AEW All Out Live Discussion Thread: Sunday September 4th, 2023 Live on PPV

[Ricky Smarks]

I do think the Omega match has the best build and honestly that Don promo really elevated it. Takeshita needs to be on those areas Don setup for him.

It’s not a title match, but they should maybe make that the main if there’s no world title match.

 

[Ricky Smarks]

I get it though it's kind of like when I went to Toronto for the first Canadian show and they didn't have the elite or punk. show was great but i went in a bit bummed

Without getting into the specifics I’ll be honest not seeing Punk is a huge letdown. It was half the reason of specifically going to Chicago for an AEW show.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Without getting into the specifics I’ll be honest not seeing Punk is a huge letdown. It was half the reason of specifically going to Chicago for an AEW show.

yeah I totally understand. situation sucks

 

[Roy Mustang]

Glad it’s not just me. I’m gonna have a good time being in Chicago live, regardless, for sure, but does make me think this is what Battle of the Belts should have been rather than a PPV.

Probably the draw of this card for me is seeing Jay White and his BCG live against a weird teamup of Bucks and FTR.

Just weird AEW has essentially three world titles in the AEW, real and ROH and they didn’t book any on this show. I understand the Punk situation and don’t get me wrong that frustrates me too not seeing him in Chicago when I flew out there, but then book the ROH title to make up for it. Chicago loves Kingston.

Yeah I'm hyped for the 8-man as the other two FTR and Bucks teaming up tags were underrated bangers (especially the 12 man vs the Dark Order one). I feel like Claudio vs Kingston makes the most sense here. Honestly Mox vs OC should be the main event as it is the match with the most hype by far.

I actually don’t mind the 4-man as I’m gonna pop for it, but I do feel a Jay singles match with an elite member would have been vastly better.

I also think when Punk couldn’t be there, they absolutely should have pivoted and ran Cole/MJF back at All Out. The build is already there. Booking a rematch on Dynamite would have been easy.

See I disagree with doing the Cole/MJF rematch so soon. I think you take your time with that. Now doing Strong vs MJF makes sense to me.


Remember when British podcasters claimed All In was a stepping stone to All Out? :. Never felt more justified to call people whiners than right now cause this a B PPV card

 

[Ricky Smarks]

Yeah I'm hyped for the 8-man as the other two FTR and Bucks teaming up tags were underrated bangers (especially the 12 man vs the Dark Order one). I feel like Claudio vs Kingston makes the most sense here. Honestly Mox vs OC should be the main event as it is the match with the most hype by far.



See I disagree with doing the Cole/MJF rematch so soon. I think you take your time with that. Now doing Strong vs MJF makes sense to me.


Remember when British podcasters claimed All In was a stepping stone to All Out? :. Never felt more justified to call people whiners than right now cause this a B PPV card

You know, I’d have loved that, too.

I’m a huge Strong mark so him getting a title shot live would have been aces.

 

[Roy Mustang]

You know, I’d have loved that, too.

I’m a huge Strong mark so him getting a title shot live would have been aces.

See I've always rated him in the ring but outside the ring minus that one time in Progress he got "SHITTY LITTLE BOOTS" chants I've not given a single fuck. Generic white guy was an apt description. But him turning a whiny little bitch has made me so into it and he is a god in the ring too. Him vs MJF when it happens will be a banger

 

[Ricky Smarks]

See I've always rated him in the ring but outside the ring minus that one time in Progress he got "SHITTY LITTLE BOOTS" chants I've not given a single fuck. Generic white guy was an apt description. But him turning a whiny little bitch has made me so into it and he is a god in the ring too. Him vs MJF when it happens will be a banger

Probably Grand Slam. Seems to be Tony’s focus now.

Which will bang when it happens. Roddy entered the tournament. I assume he’ll win it.

 

[Ricky Smarks]

See I've always rated him in the ring but outside the ring minus that one time in Progress he got "SHITTY LITTLE BOOTS" chants I've not given a single fuck. Generic white guy was an apt description. But him turning a whiny little bitch has made me so into it and he is a god in the ring too. Him vs MJF when it happens will be a banger

Normally I need charisma too but I’ve always loved him since his ROH days.

I agree his whiny character gives him something to work with and I’m really intrigued where the kingdom storyline goes with him. I really think merging undisputed with Kingdom makes the most sense. Even if it’s just kor and strong, but I do think Adam will turn on MJF.

 

[Roy Mustang]

Normally I need charisma too but I’ve always loved him since his ROH days.

I agree his whiny character gives him something to work with and I’m really intrigued where the kingdom storyline goes with him. I really think merging undisputed with Kingdom makes the most sense. Even if it’s just kor and strong, but I do think Adam will turn on MJF.

Yeah I do think the end game is Cole turning on MJF but the journey to get there should take a bit of time imo

 

[Comrade Khan]

 

[O-Blaze]

Final Card Updated

 

[Hoss]

@brandon you forgot to update the challengers for the ROH Tag Titles big dog

 

[Hoss]

@brandon you forgot to update the challengers for the ROH Tag Titles big dog

That was meant to be addressed to @Brandon Blaze

 

[Chris]

@Firefly don't forget to link this before you go to the arena big dawg

 

[O-Blaze]

That was meant to be addressed to @Brandon Blaze

Shit. Lol. Oops