A Good Day to Die Hard: Mafia with a Vengeance [Game Thread]

[Chris]

Wait Poyser is still red so he could respond

 

[Smart Marx]

Wait Poyser is still red so he could respond

So what you’re saying is hurry up and demod him?

 

[Chris]

On the real thread locking does zero bc 9 times out of 10 it will move to the main chat or mafia general discussion lol don't tell Barry that tho

 

[Poyser]

What did junk do to get mvp? The game was won when she got recruited lol

I’be not seen scum chat obv so can’t say from that aspect, but from game play alone I’d probably say

MVP: 4th
HM: haza
HM: blaze

Doddsy unlucky just because town lost really, can’t really justify two town HMs in a losing effort like this, but I thought haza was the best town player on play alone.

 

[Comrade Khan]

for real tho i cant see this being a game where awards would upset anyone, but ive been proven wrong b4

 

[Smart Marx]

Haza is 100% getting an honorable mention

 

[Comrade Khan]

What did junk do to get mvp? The game was won when she got recruited lol

I’be not seen scum chat obv so can’t say from that aspect, but from game play alone I’d probably say

MVP: 4th
HM: haza
HM: blaze

Doddsy unlucky just because town lost really, can’t really justify two town HMs in a losing effort like this, but I thought haza was the best town player on play alone.

they had basically given up and had they not recruited junk, they lose 10/10 times imo. its one of those situation where her presence in the scum chat alone rejuvenated the team and got them more focused. its possible i have bias from that as i wasnt in the game chat for that long, but i feel that + the fact she made less mistakes in the claiming department and used her duel proper (and stayed a live) is enough for me to give her the nod. i thought blaze and 4th were very solid though, especially blaze given his experience.

haza is the only answer for town i think we all agree of course

 

[RDK]

What did junk do to get mvp? The game was won when she got recruited lol

I’be not seen scum chat obv so can’t say from that aspect, but from game play alone I’d probably say

MVP: 4th
HM: haza
HM: blaze

Doddsy unlucky just because town lost really, can’t really justify two town HMs in a losing effort like this, but I thought haza was the best town player on play alone.

yeah I had 4th as mvp and still do. Active in the scum chat from what i can see, maintained good thread presence throughout and wasn't heavily suspected the way junk was. I don't think Blaze really did anything to merit an award unless you want to give him some expectancy bias so would switch him with junk in poysers list

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

I'm shit as SK, just look at my track history with the role tbh.

 

[Poyser]

Fair enough, but I think that’s mostly just the effect of going from 2 to 3 rather than anything junk did lol. I wouldn’t begrudge her the award tho

 

[RDK]

If TFW had given up that would change things lol but i haven't read the whole scum chat

 

[Marty McFourth]

Junk really took the leadership over in the Scum chat. Myself and Blaze weren't really sure on the path to victory until she joined us. We were about ready to lose hope, and she gave us a massive lease of life. I also thought her play to stay alive as traitor and whatnot is worthy of a MVP for sure. She was not pushing me as hard because she knew she'd be joining me hopefully. I don't feel I really did enough to win an MVP here, I'd 100% give it to Junk imo

 

[Comrade Khan]

i personally think expectancy bias should always be considered but i have a hard time splitting both blaze and 4th. i think you guy are underselling how botchy his claim was (4th). he claimed teh scum version of his role lol

 

[Poyser]

yeah I had 4th as mvp and still do. Active in the scum chat from what i can see, maintained good thread presence throughout and wasn't heavily suspected the way junk was. I don't think Blaze really did anything to merit an award unless you want to give him some expectancy bias so would switch him with junk in poysers list

Yeah this is probably more fair actually. I was definitely giving in to expectation bias there

 

[Comrade Khan]

and thats not discreditting 4th, i still think he played good enough to be in the HM convo. just something to consider overall. its a tough one. (tho i do think if the scum team thinks junk is mvp she should get it)