Let the Past Die: The Skywalker Saga - A Star Wars Mafia Game Thread

[Evans]

The part where I said I wanna lynch him was the joke, the rest is still accurate, an outed Hider tends to do more harm than good.

I know this is the pals era but you can't tell me that this is actually the best you can do in terms of rebuttal.

Come on man, I even put a at the end of that sentence and you still take it for real smh

So why did you shut me down when I asked about it?

 

[Tweet]

So why did you shut me down when I asked about it?

I don't even know what your point is anymore. Do you want me to reach the conclusion that lynching Barry is the best play here or what do I need to say to you?

 

[Comrade Khan]

The "is this your best" argument is clearly based on previous town games of yours where you've been very effective without having to resort to TRAPs that you abandon as soon as they've sprung. This all reminds me of WS Reloaded way too much for me to let it slide.

But it's YOUR assumption that I "resorted" to anything. I'm still playing the game now aren't I?

 

[Comrade Khan]

ANd it's also not like I haven't been poking and prodding elsewhere, so this idea that I resorted to anything is simply hogwash

 

[Comrade Khan]

Regardless, from my p.o.v were just going to be going in circle. You (Tweet) don't believe the authenticity of the play and think it's some sort of desperate plea for content. I think you're thinking is near-sighted and you think I'm only capable of creative plays as scum. I disagree.

 

[Tweet]

But it's YOUR assumption that I "resorted" to anything. I'm still playing the game now aren't I?

Yes, I'm saying you're "resorting" to towny looking plays that serve no purpose and are unlike anything town Jeff would actually do. It's not a secret that you struggle to reproduce your town game as scum, for all I know this could be your next attempt at having a successful scum game.

 

[Evans]

I don't even know what your point is anymore. Do you want me to reach the conclusion that lynching Barry is the best play here or what do I need to say to you?

This doesn't add up, could you explain why you wouldn't want to lynch the hider today but an outed hider does more harm to town than it does good?

^ I'd like that answered and I'm getting very sceptical of your responses to the questions. First you try to play it all off as a joke and don't answer my question then when Jeff pushes, it becomes an outed hider is bad for town (not disputing that it is a bad thing). There's inconsistencies forming.

Also, I have iterated my stance on Jeff & Barry a couple of times already, so trying to suggest I'm pushing for a Barry lynch is when I've said I want to see more from Barry.

Also responding to questions with questions with implied statements isn't an ideal look, similar to what you did to Jeff here. It's probably you on the defence but it doesn't scream a townie justifying his points as opposed to trying to misdirect conversation.

Since when do you need people to tell you what you oughta be doing? Whom are you currently pushing?

 

[Tweet]

night posting is ALLOWED. Do you not read OPs fully anymore Tweet?

A big part of me thinks Jeff was serious about this post btw.

 

[Comrade Khan]

A big part of me thinks Jeff was serious about this post btw.

Why would I not be? I was serious, as you completely shat the bed thinking last game was full vanilla, so the only assumption I can make is that you had once again not read the op. What's your point here big fella?

 

[Evans]

On a side note, speaking about the OP ^^

Barry comes out with a full claim yet the OP specifically advises caution lol. That doesn't sit right with me.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Like my issue here Tweet, is while I can at least accept you not believing me, the extra "points" and sass you're throwing around seems highly unnecessary for the amount of pushback you were getting originally, which was close to none outside of myself...

 

[Lethal]

I've got a bad feeling about this.

Greetings, pals. Quite possibly my favourite theme in the universe

 

[Comrade Khan]

And in the past, you've shown frustration quickly as non-town, so meta-wise, I'm concerned

 

[Lethal]

All of these posts about traps, and nobody has posted this: v

For shame. All of you.

 

[Tweet]

Evans:

I mean it's still true that an outed Hider can do more harm than good, but if he decides to hide behind scum there's not exactly a lot they can do about it. Not that I would have trusted Barry to make an adequate Hider hint even if he hadn't claimed.

The Hider usually relies on stealth for his first usage at the very least, the fact his role is out there now means that any post he makes during nighttime can be a hint on how he uses his role, and scum can exploit this for a double kill.

These are my points for why an outed Hider usually does more harm than good and why I still wouldn't lynch them. Thinking about it there's also another good reason for why I wouldn't lynch Barry today based on claim alone but it's not something I'd want to draw attention to rn.

Now if you believe what I said earlier was a joke and still keep bugging me over this, all I can deduce from that is that you want me to say that lynching Barry is the most reasonable conclusion I could have come to. That's not me putting words in your mouth, above all it's getting irritated by these questions.