GFXL: TC2: The_King vs. Ryan

[Andy]

The_King's Submission

Ryan's Submission

Vote, list the positives and negatives if you wish to do so, and please, no flaming.​

 

[John McHenry]

Going with The King here.

The King
+ Looks straight up like it could be used for their promotions like I could see this in the streets.
- Their isn't anything.

Ryan
+ Use of the Comic version so many of us went straight to the movies.
- I just got done watching a movie about teleportation and thats what this makes me think of superman teleporting but in a flying pose. The black background is just too blank for me. If you had nothing to put thier perhaps if you didn't have anything to put their you should have made it blank, yours would have really popped if you'd taken it out of the square format. Also the S is backwards.

 

[The New F'n Show]

Ryan here.

Kings is just to dark for me, can't really see the image. I get it if that's what you were going for but doesn't work for me.

 

[Andrew]

Both are amazing sigs, leaning on The King here.

However both sigs are great.

 

[Heisenberg]

Both are very good sigs and it's a hard decision to make but I went with Ryan as it was more appealing to me and caught my eye.

 

[The_King]

Ryan here.

Kings is just to dark for me, can't really see the image. I get it if that's what you were going for but doesn't work for me.

I made this so long ago that I can't remember what I was going for haha, but knowing me, I was probs shooting for dark! Thanks for the comment!

If votes for yourself count, I'll vote for myself
Good luck Ryan!

 

[Defiant]

Everybody in this tournament is stepping up and I like it. Every match so far has been a close one.

I've spent a good few minutes staring at both, I don't really spot any significant flaws and its real close, but I'm voting for King.

 

[Edgeomatic]

Both are very well done, but they arent very exciting.

I like the way Kign went with Spiderman more then the way Ryan went with Soups, so I'll vote King.

 

[Ryan]

Ah, I do remember seeing this way back when. I don't really like the way mine came out, so I won't at all be surprised if King takes this one. Good luck.

 

[BDC]

Both fantastic

I like the spiderman one better, King. It does look like it could have come right off the movie ad.

You apparently flipped Supes and it inverted his S and I agree that it may have need a little something extra in the background.

KING

 

[Chriss]

Ryan gets my vote.

Decently brushed on the sides, color sheme of the background works perfectly with the render (for me).

Kings is just too dark for me as well. Im not sying it is bad, I just like Ryans better.

 

[Ryan]

I did flip Superman because I didn't like how he looked facing the other way.

 

[Deuce]

Ryan has my vote.

 

[PHX]

Really dig both of these but King gets m vote dark spider man looks bad ass to me.

 

[Lewb]

King gets my vote here, because it is pretty much faultless to me. Ryan, I really like your piece and it works well. It's very unlucky you came up against a great piece like this.