A Good Day to Die Hard: Mafia with a Vengeance [Game Thread]

[RDK]

Next time town leader Haza shows up can it be when i'm also town? kthxluvubi

it will be the goat towncore

 

[Junkette]

This dude doesn't understand why voicing your thoughts of why you think someone is scum or serial killer or better than faking info on them

I mean he a point in general, faking info stops from you claiming and mafia knowing your role and stuff but like here in this context, just be upfront imo.

 

[Ekkologix]

we will probably never agree

 

[Junkette]

it will be the goat towncore

so i'm not trash as town, awww!

 

[Ekkologix]

of course u expect me to know there is an excute in the game as well right?

 

[RDK]

of course u expect me to know there is an excute in the game as well right?

Nobody is expecting you to know that.

We just expect you to know that it's an option and that putting the best town player in execute range with fake info is absolutely a bad idea.

 

[Chris]

Taking back all those nice things I said in the scum chat about Ekko being misunderstood and people being unfair to him by after each post

But I said that about the way you explained your points on doddsy and stuff and you were completely disregarded for bad reasons....you also reasonably explained your poyser suspicions eventually and they made sense too so that would probably work better than faking info (at least on this site)

 

[Ekkologix]

of course I, the all knowing, should somehow out of thin air know better that:

1. when my ability fails on the one role it should work on, that should mean barry is still the serial, cuz why not

2. when poyser says he is vig with restrictions, i should 100% trust him because lying isnt a thing in mafia

3. when scum have bomb, they also have an execute so dont make dumb plays


got it guys. we can move on now. next

 

[Poyser]

we didnt have poyser flip

there was literslly 0 reason to think poyser was not lying and hiding abilities

his early gameplay was not thay towny and did fit an SK, and i had no idea what SKs have here

its not far fetched SKs have their own info gathering abilities. remember the game i hosted here. i always give SKs tools to find power roles or gather some info so they have a fighting chance

from my PoV poyser had to 99% be the serial there or else there was simply no serial in game. its plain and simple really

can u tell me why is that hard to see

But there’s a vig in 99.90% of games here lol. I can understand being suspicious that I might be a serial killer, but like Chris says you post why you think that, you don’t fake info because that’s trash play. Call it a reaction test all you want but it’s shit. What did you gain from the play? Literally fuck all

 

[Chris]

And he still forgot #4: explain your suspicions instead of faking info

Don't even need the other 3

 

[Ekkologix]

Nobody is expecting you to know that.

We just expect you to know that it's an option and that putting the best town player in execute range with fake info is absolutely a bad idea.

the best town player, who i thought was serial, can burn lol

im not gna back off from him if i think he is serial

u keep acting like i faked an info on him when i thought he is town

 

[Chris]

But there’s a vig in 99.90% of games here lol. I can understand being suspicious that I might be a serial killer, but like Chris says you post why you think that, you don’t fake info because that’s trash play. Call it a reaction test all you want but it’s shit. What did you gain from the play? Literally fuck all

I was still thinking he was right after his reveal bc his reasons made sense lol if Barry wouldn't have flipped then I probably would have been thinking you were SK that night

 

[Poyser]

poyser it literally only stayed for 20 minutes

if i was playing towny before, why would u suddenly think my alignment changed?

u give fake info then take it 20 minutes after and discuss with the thread what to go from there

i was hammered so fast i didnt have time to say couple of stuff i wanted to say

regardless. in the event barry was no serial. u will have to be serial and this will 100% pay off

thats the part u r not getting

Yeah but you can see why not many people bought it. You revealed it was fake after it had backfired on you lol

 

[RDK]

of course I, the all knowing, should somehow out of thin air know better that:

1. when my ability fails on the one role it should work on, that should mean barry is still the serial, cuz why not

2. when poyser says he is vig with restrictions, i should 100% trust him because lying isnt a thing in mafia

3. when scum have bomb, they also have an execute so dont make dumb plays


got it guys. we can move on now. next

1. Your action failed. There was interference. You know how mafia works. Cop shots don't always work on the people they would hurt the most.

2. Nobody said you had to 100% trust Poyser.

3. Scum having bomb and execute aren't mutually exclusive. Putting the best players in execute range without good reason or intention to lynch is a BAD idea when an execution hasn't flipped.

 

[Poyser]

And Poyser did consider a bus drive and said it was unlikely

It was impossible unless Wang was scum lol, Wang had already said he hadn’t used his role