WS Mafia II: THE REBUILD - Game Thread

[Barry Poppins]

Juice is at five votes and is really giving me lots of reasons to vote for her. So let's just do that. I don't think anyone else should vote her until she claims.

Vote Juice

Please claim, Juice.

 

[Spitfire]

No...?

yes. a regular game is 7-9 players. Its not a debate - its a fact.
If you are used to big games - doesn't stop them being big games.

 

[Barry Poppins]

yes. a regular game is 7-9 players. Its not a debate - its a fact.
If you are used to big games - doesn't stop them being big games.

According to whom...?

 

[Alco]

Please be advised this is execution territory, gents and lasses. She can perfectly claim at 4 as well, there's enough pressure.

 

[Spitfire]

According to basic mafia. - classic mafia games. A cop, a doc, two mafia members and three VTs. That is the Classical mafia setup. Like for decades.

 

[Spitfire]

I'm being voted for bullshit reasons. So I'm not claiming.

 

[Spitfire]

Got vote because I asked about who hasn't been online.
Got voted by a racist.
Got voted because I said a big game is 12+

 

[Barry Poppins]

Let's speak factually here:

According to the Wikipedia page for Mafia, 6 players is the absolute minimum to play a classic game, which means 6-8 players is a "small game", and 9-14 would be a moderately sized game. We usually get over 13, so yes, even though we get a "large" game on the standards of the Wikipedia page, on here, 13 players would be a small game, and 20+ would be a large game, by our standards.

 

[Barry Poppins]

Got vote because I asked about who hasn't been online.
Got voted by a racist.
Got voted because I said a big game is 12+

Oh what the fuck are these mental gymnastics?

 

[Alco]

Are we really having this discussion, guys?

 

[RDK]

I feel these are pretty towny-Jeff posts, here. They're inquisitive, pushing a clear direction and giving concise thoughts. So yeah.

Ok so hear me out. We're talking about inquisition. So look at the questions asked as you've quoted. They're responsive to suspicion on himself, they're self centered questions (not in a bad way), but responsive.

Now go look at last game and skim through the same phase of play (the opening), ive quoted a bunch of it here that you can look at too now that you've unignored me.

See if you can see the difference. Question are not reflexive, he is prodding, making stuff happen, using inquisition to town/scumhunt and establish people's reads and stances. It's clearly different to what you've just quoted because it's him going out on a limb, unassisted, prying at people to help himself get to grips with the game and get people on record.

 

[Spitfire]

So a large game..

 

[Barry Poppins]

God, part of me thinks scum Juice would not pull this shit as she'd have teammates telling her to knock it off, but at the same time, Juice seems like the kind of scum player to go rogue at the drop of a hat.

 

[Spitfire]

Last two games I've played - I have been voted for bullshit reasons on day 1. And been asked to claim first. Bit bored of this shit tbh.

 

[Kajuh]

Let's stick to talking about the game please