Ys Origin Mafia - Game Thread

[Odo]

yes it has been a scum role

no it is not a token role, and the usage doesn’t make sense from a scum perspective at all

 

[Banez]

Grim is Barry, MP is MP, apparently not from WF but knows quite a lot about all of us.

Banez, you got any ideas why you're still alive, what with your grand plan and all?

I'm still alive because i'm easy lynch candidate.

Why waste a night kill on someone like me.

 

[Lethal]

Anyway;

Vote: Banez

This is a vote to lynch. I may reconsider if something else comes up, or he answers the question.

 

[Banez]

 

[Odo]

Well I have to contend that my first thought was: imagine if Magic told his scum team to petrify him as a way of getting out from under the pressure.

It's WIFOM-territory though.

Regarding the exchanges of Magic and you and Rugrat yesterday, I was pretty much in team Rug/Odo throughout. Magic's read of CP felt disingenuous to me as well and if anything it established town leans of Rugrat and you in my eyes. CP's reactions afterwards were interesting as well. If I want to believe he's scum, then it looked like him purposefully distancing himself from Magic at the time. I wonder how his play will pick up now that he's got more time to play (according to himself)

EDIT: this was a reply to @Odo

For reasons I gave yesterday, both of them being scum doesn’t fit. Aware CP gave some raisins about his work which I’m inclined to believe, but I just think more of the game would look like the last 12 hours if they were scum together

Also his duel not hijacking the lynch looks good for him too?

The fact that the petrify doesn’t give the flip looks like it was intentionally designed to make you not want to kill the player ... everything says it’s a play to me

 

[Lethal]

Wow

 

[Hohenheim of Light]

For me, Smark is playing similarly to last game, so I'd say I'm pretty positive about him.

Grim (who's MP, I guess?) hasn't really stood out to me (despite having 100 posts apparently, wow). There was one instance where he clearly echoed Rugrat's suggestion of CP dueling Magic and at the time I thought it was odd how he seemingly took on a Rugrat opinion as if it were his own. Other than that, I'm fairly null about him.

ty for your thoughts

I am currently in favour of killing magic today, the petrify feels like a PLAY to me

wonder if scum would voluntarily give up one of their votes for a day?

under the assumption that Jeff will return to lead an MP lynch before I post again:

3-shot watcher. Watched Jeffatron Last night and no one visited him. Why? Cos he’s claimed mason, self explanatory

Limited Watcher’s kinda weak tbh, would have been even more of a Hail Mary if not for the mason claims.

Gotta wake up in 4 hours, cya. If I’m lynched before I’m back to catch up tonight, Have fun!

the most likely role to target jeff last night was town bg, as I doubt scum would want to shoot a mason just to confirm the other. Role usage makes more sense as scum than town imo.

unvote
vote MyP

I'm still alive because i'm easy lynch candidate.

Why waste a night kill on someone like me.

some like you as in vanilla townie or Mr. Banez?

 

[Hohenheim of Light]

For reasons I gave yesterday, both of them being scum doesn’t fit. Aware CP gave some raisins about his work which I’m inclined to believe, but I just think more of the game would look like the last 12 hours if they were scum together

Also his duel not hijacking the lynch looks good for him too?

The fact that the petrify doesn’t give the flip looks like it was intentionally designed to make you not want to kill the player ... everything says it’s a play to me

Reading over the petrify mechanics, I'm not sure this idea suits magic, who may feel he could defend himself out of any hole.

 

[Hohenheim of Light]

Caught me

also phenom being around 5 minutes before night was posted and disappearing is a shocker.

 

[Lethal]

Is there any logical explanation for why nobody died last night? Scum kill was blocked (or protected or not submitted), vig (if there is one) was blocked/protected/not submitted, and the SK (again, if there is one) was blocked/protected/not submitted.

Would the petrification have something to do with it?

 

[Hohenheim of Light]

Is there any logical explanation for why nobody died last night? Scum kill was blocked (or protected or not submitted), vig (if there is one) was blocked/protected/not submitted, and the SK (again, if there is one) was blocked/protected/not submitted.

Would the petrification have something to do with it?

Well..

I think we can safely rule out sk wrt to what Haza's role might've been if he got far enough.

Vig may not be there or is a coward.

Petrification could be a kill-modifier.

Petrify mechanics:
A petrified player will be considered temporarily dead, meaning they cannot post, vote or use roles and they will not count towards majority.
They will not flip like a dead player however.
Petrified players can be targeted with roles and killed and lynched like any other player.
If a petrified player is killed or lynched, they will shatter and their flip will only be revealed to the Darklings.

There is but one way to lift the curse...

Maybe there's a player that can unpetrify.

 

[Hohenheim of Light]

no it is not a token role, and the usage doesn’t make sense from a scum perspective at all

It makes even less sense from a town perspective.

 

[Tweet]

Vote Count
​

PHEN0M​	1 (Alco)
Banez​	1 (Darth Lethal)
MyPrerogative​	2 (Hohenheim of Light)

21 hours remaining in Day 2.
With 15 alive it takes 8 votes to lynch.​

 

[Comrade Khan]

There is def someone who can unpetrify, look at the last line of tweets petrify. Rad no one died though.

 

[Odo]

Nah, cause jeff is both useful and pseudo confirmed, watching him kinda makes sense, it’s just not what I would have dinet