A Good Day to Die Hard: Mafia with a Vengeance [Game Thread]

[Junkette]

Finishing the game with the most posts as an survivor/traitor role that should theoretically stay in mid range post wise is something i can be proud of right? ASKING FOR MY OL’ PAL JUNK

 

[Lethal]

@Lethal Banks question you said i was in obvious scum meta in the dead QT, care too share?

Sure. I felt you were open wolfing big time, power wolfing even. It was as though you had something extra up your sleeve, and then the shoddy play around the duel by appealing to town to blend in seemed off. Sort of made me think you're being too careful so you can earn townie points, rather than just (figurative) balls to the wall and getting into it.

 

[Comrade Khan]

As I said in the dead QT, hindsight can be a wonderful thing and I'd have butchered the end myself.

I enjoyed the game for the limited time I got to play, one of my favourite themes, and I just had the bastard luck to tracker the darn PGO and get vigged at the same time.

Had Jeff & Chris linked but didn't have enough of a presence to sink my teeth into it. Taken 3 years but Lethal is learning. Now I just need to use roles well.

Thanks for the game Smark and congrats to the scum team

Dunno if u saw but Chris n I were praising you nailing my team mate meta to a tee

 

[Junkette]

Fair read, I was being more careful with it cause I wanted a shot that would push me unto endgame.

Glad Poyser killed you and you killed yourself to make sure I’d go on too endgame. Thanks

 

[Smart Marx]

My biggest criticism for myself is I probably shouldn’t have let Junk join the mafia team. I originally didn’t when we added Doddsy and then when Poyser joined right after I tried to split the difference and give a few conditions for her to be able to join them.

Since 4 is under 25 and 5 over. Figured giving her the option to join made it fine and whatnot.

Instead I’d probably keep her out, and eliminate the survivor part and just let her win with mafia.

That I feel eliminates the main issue with the hated townie being in the mix and maybe get rid of the executioner. I added that last minute as well because I felt Hans Gruber of all people was underpowered just being a one-shot ninja and strongman.

They didn’t even use it, though. Saving that can be powerful, but you risk losing it. Hence day 2, usually.

 

[Junkette]

I can’t deny it; I was open wolfing

 

[Junkette]

My biggest criticism for myself is I probably shouldn’t have let Junk join the mafia team. I originally didn’t when we added Doddsy and then when Poyser joined right after I tried to split the difference and give a few conditions for her to be able to join them.

Since 4 is under 25 and 5 over. Figured giving her the option to join made it fine and whatnot.

Instead I’d probably keep her out, and eliminate the survivor part and just let her win with mafia.

That I feel eliminates the main issue with the hated townie being in the mix and maybe get rid of the executioner. I added that last minute as well because I felt Hans Gruber of all people was underpowered just being a one-shot ninja and strongman.

They didn’t even use it, though. Saving that can be powerful, but you risk losing it. Hence day 2, usually.

A traitor that can’t join with the scum team isn’t fun for the traitor at all tbh. So I’m quite glad you changed it tbh.

 

[Comrade Khan]

That's fair smark. Will say Eben if it scared me as scum, I like the in thread declaration of alignment change from the host

 

[Smart Marx]

That's fair smark. Will say Eben if it scared me as scum, I like the in thread declaration of alignment change from the host

I want to thank you for this and @Poyser too during the game. I did this after many years of feedback.

Glad you guys like it. I’ll always do this now.

 

[Smart Marx]

A traitor that can’t join with the scum team isn’t fun for the traitor at all tbh. So I’m quite glad you changed it tbh.

That’s fair.

In that case remove the hated townie. I’m fine with the role in general as I didn’t invent it. It’s a standard role, but it’s become a crutch for far too many scum teams.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I want to thank you for this and @Poyser too during the game. I did this after many years of feedback.

Glad you guys like it. I’ll always do this now.

Yea it keeps it fresh but adds a layer of intrigue and game state the alignment changer has to account for, making it much less cheesy. I'm down w it

 

[Junkette]

It was fine, but fuck next time give me a heads up it’ll be announced publicly, i was chatting in the scum chat not even knowing the traitor find was revealed too everyone! Like damn shit that was close

 

[Comrade Khan]

That’s fair.

In that case remove the hated townie. I’m fine with the role in general as I didn’t invent it. It’s a standard role, but it’s become a crutch for far too many scum teams.

Hated is a weird one for sure . Probably should b policy lynched day 1 if no other options exist in fact

 

[Smart Marx]

So I’ll give that to @Poyser.

At the very least your feedback will probably nuke the hated townie from my lineup. If I can remember.

And I might also try a game without a serial killer because I’m definitely always going to stack them.

Might. Keyword.

 

[Junkette]

I mean hated townies could also learn too fake VT