A Good Day to Die Hard: Mafia with a Vengeance [Game Thread]

[CraigPelton]

Slander

I meant prodding jeff d1 for not being obvtown yet

 

[RDK]

For those wondering me and cp are actually really good friends lol

 

[Ekkologix]

You bring up completely valid points, however I still think that those were weak things to start with. Probably could've gone after something else.

thats all i got from page 1 to 4 lol
its probaably the best u can have out of 4 pages of fluff
to try and atleast read which fluffer is the most nervous

im probabaly hella wrong given the way the thread reacted to it so its w.e

but im clearly not pushing that narrative now. it was just an observation while it lasted

 

[Ekkologix]

I could come up with other reasons if you want, some more logical shit but I don't feel like that's necessary

it has to be u
only u can play like this

 

[Comrade Khan]

Yeah I'm too gassed to catch up with this new activity, I'm crashing. I'll do a full readback and read list in the a.m.

 

[Ekkologix]

6 nulls on day 1 in a game with 18 players is too many.

its actually alot yea

specially after the interactions we had

6 nulls in page 1, thats okay

6 nulls after page 35

oops

 

[RDK]

this slot is 90% a wolf one
i can smell it

guy null reading everyone up to this point

there is no way u look at that haza entrance and jeff reaction and not town read atleast one of them

even the chris read is weird given how u completely disregarded that he was encouraging others to not fluff and instead u nitpick on his post to sky

[vote lynch grim]

I mean he isn't scum reading either of us? Couldn't it just be that he doesn't know which of us is town. You know the Ripped one isn't the easiest to read

 

[Ekkologix]

i mean idk, i would imagine if u r scum u wud atleast drop in 2-3 town reads and 2-3 nulls so u can buddy off these players u r town reading atleast

idk the only game i saw u as scum u were super uninvolved

u actually got lynched without even submitting ur actions iirc

 

[RDK]

Nothing has been done to change my mind on Jeff and I'd actively encourage people to help me push him at this half way stage of the phase

 

[Ekkologix]

I mean he isn't scum reading either of us? Couldn't it just be that he doesn't know which of us is town. You know the Ripped one isn't the easiest to read

yea but like from a town PoV
i look at ur strong thread entrance followed by posts about jeff, which i did not agree much with but i like the attempt, and then jeff reaction to it felt pretty towny

like atleast one of u here has to be town. calling u both null is pretty lazy imo

its too safe of a read that cant get tracked back to him

when u start handing too many of these nulls its a red flag

 

[Nostradamus]

you do not understand mafia. but that's okay because you are new

Mafia is about deception, research and patterns. But then people will use their known patterns to their advantage to try and play around people. So from my understanding, you shouldn't expect things from the way anyone plays an alignment because they tend to use those things in their favor by pushing or swapping them. They could still fall on either side regardless of your expectations.

 

[Ekkologix]

also i dont like how @Project Jonny picked up on my post and zinger but not pick upon players that were nitpicking on jeff in page 6-ish

or even barry

im actually moving u to slightly scum from null

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

its actually alot yea

specially after the interactions we had

6 nulls in page 1, thats okay

6 nulls after page 35

oops

This feels like such a weak argument to attempt to pivot suss onto me especially considering the fluff phase of the game was half of those pages.

6 nulls is perfectly fine on day 1 in the early game because most people's metas manifest as the game goes on. I'm not even gonna pretend I'm great at the game by auto-reading people on posts that could swing either way on the alignment scale.

 

[RDK]

yea but like from a town PoV
i look at ur strong thread entrance followed by posts about jeff, which i did not agree much with but i like the attempt, and then jeff reaction to it felt pretty towny

like atleast one of u here has to be town. calling u both null is pretty lazy imo

its too safe of a read that cant get tracked back to him

when u start handing too many of these nulls its a red flag

I wouldn't expect people to have a read on me yet tbh. It's very rare I'm a strong town read for a concensus day one

But yeah obviously one or both of us is town based on this phase so I see what you're saying. I can just see my generally erratic meta being a stumbling block to that

But actually I'm coming around on your point

 

[Ekkologix]

if everyone can iso barry and give me a kind genuine read on him so we can move on that wud be nice

time to bring bully ekko in this forum aswell

1. @The Grimch
2. @Tweet
3. @Ekkologix
4. @Zinger Burger
5. @Poyser
6. @Sky
7. @Chris Kringle
8. @Noelle Kringle
9. @Lethal Banks
10. @CraigPelton
11. @Hans Gruber
12. @Project Jonny
13. @The Blaze
14. @Doddsy
15. @Wang Chung
16. @Junkette
17. @Raidokken
18. @RetepAdam.