Worst Storylines in Wrestling History

[Bobby Barrows]

This is a similar discussion topic to LadyHotRod's Worst Championship Reigns of all times, but will be based on storytelling instead of championship reigns. Give your opinion on what you believe is one of the worst storylines ever in the history of professional wrestling.


​

My first pick would be the very obvious face turn of Invader #1, or Jose Gonzalez, in WWC after he murdered Bruiser Brody, up to and including the fucking stabbing angle they did the next year where Gonzalez "stabbed" Atsushi Onita in 1990. I don't think there's any storyline that tops this as far as bad fucking taste goes.

 

[Cwalker]

Two words:

Katie Vick

 

[Lady Redfield]

Mae Young giving birth to a hand will forever be one of the top for me. Pretty much any storyline with her was stupid, but, that one stands alone as the absolute worst.

 

[Dale]

Honory mention to the Anonymous Raw GM, that shit was fucking garbage

 

[Kiffy Lube]

Katie Vick is a masterpiece.

Bad storylines for me would just be sumthin' bland like TNA tryin' to make Crimson their Goldberg. He was just borin' as fuck.

 

[Cwalker]

How bout that time Kevin Nash texted himself and let to a shit sledgehammer on a pole match

 

[Gentleman Jake]

Mae Young giving birth to a hand will forever be one of the top for me. Pretty much any storyline with her was stupid, but, that one stands alone as the absolute worst.

I tend to agree with this


Hornswoggle McMahon was also dog shot


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

 

[Mitch Buchannon]

That Undead Realm bullshit

Claire fucking Lynch


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Mitch Buchannon]

Also James Storm murdering Mickie James


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[King Kota]

Lashley/Zayn broc/Cain

 

[Sky]

Every single storyline involving Lita and Kane from 2004-2005. The rape, the forcible marriage, the miscarriage by Snitsky, and the cheating with Edge in a cruel parody of the actual Lita/Edge/Matt Hardy affair. It's not just terrible television, it's morally repugnant.

 

[Mox Girl]

How bout that time Kevin Nash texted himself and let to a shit sledgehammer on a pole match

Least that provided us with "OMG Kevin Nash, WTF thought he was dead LOL"

 

[Chris]

Least that provided us with "OMG Kevin Nash, WTF thought he was dead LOL"

Yeah Punk was gold in it but that almost makes me even more upset bc that was NOT what I wanted him doing after the Summer of Punk at least he got the strap back come Survivor Series

 

[Lady Redfield]

Oh man, the Samoa Joe being kidnapped angle made an abrupt appearance in my memories upon revisiting this thread.

 

[Cwalker]

Aces and Eights. They were Retribution until Bully Ray got involved