Barry Presents: Whodunnit 2: The West Smithton Sagas GAME THREAD

[Poyser]

I dont even make one post and I'm suspects lol this game on this site

I am reading through post now

 

[Banez]

vote banez

awful entrance

What makes it awful? It's what i gathered reading the fluff and no point posts.

Banez, why do you think I’m voting Poyser?

To either

1) Gauge a reaction.
2) See if anyone jumps the train blindly.
3) To appear active while not really doing anything.

One of the three. Feel free to tell me how i'm wrong and 'm terrible player

Also "Why do you want to lynch Poyser this early?" Because, if he's scum, he'll obviously become harder to lynch as the game goes on???

If Poyser is scum then Banez is too

Wow what a 10/10 insight.

fucking genius over here.

 

[Tweet]

1) because he isn't trying to pressure me early when it makes no sense to. Scum Odo does that a LOT.
2) I never said I read Tweet scum, I could go either way. He's been rather sensible and level-headed but that seems out of character this early on. Reads are not necessarily connected, and when I get more reads that'll be more obvious
3) See above. Reason for my read is: the arrive-vote-leave strategy is scummy, but isn't that usual N0M anti-Mafia at this point?

Second person to say me being sensible is out of character

 

[Sky]

Wow what a 10/10 insight.

fucking genius over here.

Why didn't you understand it, then?

 

[Poyser]

On tweet, who I also saw smth in. this isnt the case here as mitch is quite an unknown and I dont think you have a track record of catching him do you?

Anyways, I'm more interested in banez, for now.

Wasn’t game show where I banged lethal on one post also the one where you side kicked me? Just find it odd to see you draw the line here with Mitch who I think I made a pretty good point on, when you don’t usually have a problem with me going after players based on one post

 

[Odo]

I of course might be wrong, but it seems like Poyser is just latching on to any clumsy post that folks such as Mitch or OMB are making

 

[Sky]

I dont even make one post and I'm suspects lol this game on this site

I am reading through post now

This guy looks SHAKEN

 

[Poyser]

I of course might be wrong, but it seems like Poyser is just latching on to any clumsy post that folks such as Mitch or OMB are making

Well I’m not pushing OMB at all but yes I did find his post about being a suspect when he’s not quite funny

and anyway reacting to dumb as fuck posts is like 99% of the fun of playing mafia on this site

 

[Odo]

What makes it awful? It's what i gathered reading the fluff and no point posts.



To either

1) Gauge a reaction.
2) See if anyone jumps the train blindly.
3) To appear active while not really doing anything.

One of the three. Feel free to tell me how i'm wrong and 'm terrible player



Wow what a 10/10 insight.

fucking genius over here.

Interesting that option 4, I saw something you didn’t didn’t come to mind

I only tell people they are terrible when they bring bullshit to a knife fight. New year, new me and all that

 

[Odo]

Wasn’t game show where I banged lethal on one post also the one where you side kicked me? Just find it odd to see you draw the line here with Mitch who I think I made a pretty good point on, when you don’t usually have a problem with me going after players based on one post

except you had a years worth of data with lethal, whereas I’m pretty sure Mitch hasnt been scum with us around?

 

[Canadian Dragon]

^^

 

[Kross Rhodes]

Hello

I of course might be wrong, but it seems like Poyser is just latching on to any clumsy post that folks such as Mitch or OMB are making

Seems to be the case.

 

[Odo]

You still going with Mitch = scum btw, or is Smark your primary lean?

 

[Tweet]

unvote
vote Poyser

So this little push of him on Mitch was dropped as soon as it started, which gets me back to thinking it was just another diversion.

 

[Poyser]

except you had a years worth of data with lethal, whereas I’m pretty sure Mitch hasnt been scum with us around?

Yes but I’m also a good player that is pretty good at catching people early on. My issue isn’t with him not following me btw, my issue is with him taking issue with it as in “would lynch poyser” based off of it when it’s something I regularly do as pointed out to Tweet last game and as he has said here as well. Not having played with someone as scum before isn’t going to stop me from trying to read them lol, that’s weird.

also I don’t have a scum lean on smark? Never said I did lol, my vote on him was a joke for making the same joke I did. Mitch is who I’m pushing