Barry Presents: Whodunnit 2: The West Smithton Sagas GAME THREAD

[Tweet]

Quite, but her last scum game proved any improvement to her town game only happens as scum and then doesn't register as town

Don't really need sky in end game willing to lynch everyone and anyone with a two second thought about why they would be scum but not for why they're likely town.

I think I like Magic as town for wanting to get rid of Sky regardless of her alignment, usually scum likes to drag her to endgame so they got someone to vote with them. So him wanting to defuse this landmine looks good imo.

 

[Daddy Deville]

And OMB bussing Poyser? I doubt he has the confidence to

 

[Sky]

Well I like the thoughtfulness given that I absolutely hate surviving to endgame, it never goes well. But I would not say getting rid of me ASAP is a good idea at all.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Always so subtle

 

[Canadian Dragon]

But yeah, clearly you see some stank, let's get a claim out of mitch yea?

 

[Banez]

Why do you rush always into quicklynch as town Sky in endgame?

 

[Banez]

I'll give help to Jeff.

vote Mitch

 

[Daddy Deville]

1. Jeffatron - leaning town on Jeff, he hasn't really seen like scum Jeff
2. Big Man - null on Big Man, not enough posts
3. Raidokken - leaning scum on Haza, same feelings as last game where there's a lot of fluff
4. Judas Iscariot - I feel OMB is bussing Poyser, like I said I could easily see him being coached
5. Mitch Perfect - I know I'm town
6. Odo - I feel like Odo is town Odo, I've really liked his posts
7. PHEN0M - null on N0M, he's super hard to read
8. Showtime - null on Magic, not enough posts
9. Alco
10. Darth Lethal - conflicted on Lethal, leaning more town but he could easily be indy or mafia
11. Banez - null on Banez, still trying to get a read from him
12. Mr.Tweetums - conflicted on Tweet, could be indy
13. V. Skybox - last game aside, getting town vibes from Sky, hopefully I don't get fooled again
14. Uncle Larry - leaning scum on KIF, though it is KIF so I shouldn't go to crazy about it like before
15. NotBrutus - null on Brutus, haven't seen enough yet so still trying to get a read
16. Poyser - my feelings on Poyser are known
17. Broken God - I feel he's played a pretty town game

Typical go with the flow Mitch doesn't seem to dare to rock the boat just agree with the typical mafia and town reads I be watching this if Mitch flips scum cause there could be a maf in his null statement

 

[NotBrutus]

I would say that from your answers now, that thought process seems genuine. I've personally also cooled off on town reading sky and back to null with her, so it could have some legs.

What are your thoughts on mitch, and his read list.

Seems to be all over the place. Doesn't give a comment on Alco, yet gave one to Big Man... who both have the same of posts (0). Gives a scum read to KIF but then says that's just how KIF is. Is null on Magic for not having enough posts, but yet has a lot more substance in those posts than any of Mitch's low post null reads.

Also, not quite sure why he's indy hunting in that list. Like, why Tweet and Lethal?

 

[NotBrutus]

Typical go with the flow Mitch doesn't seem to dare to rock the boat just agree with the typical mafia and town reads I be watching this if Mitch flips scum cause there could be a maf in his null statement

Who from his null lists, do you think is mafia?

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Seems to be all over the place. Doesn't give a comment on Alco, yet gave one to Big Man... who both have the same of posts (0). Gives a scum read to KIF but then says that's just how KIF is. Is null on Magic for not having enough posts, but yet has a lot more substance in those posts than any of Mitch's low post null reads.

Also, not quite sure why he's indy hunting in that list. Like, why Tweet and Lethal?

ok you can have a cookie

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Mitch should be in claim territory now, @Mitch Perfect

 

[Daddy Deville]

Tbh @NotBrutus I can't really say but I wouldn't put it past him to do it if he is mafia personally I think Poyser/Smark/Mitch are high scum reads. I put Tweetums & Darth as slight leans as well.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Tbh @NotBrutus I can't really say but I wouldn't put it past him to do it if he is mafia personally I think Poyser/Smark/Mitch are high scum reads. I put Tweetums & Darth as slight leans as well.

I'm interested in this read, do tell.

 

[NotBrutus]

Big Man being tagged lol

Wasn't it a running gag he doesn't show up for Day 1?