Prey At Night: The Strangers Mafia Game Thread

[Mandalorian]

@Bobby Barrows I think I saw you'd done a bit of a read through of some of Wang's posts. What were your thoughts coming out of that and where would you put him?

 

[Grim]

@Bobby Barrows I think I saw you'd done a bit of a read through of some of Wang's posts. What were your thoughts coming out of that and where would you put him?

Less of a town lean, leaning back into Null. His reads list is just not good. I don't think he even has any firm town leans outside of Sky.

 

[Sky]

Again, I haven't. I interpreted a post and made a good point that a scum tactic is to get into a 1-on-1 with someone, because it does allow posts to pile up without actually doing much.

I have not once made the implication that you haven't done anything. I'm pointing out that it is a scum tactic, and Ekko could use that as an argument.

Is my thing with Ekko a scum tactic then?

 

[Spitfire]

Vote:Ekko

No one else is likely to attract my vote and he is nothing like his last few town games on WG or FV

 

[Grim]

Is my thing with Ekko a scum tactic then?

I dunno, could be. But youve also been going after John, Blaine, and a few others, so I don't think you're hyperfocusing on one person rather than shooting from the hip at everyone, so to speak.

 

[Spitfire]

Even if Sky is scum. She is not even remotely a good lynch option today. Suggestion by anyone would be unmerited

 

[Grim]

Even if Sky is scum. She is not even remotely a good lynch option today. Suggestion by anyone would be unmerited

Agreed tbh.

 

[RDK]

You're back to null. Sky gave info

Irrelevant, I don't care about your reads as I don't really value them, I care about the intent behind scum reading someone with 1 post, unless you can explain why that post makes me scum which I'm sure you can't.

 

[Spitfire]

Barry earning town points or my pocket. Hard to tell lol

 

[Grim]

Barry earning town points or my pocket. Hard to tell lol

I mean considering I'm still questioning your lean on Haza, I'll let you decide for yourself.

 

[Spitfire]

Irrelevant, I don't care about your reads as I don't really value them, I care about the intent behind scum reading someone with 1 post, unless you can explain why that post makes me scum which I'm sure you can't.

a one post hello and then nothing else is just stranger behaviour from someone who isn't shy from being active in mafia games. I'd ask Sky as the host of the last game on OLF - if she thinks the start is suspect considering he was one of the top posters in the game.

 

[RDK]

a one post hello and then nothing else is just stranger behaviour from someone who isn't shy from being active in mafia games. I'd ask Sky as the host of the last game on OLF - if she thinks the start is suspect considering he was one of the top posters in the game.

Yeah that's an absolutely dreadful post for a few reasons

 

[Spitfire]

Day one scum reads can turn into day three strongest town reads. No benefits to getting bogged down in day 1 locked in reads though

 

[Spitfire]

Yeah that's an absolutely dreadful post for a few reasons

You're allowed your opinions

 

[RDK]

You're allowed your opinions

You've now used activity as a reason to suspect two players that have good scum range and no history of completely no showing as scum.

The poyser town read is bad because it completely reduces his scum range.

The read on me is bad A) because it takes a one game sample and turns it into a linear argument of me being a scum lean because I've not posted as much as I did in that game and B) because you bring sky into it for no reason other than to try and lead her into the read so that you can abstain responsibility.

I'm going to assume you're just scum here unless this was simply a spite read for getting you D1'd last game.

I'll reserve my vote since I haven read more than a handful of posts this game and would rather try and do that first