AEW Dynamite Mafia Game Thread

[Doddsy]

I'm assuming scum have a down is protective role that will counteract mine, to double protect someone and leave them open I assume is the design.

It's not necessarily a bg, specific is a protective role so open to more. I'm slightly confused by how it works tbh

 

[RDK]

Ok yeah then I don’t really buy it at all

Also my memory for this game is shit but also pretty sure he was nowhere near as gung ho on lynching lethal yesterday as he is today right?

WRT smark it’s a weird one because I know he does the asking questions thing as town as well but reading back end of day it didn’t really feel genuine and I don’t think anybody really gave him the case on lethal in order to vote him did they? And yet he voted anyway and I’m pretty sure smark has refused to vote people just to avoid a no lynch before so yeah just doesn’t feel like town smark to me

So you think it looks worse for Smark if Lethal turns out to be town? Do you think Lethal/Smark could ever be S/S considering he did vote rather than refusing?

 

[Odo]

Yes but i'm not talking about a town BG. I'm talking about you saying it's not likely there is a scum bodyguard. Which will be interesting later if someone flips BG and are scum.

but indirectly you are. If you assume Doddsy is legit, then you also assume there’s a bodyguard or jailkeeper in the game. I’m saying that having both of those be town seems OP, and if they are cross faction, then the faith healer being scum makes far more sense from a design perspective than the opposite

I too would be very ‘interested’ if there was now a scum bodyguard

 

[Evans]

@Chloe B you voted me because I faked something.

can you finally respond to what I supposedly faked please?

 

[RDK]

but indirectly you are. If you assume Doddsy is legit, then you also assume there’s a bodyguard or jailkeeper in the game. I’m saying that having both of those be town seems OP, and if they are cross faction, then the faith healer being scum makes far more sense from a design perspective than the opposite

I too would be very ‘interested’ if there was now a scum bodyguard

Poyser said:
Well, the BG could be scum tbf

I mean I guess, but that seems to be more like a Barry design than a Jeff one lol

I didn't read what you said as being "both of those being town seems OP"

I read it as, "no Poyser there probably ain't a scum BG for these raisons"

perhaps I just misinterpreted.

 

[Odo]

I mean to clarify

it’s possible that Doddsy is town and that there is a scum protection role. It’s also possible that Doddsy is town, there’s a scum protection role and another town protection role, but then it starts to get silly

 

[RDK]

I mean to clarify

it’s possible that Doddsy is town and that there is a scum protection role. It’s also possible that Doddsy is town, there’s a scum protection role and another town protection role, but then it starts to get silly

Lol I think that's the point of role madness games. Thanks for clarifying.

Do you think Lethal throws in the towel like this as scum?

 

[Alco]

Are there buys for Lethal's watcher claim? I'd like Tweet to come in as well tbh

 

[Odo]

Lol I think that's the point of role madness games. Thanks for clarifying.

Do you think Lethal throws in the towel like this as scum?

I think it’s very plausible, yes, although it seems he has now unthrown the towel, so I’ll make up mymind after tweet responds

 

[RDK]

Are there buys for Lethal's watcher claim? I'd like Tweet to come in as well tbh

Lethal claimed watcher?

 

[Odo]

Lol I think that's the point of role madness games. Thanks for clarifying.

Do you think Lethal throws in the towel like this as scum?

I do kinda have a shitty raisin to believe it

 

[Odo]

Uh that reply was meant for Alco

 

[Chloe B]

@Chloe B you voted me because I faked something.

can you finally respond to what I supposedly faked please?

I was wrong because I don't remember saying it but looking back I in fact said which is weird because I don't remember thinking it

Oh well, sorry buddy

Still think a staunch defence of Tweet is sus

 

[RDK]

Well one of the flips IIRC had multiple roles so it's not like it's out of the realms of possibility. Passive and Active makes it more believable too. I still think he is probably scum on play though and likely trying to milk the rest of his usage before the inevitable.

 

[Chloe B]

Are there buys for Lethal's watcher claim? I'd like Tweet to come in as well tbh

Might as well lynch Tweet then lynch Lethal if the info is no good

Hes gonna die either way anyway