"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

[Canadian Dragon]

oh and captain holt, how would you describe the difference between Baldricks town and scum game?

 

[Canadian Dragon]

dammit poyser

 

[Poyser]

who are you talking to btw, there's 2 guys you were grilling and you didnt quote

Sorry, that McNighthunter guy

 

[Canadian Dragon]

 

[Poyser]

One person saying Sister Abigail is coming out too hard and aggressive and one dude saying they're too reserved

like wat

 

[Canadian Dragon]

One person saying Sister Abigail is coming out too hard and aggressive and one dude saying they're too reserved

like wat

fwiw i just looked at their 10 posts and 95% nothing so id agree more with the latter. i know u said they cut thru the bullshit but outside of like 1/2 posts its asking a lot of wtv questions. not saying I sus btw, just imo its not much there. take a look

 

[Canadian Dragon]

and by "nothing" I mean it's a lot of questions with 0 followthru

 

[Poyser]

fwiw i just looked at their 10 posts and 95% nothing so id agree more with the latter. i know u said they cut thru the bullshit but outside of like 1/2 posts its asking a lot of wtv questions. not saying I sus btw, just imo its not much there. take a look

For me its more the fact that he was just up in people's grill and didn't let them settle. He asked mcnightguy if he was scared to play after a nothing answer, asked john mchenry if he was looking for a soft landing into the game which I guess won me over because it struck me as a great observation and the kind of thing I'd be asking (I also wholeheartedly agreed at the time). He also tagged you to call you out. Even with Wang, you can see he was gearing up to give him shit before he realised that he'd actually made a couple posts before replying.

Im not "this guy is lock town never rescind" level of confident or anything as it is early but I just thought it was a very strong entrance and not particularly one that I'd expect a scum to make.

I def don't agree with saying they've been reserved so I'm definitely looking for more elaboration on that from captain holt

 

[Captain Holt]

Baldy usually blends into the background more as mafia. He posts enough but he does everything he can early on not to take sides, not to rock the boat.

As town, I wouldnt say hes a leader, but hes a lot looser and less guarded. Granted, this may be due to your aggression tpwards him Poyser but I dont see him firing back at you directly as mafia.

And all I meant by my statement at Poyser is that I dont think he was expecting someone to come at him like that so early and rattling him and forcing him to open a bit is a good thing. I love when playerß force other players to talk more.

 

[Captain Holt]

I may have worded it incorrectly but I was saying Man was playing reserved.

Gonna be atcwork for a bit

 

[Canadian Dragon]

For me its more the fact that he was just up in people's grill and didn't let them settle. He asked mcnightguy if he was scared to play after a nothing answer, asked john mchenry if he was looking for a soft landing into the game which I guess won me over because it struck me as a great observation and the kind of thing I'd be asking (I also wholeheartedly agreed at the time). He also tagged you to call you out. Even with Wang, you can see he was gearing up to give him shit before he realised that he'd actually made a couple posts before replying.

Im not "this guy is lock town never rescind" level of confident or anything as it is early but I just thought it was a very strong entrance and not particularly one that I'd expect a scum to make.

I def don't agree with saying they've been reserved so I'm definitely looking for more elaboration on that from captain holt

thats fair. i just feel its not that hard to that and then not engage aftewards. ill admit some of that could simply also be bad timing, since i wasnt there live to answer his tag (and I think I know what his reasoning is anyways, hes seen me play scum more than town and i had good scum games those games as well. its not unatural for him to want to test me early)

 

[Poyser]

Baldy usually blends into the background more as mafia. He posts enough but he does everything he can early on not to take sides, not to rock the boat.

As town, I wouldnt say hes a leader, but hes a lot looser and less guarded. Granted, this may be due to your aggression tpwards him Poyser but I dont see him firing back at you directly as mafia.

And all I meant by my statement at Poyser is that I dont think he was expecting someone to come at him like that so early and rattling him and forcing him to open a bit is a good thing. I love when playerß force other players to talk more.

Out of interest, which posts that he's made this games are the ones that you think takes him out of his scum meta? Like what has he said that make you feel hes taking sides and "rocking the boat"?

 

[Poyser]

I may have worded it incorrectly but I was saying Man was playing reserved.

Gonna be atcwork for a bit

Yeah we got that, we just aren't sure what you mean by it. How is he playing reserved?

Or is "Man" different to sister abigail lol?

 

[Wangman Page]

I think baldrick is my best option so far, mostly in the sense that he’s just talking shite and I can’t see where he’s coming from which is usually the red flag. Like if I think you’re talking shit but I can see what you’re thinking then whatever, but his posts just aren’t making sense

Baldys posts won't make sense at times. He tends to have a plan but is hard to follow until later.

Sent from my SM-S908U using Tapatalk

 

[Wangman Page]

Did I misread some other votes then? My bad.

I am fine with having a vote on me, there's logic there if you think about it.

Sent from my SM-A137F using Tapatalk

Yeah Man voted Smark helped when he asked is this how you vote by voting to show.

Sent from my SM-S908U using Tapatalk