Nintendo Mafia - Game Thread

[Canadian Dragon]

Magic said before the game he's going to struggle to have any time at all for the game. he's not going to magically have time to play if he's scum and he's been inactive early as scum before. it is completely null.

I would also say that I very much doubt scum magic's only contribution to the thread on day 1 and most of day was to just lynch sky. i dont really see him doing nothing but bus his teamate that early, knowing that he generally likes to help and has won with sky in the past

 

[Roy Mustang]

We've had 3 full days and Rugrat could still fall to either side for me, but I haven't seen his latest transgressions. Sky locking her vote on him when she did, is just so . Would Sky still be THAT obvious in fabricating distance?

Yeah that's what makes it a WIFOM nightmare. It was so fucking obviously fake.

Also Magic almost guaranteed town, even with his limited activity sussing Sky is something he did basically everytime he spoke up.

Yeah unless Magic went hardcore bus mode, he is town. He was on Sky right from day 1.

Who needs roles when you can fake info on scum

It worked so well we lynched someone else when we might have lynched Sky a day sooner if you actually used it on her . Also thoughts on the no results on the vig? Do you think the Jailkeeper or Roleblocker is in the VT's or Lethal?

 

[Canadian Dragon]

also his readback stuff looked a lot like town magic to me

 

[Roy Mustang]

If scum jailed Lethal why not just kill Tweet at that point?

Maybe they did... Haza martyred himself night 2

 

[Lethal]

Arsonist is third party, it’s only when Mafia have a poisoner or burner that there needs to be a healing based role in play

Ah. Thanks for clearing that up.

@Jeffatron If I'm correct you used your role on Tweet both nights right? I think this flip makes Lethal being scum more likely with the claimed JK shot

I've explained why I JK'd Jeff. I have no idea what I'll develop tonight.

 

[Tweet]

If scum jailed Lethal why not just kill Tweet at that point?

Uh... what?

 

[Roy Mustang]

And any good scum team knows to put the rolewatcher on the gunsmith. Done it so many times myself as scum. So they see you and Alco. They pick one of you two to Jailkeep (you as you were more active and easy to explain). If they don't kill Tweet they know Alco is the Bodyguard (I mean they would be wrong but that is what you would guess. Plus Lethal can explain it as the usage looks town. Also the Rolewatcher can claim watcher then (WHY DID SKY NOT CLAIM WATCHER?)

 

[Roy Mustang]

Ah. Thanks for clearing that up.



I've explained why I JK'd Jeff. I have no idea what I'll develop tonight.

Yeah and I get the town motive for it too. However there is a strong scum motive that make senses for a good scum to do. I've done these exact plays myself.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

i have 0 idea why sky picked that claim outside of just scaring town into not lynching ,i guess it did work on day 2 as we ultimately did not lynch.

 

[Roy Mustang]

^I think we would have also not lynched the watcher day 2 (well Tweet would have done)

I'd add to my above therory I can see his usage as town which doesn't make this a slam dunk theory. Also I think OMB is scum and that would mean Lethal and him are bussing?

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Either way, if the vig took a shot tonight, I would not be upset

 

[Canadian Dragon]

what was your claim again gambitto?

 

[Roy Mustang]

what was your claim again gambitto?

VT Pikachu

 

[Tweet]

I think I'd prefer lynching OMitchB tomorrow, Mitch has been nothing but scum on play and the point Magic made that just about the only reason to kill PHEN0M was to make Mitch look town off of the Mario flip is very compelling to me.

Also I wanna be 2/2 on my main d1 scum reads

 

[Canadian Dragon]

k. i guess that would put you in very late POE as well. Sky jumped all over you day 1 iirc, however, which bodes well for you. have you town on play/gut as well.