Ys Origin Mafia - Game Thread

[Comrade Khan]

The least convoluted is to just not use the WIFOM from the fact he edited his post.

I mean, I haven't. Think of it this way, how often in games have we thought someone had made an obvi slip and it turned out to just be bad phrasing? I'd say 9 times out of 10 it hasn't been a slip in my experience.

 

[Odo]

I mean if you guys really want to let a guy get a town confirm based on an edit that’s on you guys.

nah, the onus is on you to give a rational explanation that doesn’t revolve around CP being an idiot or a cheat

 

[Rugrat]

How is my play "has to be town"

But now i'm light blue? So you're not that sure i'm town anymore.

Why do you talk yourself praising you read me perfect but yet your list seems you're not that sure anymore?

I dont think you are town, you could be faking vanilla cop for all we know, it's not out of possibilities and it could have been given as scum fake.

So you think I’m faking vanilla cop? You are aware if you’re legit I could just not claim it at all, let you die then just have my team roleblock the vig until he’s lynched.

No I’m not sure you’re town, because another player who has no agenda to lie is claiming info on you. There’s a lot of moving parts in mafia so just because I have a perfect record of reading you, it doesn’t mean it will stay consistent.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I think you should duel magic

he’s probs scum and if he isn’t, well laugh about it for months to come

But we wouldn't see the flip until the game is over...so...to that I say no.

 

[Smart Marx]

nah, the onus is on you to give a rational explanation that doesn’t revolve around CP being an idiot or a cheat

I don’t care about his edit at all. I think he’s scum based on things completely nothing to do with that edit.

 

[Smart Marx]

But we wouldn't see the flip until the game is over...so...to that I say no.

This. Magic is off limits until he’s unfrozen imo.

 

[Rugrat]

FWIW CP was one of the main people criticising Magic for editing posts in MCU.

Is Banez a mong? If he’s scum, this is all time abysmal play.

 

[CraigPelton]

eh? I edit posts more than anyone. I've never criticized anyone for editing unless it was way late or done for cheating purposes, i.e magic and smark in that one game. in my view editing within 1-2 mins is fair game. that's always been my stance/practice.

 

[Alco]

What happened to dueling Banezie

 

[Comrade Khan]

scenes if the scum team is smark magic MP and banez im gonna die laughing tho Xp

 

[Odo]

You realise that if he is scum, you’ve basically lost with that stance right?

 

[Rugrat]

eh? I edit posts more than anyone. I've never criticized anyone for editing unless it was way late or done for cheating purposes, i.e magic and smark in that one game. in my view editing within 1-2 mins is fair game. that's always been my stance/practice.

You haven’t read the thread properly boyo

 

[Comrade Khan]

What happened to dueling Banezie

its still on the table for me fwiw. im personally waiting from input from phenom n bigs

 

[CraigPelton]

You haven’t read the thread properly boyo

then explain the misunderstanding?

 

[Smart Marx]

You realise that if he is scum, you’ve basically lost with that stance right?

Magic? Do you just want to kill him on the off chance he could be scum without knowing until it’s over?