Barry Presents: Whodunnit 2: The West Smithton Sagas GAME THREAD

[Tweet]

except you’re a notorious busser and quite routinely get worried about looking bad off the back of your teammates to the point of trying to get ahead of the danger and wagoning them early. This is something you do basically every single time you’re scum. Not to mention you’re just straight up bullshitting about not being worried about “me in particular” when I’ve probably caught you more than anybody else lmao

Well there's no use denying any of this. I wish I'd draw scum some more so I could work out those flaws but oh well. Doesn't change that I just detailed my thought process which you ignored in this instance in favour of believing what you wanna believe and talking about how great you are instead.

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

You mean the wagon I basically started? And still have a vote on?

It's called getting reads out of people. At this point on the wagon scum are gonna try to quietly hop on it.

Because mafia have never voted early on someone to sway innocence I mean if Poyser is mafia and you are to throwing a vote and if he survives another day or whenever a flip does turn you can turn around and say look I voted him first I was the one that got it started you play the long game

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Why would it? If you're scum and looking like an obvious lynch, teammates will have no choice but to go wow you guys are right time to vote Poyser in time for the scum flip.

Do they really? I think they'd value his ability too much.

 

[Poyser]

Pretty sure I’ve flattened Tweet more than anyone

please continue

In terms of numbers idk u may be right but pretty sure I’ve caught him every single time we’ve played me town and him scum lol

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Maybe they’re already on it and just waiting for the townies to give up and hop on!

So that would make some combination of Smark, Odo, me, and Tweet all scum to you?

 

[Smart Marx]

The thing is they're not quietly hopping on it, so... Says something, doesn't it?

By quietly I mean no real substance in the votes. Like OMB's I don't like his insult game even though he does that as town all the time.

 

[Poyser]

OMB bussing Poyser so he can carry home the Maf victory. Flawless strategy

 

[Smart Marx]

The thing is they're not quietly hopping on it, so... Says something, doesn't it?

Wait, what are you implying here? You think he's town?

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Wait, what are you implying here? You think he's town?

No, I'm implying that they don't want to lynch an important teammate early on.

 

[Poyser]

So that would make some combination of Smark, Odo, me, and Tweet all scum to you?

Well Mitch and tweet are on me and there’s 2 of my scum reads right there.
But you asked what does it say, I’m just giving you a possibility that you may not have considered!

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

No, I'm implying that they don't want to lynch an important teammate early on.

I didn't mean to like the post was trying to quote the message lol

 

[Smart Marx]

Because mafia have never voted early on someone to sway innocence I mean if Poyser is mafia and you are to throwing a vote and if he survives another day or whenever a flip does turn you can turn around and say look I voted him first I was the one that got it started you play the long game

This completely conflicts with your earlier trying to sway the direction. Looks like you're inventing reasons to scum read me.

 

[Poyser]

Well there's no use denying any of this. I wish I'd draw scum some more so I could work out those flaws but oh well. Doesn't change that I just detailed my thought process which you ignored in this instance in favour of believing what you wanna believe and talking about how great you are instead.

No I did comment on it and said I don’t think it really messes with reality. His second post was more nothing and I don’t know what you wanted me to say about it or what there was to jump on, I was waiting for him to react to my vote you’re right but he didn’t and I also got caught up trying to defend myself. But me not replying to one post doesn’t really equal me not pushing him when I continued talking about him the entire time which is why I don’t really believe your explanation of thought process

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

This completely conflicts with your earlier trying to sway the direction. Looks like you're inventing reasons to scum read me.

Mafia can't do both?

 

[Smart Marx]

OMB bussing Poyser so he can carry home the Maf victory. Flawless strategy

Seems dumb, but OMB's reasoning has been off.