God, the star rating shit is so fucktarded and subjective. Yes, by Dave Melzter's standards, some nerdy smurf who created it and sits in his basement watching chink wrestling all day, John Cena vs. CM Punk wouldn't even be remotely close to a 5 star match, so Enzo's right. HBK and Taker was far better, and he didn't even give that 5 stars. Not to mention Enzo you're beloved Flair vs. HBK match only got like 3 and a half stars from him rofl. With that said, I commend the fuck out of this match for the simple fact that it culminated and created such a rivoting feud on a fucking second-rate, GIMMICK PPV. Who would have thought this type of calibre match/feud would happen there, in MODERN day WWE. However, it was pretty much like going back to the Attitude Era with that night, drama and action like that was common on pretty much every PPV so this match is being horribly and laughably overrated by all of you, even though that means little since again, "ratings" are opinionated. It was a sick match, but the ending was far better, with Punk escaping through the crowd and Vince begging him not to, made it all, and most of all, made Punk a star. On that note, awesome match, bout as good or better than HHH/Taker but who the fuck really cares to go into semantics over it.
Also, the Fatal Four Way absolutely shit on the terrible AJ/Daniels match, lol.