Nintendo Mafia - Game Thread

[Chris]

haza lookin like he's come to play

This is the post that Gambit agreed with and read Haza town right after. Jeff doesn't give any sort of inclination about reading Haza at all, just showed he was glad Haza was coming out playing more than he has in some other games recently. I see nothing here to "agree with a town read" at all. Also, Tweet was the first one to point out his read of Haza being weird, and Haza jumped on him for it as well, but he only focused on Sky being the one to twist his words for a scum read on him when it was clearly not just her going at him for it.

Vote Gambit

 

[RDK]

This is the post that Gambit agreed with and read Haza town right after. Jeff doesn't give any sort of inclination about reading Haza at all, just showed he was glad Haza was coming out playing more than he has in some other games recently. I see nothing here to "agree with a town read" at all. Also, Tweet was the first one to point out his read of Haza being weird, and Haza jumped on him for it as well, but he only focused on Sky being the one to twist his words for a scum read on him when it was clearly not just her going at him for it.

Vote Gambit

I can see why Jeff's post looks like at least a lean in gambit's defense but it obviously doesn't look great

 

[Tweet]

On second thought Haza has been kinda sick and tired of drawing scum over and over again and him actually trying to be helpful could indicate he's not scum for once.

Or you know, he might be scum who wants me to think the above

 

[Tweet]

I don't believe you, or this way of thinking.

Rugrat and OMB are probably not aligned with the gist of their recent pots.

.....????

 

[Chris]

I can see why Jeff's post looks like at least a lean in gambit's defense but it obviously doesn't look great

Yeah it's easy to see it from a town perspective as well, and I don't think his explanation was necessarily bad but the way he tried to switch it over to Sky was weird too. Like I was thinking Sky was the only one sussing him from how that convo went until I just went and read back and saw you and Tweet were too

 

[Tweet]

Not a great fan of Barry either btw, this whole excusing himself for not being active when nobody had even called him out for it yet stuff is mindboggling.

 

[Chris]

Not a great fan of Barry either btw, this whole excusing himself for not being active when nobody had even called him out for it yet stuff is mindboggling.

Well OMB had kind of, but I think that hurts his case even more bc he's been on the record saying OMB not giving reasons hurts his reads so I don't see why he'd think he needed to defend that so hard

 

[RDK]

Not a great fan of Barry either btw, this whole excusing himself for not being active when nobody had even called him out for it yet stuff is mindboggling.

Man was just plugging his twitch imo

 

[Tweet]

Idc that Gambit tries to hide behind a read that he thinks (or pretends to think) that Jeff made, what it boils down to is he read Haza town for 2-3 posts at best, that from my perspective don't even slightly warrant a town read. The argument that he hasn't played in a while doesn't apply cause he admitted he's not reading Haza based on meta, but on the merit of those few posts. He gave reasons for why he made that read but I don't currently buy em.

 

[Tweet]

Man was just plugging his twitch imo

Well I already follow his twitch so

 

[RDK]

Idc that Gambit tries to hide behind a read that he thinks (or pretends to think) that Jeff made, what it boils down to is he read Haza town for 2-3 posts at best, that from my perspective don't even slightly warrant a town read. The argument that he hasn't played in a while doesn't apply cause he admitted he's not reading Haza based on meta, but on the merit of those few posts. He gave reasons for why he made that read but I don't currently buy em.

Yes tldr it was a weak town read that is likely a ploy to look good when I come out as town which historically one way or another happens sooner than later hence being useful sooner than later.

The last point isn't relevant if he truly doesn't know that which is possible. Still thought it was worth pointing out in case

Regardless he should at least be made to claim for what was either an extremely generous town read or more likely a fabricated one

 

[Roy Mustang]

This is the post that Gambit agreed with and read Haza town right after. Jeff doesn't give any sort of inclination about reading Haza at all, just showed he was glad Haza was coming out playing more than he has in some other games recently. I see nothing here to "agree with a town read" at all. Also, Tweet was the first one to point out his read of Haza being weird, and Haza jumped on him for it as well, but he only focused on Sky being the one to twist his words for a scum read on him when it was clearly not just her going at him for it.

Vote Gambit

Sorry but acting like Jeff's post is some super clear post that can't be viewed as a town read is hindsight bullshit. Saying you like someone's post is usually something people say when they find someone town. Odo says this all the time, Poyser says it, heck probs others too. Heck I say it when I find someone town often. So why would I assume it is just him being happy that he is active? Also how would I know how Haza has played in past games? I haven't played most of the recent games and the only one I did, I died night 2 so was barely in it so again why would I know it was Jeff referencing activity?

I went after Sky because she literally was twisting my words and I explained why it was scummy. She was literally stretching my words to fit her case. Why would I go after Haza? I find him to be town. So I need to accuse every person calling me scum of being scum? That's awful play and makes no sense. Haza is a town lean and tbh his activity is hardly making me disagree with my own assessment on that.

Sky's post came off as literally twisting my words hence why I pressed her. Tweet called me scum because he thought my read was bad and too early. OK fine I'll just fluff till day 2 and do nothing. Also my Haza read came after more than 3 posts. And trust me I have read players off less before and been right.

 

[Roy Mustang]

Yes tldr it was a weak town read that is likely a ploy to look good when I come out as town which historically one way or another happens sooner than later hence being useful sooner than later.

The last point isn't relevant if he truly doesn't know that which is possible. Still thought it was worth pointing out in case

Regardless he should at least be made to claim for what was either an extremely generous town read or more likely a fabricated one

So I should claim because I made an extremely generous town read ? Do you do this every game people make early town reads? The case against me is terrible imo so I'm good thanks.

 

[RDK]

So I should claim because I made an extremely generous town read ? Do you do this every game people make early town reads? The case against me is terrible imo so I'm good thanks.

Who else are you reading town? Who are you reading scum?

If it only took 6 or 7 posts to read me town this should be easy

 

[Tweet]

Sorry but acting like Jeff's post is some super clear post that can't be viewed as a town read is hindsight bullshit. Saying you like someone's post is usually something people say when they find someone town. Odo says this all the time, Poyser says it, heck probs others too. Heck I say it when I find someone town often. So why would I assume it is just him being happy that he is active? Also how would I know how Haza has played in past games? I haven't played most of the recent games and the only one I did, I died night 2 so was barely in it so again why would I know it was Jeff referencing activity?

I went after Sky because she literally was twisting my words and I explained why it was scummy. She was literally stretching my words to fit her case. Why would I go after Haza? I find him to be town. So I need to accuse every person calling me scum of being scum? That's awful play and makes no sense. Haza is a town lean and tbh his activity is hardly making me disagree with my own assessment on that.

Sky's post came off as literally twisting my words hence why I pressed her. Tweet called me scum because he thought my read was bad and too early. OK fine I'll just fluff till day 2 and do nothing. Also my Haza read came after more than 3 posts. And trust me I have read players off less before and been right.

Just to be clear, I also think that Jeff saying something positive about Haza could be seen as a town lean but whether he reads Haza town or not has no bearing on my opinion about your read on Haza.

Also Sky twisting just about everything into a case for why the person saying it is scum is like vintage Sky.

What's your opinion on Mitch if you compare his entrance of this game and last game?