A Good Day to Die Hard: Mafia with a Vengeance [Game Thread]

[Marty McFourth]

I’m aware, i’m trying to get off online and find real friends, I’m starting to make some but like idk still hard and i’m still dealing with shit so I’m kinda in a non social just do shit too distract myself kinda mindset which I know isn’t healthy but it’s where I’m at rn :/

I get ya. Good luck Junk. I'd probably say PM's on here would be less intensive then than Discord which is instant chant and requires more attention imo. Never feel bad about having online friends though. I consider people on here actual friends, and I won't let anyone tell me otherwise. Thousands of miles or not.

 

[Ekkologix]

next time pls make my role work on the one person its supposed to work on lmao

we lost an entire phase thinking poyser was serial cuz my ability was unable to detect the SK despite targeting him n1

it felt pretty bastardy to me. i know u will disagree but when a role is made to only works vs 1 other role i wud expect to be able to bypass his ascetic passive or else whats the point of my role really

wud be better off as vanilla


that aside. i went from being town read by everyone to lynched in 20 minutes. 0 analysis was done.

when i came to clear my result after getting all reactions i want, i was basically already hammered. actual kek day

this majority lynch is so annoying idk how yall like it

cant even claim a fake result then bait reactions and come bk after 20 min without seeing urself hanged

whats worst is how ppl imagine scums just randomly decides to suicide out of nowhere like its my first game of mafia or something


ayyeeee im town read by everyone lemme just get myself lynched real quick for free to throw for my scum team woohooo!!!!

 

[Ekkologix]

i think my grandma who has never played this game can come up with a better fake claim than that as mafia

there was literally no indication a serial killer existed in the game either due to no kills. it was basically a suicidal move to call poyser serial there if im maf.

clear lack of analysis, but really cant blame u guys. i did think he was serial for sure so did an unecessarily hard tunnel because if he wasnt serial then i had no idea who would it be

 

[Smart Marx]

There’s no immunity if it doesn’t work on the role that catches it. Getting a no result never should have made you assume he was safe. Only a negative he’s not result

And never fake info on someone regardless of anything

 

[Ekkologix]

if the CIA agent was a fake claim. its better to just claim copping my ally as not SK

There were 4 mafiosos. Plus a traitor and a serial killer.

4 is under 25, 5 just over. So mafia starts with 4.5.

33% non-town in an 18-player game and town myslynched three times before Mafia could win.

Pretty standard. On top of that Town was clearly going to lynch Wang here completely on there own.

People like to blame setups, but town was losing this game, on play, regardless, and if it wasn’t for Doddsy’s genius census shot, town only lynched one scum boi.

Junk was a lover too so she died if Fourth did. And Junk only joined under the team under a couple circumstances. When that happens the game was let know someone they probably already cleared joined up with them and I immediately saw people say that Junk disappeared after that and rightfully deduced she was in the scum qt reading back. Should have followed up.

Looking back I did tell scum I wouldn’t have let Junk join the team and have them keep the vote steal, but they didn’t need it anyway because they could have lynched Jonny with their three actual members.

Town were also ridiculously stacked themselves with kills and investigation and protection, but no one notices that unless town win and then it’s mafia complaining about a bad setup. It’s exhausting.

It should be said both sides had many restrictions. Mafia for example could only each use one of their extra roles a night, not all 3 and the day roles couldn’t be used together and they couldn’t be used on Jonny because I mitigated for hated. Hence why they lynched Wang, even though they could have just lynched Jonny without the vote steal. In the end, they didn’t even need it, which again shows, it’s not why they won.

I should point out I made this game quickly to fill a gap and get mafia back on and then made three roles last minute, like literally when I’m PMing roles, so maybe with an extra day or two I could edit the setup a little, but honestly until town lynched CP for reasons, it was a close game. Scum came quite close to losing. If town lynched Blaze or they shot him, and then lynched Fourth, Junk was also a lover so she would have died with Fourth, and town wins. No idea why CP got lynched when Fourth claimed his role cop role.

Mafia win. Whoever wants to go next, go.

isnt 3 mislynches for 4 maf a bit too low?

we had 4 mislynches and 2 misfires right? like we only lynched maf twice out of all days and kills

 

[Chris]

Poyser had came around to you being town I'm pretty sure lol he'd unvoted and went Wang but all 3 scum left alive (4 if you count the traitor) and the double voter voted you so you can't really blame all of town too much

 

[Hidden Blaze]

Just like my Atlanta Braves winning the World Series killed baseball, me winning gonna kill mafia the curse lives.

jk

 

[Chris]

Just like my Atlanta Braves winning the World Series killed baseball, me winning gonna kill mafia the curse lives.

jk

This is like the most tame post-game ever lol

 

[Hidden Blaze]

Look I just wanna think I’m cursed alright!

 

[Ekkologix]

There’s no immunity if it doesn’t work on the role that catches it. Getting a no result never should have made you assume he was safe. Only a negative he’s not result

And never fake info on someone regardless of anything

usually anti specific roles will be able to bypass immunities by that role. i thought barry was survivor or godfather since my ability failed on him without returning negative. i never thought serial has a way to fail my ability. its understandable if serial can make cops, trackers, watchers and everything fail.. but not my ability imo.

it felt like i got a neutral on someone i was always supposed to get a positive on. rest of the cops should get neutral on him not my role

there was basically no way im ever getting a positive on him this day. even if i investigated him again n2 he still gives me neutral cuz that mechanic is in the game where he can abstain and basically defeat his counter role

kinda feels robbed when ur action only works against one role out of 17 players and u target that exact player n1 and still not get a positive result. basically not rewarded for properly finding ur target which is a shame

similarly, i talked about the existence of a serial alot, it wuda been sick if barry picked up those hints and just shot me n1 and be done with it. that wud be a beautiful play by him and he deserves to be rewarded for it. but rewarding for abstaining is wack

 

[Ekkologix]

Poyser had came around to you being town I'm pretty sure lol he'd unvoted and went Wang but all 3 scum left alive (4 if you count the traitor) and the double voter voted you so you can't really blame all of town too much

i was already hammered at the time i think

ur reaction was good. but TFW had the worst reaction to my fake result which i wrote down but none picked up on it after either

 

[Smart Marx]

Normally a serial killer needs to kill to win.

You got bamboozled because he got outed early.

That all it is. At least he got killed.

 

[Doddsy]

next time pls make my role work on the one person its supposed to work on lmao

we lost an entire phase thinking poyser was serial cuz my ability was unable to detect the SK despite targeting him n1

it felt pretty bastardy to me. i know u will disagree but when a role is made to only works vs 1 other role i wud expect to be able to bypass his ascetic passive or else whats the point of my role really

wud be better off as vanilla


that aside. i went from being town read by everyone to lynched in 20 minutes. 0 analysis was done.

when i came to clear my result after getting all reactions i want, i was basically already hammered. actual kek day

this majority lynch is so annoying idk how yall like it

cant even claim a fake result then bait reactions and come bk after 20 min without seeing urself hanged

whats worst is how ppl imagine scums just randomly decides to suicide out of nowhere like its my first game of mafia or something


ayyeeee im town read by everyone lemme just get myself lynched real quick for free to throw for my scum team woohooo!!!!

You can't be serious

 

[Smart Marx]

Also, he should be rewarded for abstaining. After claiming it was his best bet to win. He needed to trick town into thinking there wasn’t a serial killer and it seems like he succeeded. Not killing makes his win take longer so he has to fend off the lynch longer.

There’s risk and reward for both killing and not.

 

[Junkette]

No killing SKs are lame