• Welcome to "The New" Wrestling Smarks Forum!

    I see that you are not currently registered on our forum. It only takes a second, and you can even login with your Facebook! If you would like to register now, pease click here: Register

    Once registered please introduce yourself in our introduction thread which can be found here: Introduction Board


Success after Roh?

Matthew Edwards

Member
There have been a lot wrestlers that have been in Roh that have gone on to have a successful carrer in bigger promotions like Samao Joe and Cm Punk. Who do you think has had the biggest breakout success?:drinks_pepsi:
 

ROHisWrestling

Member
Samoa Joe, despite not becoming a World Champion yet (which isnt his fault) he has had some AMAZING matches in TNA and is..imo, the biggest professional wrestling star to ever come from Ring Of Honor
 

The Rated R CMStar

Guest
CM Punk in my view. WWE is bigger than TNA, and to already have critics and expecialist pushing him to main event Wrestlemania has to tell something, besides, he is already a World Champ.
 

Great One

Guest
Amazing matches in a 2nd rate company =/= success. CM Punk is already and will become a much bigger star than Samoa Joe.
 

phantomgerald

Guest
Definately CM Punk, because he's establish himself in WWE and he's so good that WWE didn't feel the need to "personalise" him. If Joe was in WWE, he would probably have a Umaga-like gimmick and be released five years later.
 

Soulpower

Guest
CM Punk. He's gotten over with the majority of the live crowds, (even outpopping DX and the Hardys last year) he's the champion of one of the three brands, and has simply gotten more exposure that Samoa Joe has. SO for now its Punk.... Until Joe finally goes to WWE, that is.
 

Matthew Edwards

Member
You know you guys & gals don't have to just pick those two names. I was just using those two big names as just examples!:red_bandana:
 

JHar888

Member
No offense, but you can make some silly threads. Anyways, I'd say CM Punk. He's defeated some of the greatest superstars in WWE, including Edge, Randy Orton, John Morrison, and Big Daddy V. Joe has been in some great matches, but Punk is more of a "fan favorite."
 

Matthew Edwards

Member
JHar888 said:
No offense, but you can make some silly threads. Anyways, I'd say CM Punk. He's defeated some of the greatest superstars in WWE, including Edge, Randy Orton, John Morrison, and Big Daddy V. Joe has been in some great matches, but Punk is more of a "fan favorite."
Click to expand...


Opinions vary!:fish:
 

RaVeN*

New Member
CM Punk. He is the ECW champion. Joe, former x-divison champion. CM Punk will have a better career unless Joe goes to the WWE.
 

Montana

Guest
I'd say CM Punk out of the two. Although i think Colt Cobana has a good chance to becoming perhaps a bigger star than cm punk in the long run. To me his style fits the wwe much better. He has more size, and he's a real entertainer. CM Punk is mainly a great/promo guy, but has been involved with anything majorly entertaining.
 

Matthew Edwards

Member
Montana said:
I'd say CM Punk out of the two. Although i think Colt Cobana has a good chance to becoming perhaps a bigger star than cm punk in the long run. To me his style fits the wwe much better. He has more size, and he's a real entertainer. CM Punk is mainly a great/promo guy, but has been involved with anything majorly entertaining.
Click to expand...


Like I told everybody earlier. You can pick anybody from roh. I does not have just those two!:bb:
 

thedeadite

Member
eddie guerrero?
matt hardy?
jeff hardy?

..... ;) they were technically IN ROH ...kinda...for a match or so that is....... then left to go back to the big leagues to be huge stars again... ;)

..though i am kidding
I'd say Punk has had the most fame, followed by Joe, but I agree that Cabana has a chance to surpass both.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top