupid rodent. I'm done getting sucked in to engaging with you in every fucking game, yet here you are again spewing absolute garbage trash. People can evolve in game play. I have bigger fish to fry and can do without the distraction. What do I achieve by tunneling you game after game after game? A bad reputation and you popping in my notifications. Piss off you zit.

 

[Lethal]

I don't feel his push on Mitch was genuine. It honestly seems like clutched at someone the first chance he got to relieve pressure and he saw Mitch's post. So he dived immediately on him off oe post and then didn't provide anything until called out on it. A town Poyser doesn't need to be pushed into providing a legit case on someone he thought needed to be pushed. I'm just saying, it fails the smell test for me.

I appreciate you explaining your thought process. Thanks

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Fuck off you stupid rodent. I'm done getting sucked in to engaging with you in every fucking game, yet here you are again spewing absolute garbage trash. People can evolve in game play. I have bigger fish to fry and can do without the distraction. What do I achieve by tunneling you game after game after game? A bad reputation and you popping in my notifications. Piss off you zit.

And they say I'm easily triggered.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

also why is Lethal saying I'm defending Mitch? I questioned the genuineness of Poyser's read on him, because he had one post at the time. That's hardly defending the guy lol

I'm also confused by this. Questioning the reason behind Poyser's read would surely have more to do with, you know, suspicion of Poyser (as has been the running theme this game) rather than defense of Mitch.

 

[Smart Marx]

What contextual clues does it provide?

Inorganic? How so? Sure, Poyser is a HUGE threat, but you're not even remotely entertaining anything he has said in regards to the case. Ok, we lynch Poyser and then what? he flips town and we're down a strong player on D1. Not the start I want.

If Poyser is scum, Tweet could just be town going back and forth on a read as a scum to scum interaction wouldn't be that awkward.

If Poyser is town, Tweet's flip-flopping comes off far more strange and off-putting to me and would then require further pushing.

I explained above, but he basically grasped at the first thing he could to move the spotlight and rushed at the chance to push Mitch's post.

Without really saying anything with that first vote. That idea isn't doing it for me.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Fluff

I had to flag this up. Calling me on fluff? During what to everyone except Poyser was the fluff phase? Really?