Barry Presents: Whodunnit 2: The West Smithton Sagas GAME THREAD

[Mitch Buchannon]

1. Jeffatron - Jeff still feels town to me, he's stayed in his comfort zone versus when he's maf I feel he tries different risky plays
2. Big Man/Rugrat - Rugrat has been his trolly self, which seems like town Rugrat
4. Judas Iscariot - still feeling good about OMB, I believe his VT claim
5. Mitch Perfect - I know I'm town
6. Odo - despite leading the lynch on Haza I'm still feeling good on Odo, he's been a good town leader this game
7. PHEN0M - only now N0M is starting to make his presence more known but I'm still not liking his posts, I'm leaning more mafia or indy on him
8. Showtime - Magic claimed tracker and
9. Alco/Haza - hasn't posted a whole lot since he was repped back in, still unsure
10. Darth Lethal - still not feeling good about Lethal, when he's town I feel he's a lot more vocal
11. Banez - bumped up to totally leaning maf on Banez, he has played a pretty scummy game
12. Mr.Tweetums - Tweet claimed mason and I'm feeling pretty good about him as town
14. Uncle Larry - my feelings about KIF are known, he has to be mafia
15. NotBrutus - not feeling good on Brutus, I had him leaning town but his post-lynch post didn't sit right with me so I'm leaning more mafia
17. Broken God - I still feel he's played a pretty town game, nothing's changed

 

[PHEN0M]

N0M suddenly coming alive as the number of people who wanna POE him rather soon slowly increases

This is a dumb take.

 

[PHEN0M]

1. Jeffatron - Jeff still feels town to me, he's stayed in his comfort zone versus when he's maf I feel he tries different risky plays
2. Big Man/Rugrat - Rugrat has been his trolly self, which seems like town Rugrat
4. Judas Iscariot - still feeling good about OMB, I believe his VT claim
5. Mitch Perfect - I know I'm town
6. Odo - despite leading the lynch on Haza I'm still feeling good on Odo, he's been a good town leader this game
7. PHEN0M - only now N0M is starting to make his presence more known but I'm still not liking his posts, I'm leaning more mafia or indy on him
8. Showtime - Magic claimed tracker and
9. Alco/Haza - hasn't posted a whole lot since he was repped back in, still unsure
10. Darth Lethal - still not feeling good about Lethal, when he's town I feel he's a lot more vocal
11. Banez - bumped up to totally leaning maf on Banez, he has played a pretty scummy game
12. Mr.Tweetums - Tweet claimed mason and I'm feeling pretty good about him as town
14. Uncle Larry - my feelings about KIF are known, he has to be mafia
15. NotBrutus - not feeling good on Brutus, I had him leaning town but his post-lynch post didn't sit right with me so I'm leaning more mafia
17. Broken God - I still feel he's played a pretty town game, nothing's changed

What don’t you like about them out of curiosity? Don’t skimp on the details.

 

[Mitch Buchannon]

What don’t you like about them out of curiosity? Don’t skimp on the details.

Very fluffy posts at first. Your recent posts came off as "get in the thread and make some better posts N0M" so you could cover your bases.

 

[Lethal]

My theory was that SK and scum both shot Sky. And if that’s the case, then I’m inclined to give Lethal a town read based off of their N1 argument

Why would both entities shoot low-level fruit? Why do I get a town read from it?

 

[Lethal]

Did Mitch ever end up claiming btw? I need to do a claims list. Looking at this list, I def. agree that KIF should be shot. We already got a claim off banez, so we would be voting to lynch. I would start with Mitch/Nom/Kif d3 before circling back to others.

nope, the lynch went back to Poyser and was carried through to a result.

 

[Lethal]

I Claimed as well I dont think we need mass claims yet tho not sure how I feel saying to shot kif yet I get he hasn't really posted but seems to me that's it's a easy to go him granted he could be maf.

Odo/Tweetum/Mitch/Lethal though I think there might be one or two mafia in there and I haven't ruled out that possibility that smark is maf.

You're wanting to keep KIF around for ? reasons who hasn't even registered a vote, and you're suspect of Smark who was integral in the lynch of Poyser? Why do you think Smark is scum? Don't skip details

 

[Lethal]

10. Darth Lethal - still not feeling good about Lethal, when he's town I feel he's a lot more vocal

Wow, this is genius insight for a read. Needless paper pushing to appear as though you're contributing.

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

I just think it is a easy out I'm not saying hes town or mafia idk just feels like it's a way out

 

[Lethal]

I just think it is a easy out I'm not saying hes town or mafia idk just feels like it's a way out

He's offering nothing though. Cannot read him, not voting, not contributing. Why keep him around?

You also skipped that reasoning on Smark

 

[RDK]

pretty busy this weekend but will be as active as possible if I'm alive when day breaks

 

[PHEN0M]

Very fluffy posts at first. Your recent posts came off as "get in the thread and make some better posts N0M" so you could cover your bases.

So how I’ve played every game over the past 2 months, got it.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

2 1/2 Hours to Get Your Powers In...​

 

[Lethal]

Updated for the end of Day 2. Yellow is the hammer vote.

 

[Lethal]

Reads:

Jeffatron
Big Man Rugrat
Judas Iscariot
Mitch Perfect
Odo
PHEN0M
Showtime
Alco Haza 2.0
Darth Lethal
Banez
Mr.Tweetums
Uncle Larry
NotBrutus
Broken God

Town Read / Town Lean / Fence (Null) / Scum Lean / Scummier Lean / Scum