AEW Dynamite: Beach Break- January 26th 2022

[Comrade Khan]

It's literally just the breaking of a scale that's the issue lol it makes 5 not mean shit anymore

well it means something, just not that its the best. its pretty easy tbh

 

[Hoss]

Again, I'm not trying to take away from the match. It's the scale that's the problem.

 

[Comrade Khan]

5 just means he thinks its a standardly very good excellent match. but its not the best, dont even think he knows what that is at this point. but if if u like similar things than him, its a pretty easy baseline to understand, imo

 

[Marty McFourth]

sammy pretty much the worst at no selling all the time but im giving hi ma pass cuz cody didnt sell shit either lol

Yeah, they both kinda went from spot to spot, and whilst I loved it. I can see why others have issue with that. Selling wise, there wasn't a lot in that match to be fair.

 

[Hoss]

As far as I'm concerned, this match was a 3.5 anytime before 2018

 

[Chris]

well it means something, just not that its the best. its pretty easy tbh

But like what does it mean if he gives something 4.75, 5, or 5.25 on this scale? Those are now virtually identical to me now when 4.75 vs 5 meant something before

 

[Hidden Blaze]

Maybe Uncle Dave needs Riddle to come calibrate his a scale

 

[Hidden Blaze]

His scale *

 

[Comrade Khan]

like no one would have a consistent scale (even if they didnt break it) without breakign consistency over 20 years so i think its best to just see it as 4+ is good 5+ is must see and the rest of the details are pretty subjective.

 

[Comrade Khan]

But like what does it mean if he gives something 4.75, 5, or 5.25 on this scale? Those are now virtually identical to me now when 4.75 vs 5 meant something before

the better question is who cares

 

[Chris]

5 just means he thinks its a standardly very good excellent match. but its not the best, dont even think he knows what that is at this point. but if if u like similar things than him, its a pretty easy baseline to understand, imo

I always agree on his ratings when I compare them to the same show usually, so thats always been my rule. His highest rated match on a show usually my favorite, etc. Comparing show to show and company to company especially just ain't it tho

 

[Comrade Khan]

its an opinion scale

 

[Hoss]

There's not even a cap on the current scale. It's just go as high as he feels like. So basically no number means anything. Man could give a match a fucking 10 tomorrow and that would just be that

 

[Chris]

the better question is who cares

us apparently

 

[Hoss]

the better question is who cares

A lot of people honestly. And it's relevant enough that you shared that info.