Ys Origin Mafia - Game Thread

[Rugrat]

Since there’s a reasonable chance the petrifier could be town, I think we should take Magic being the victim as NAI.

 

[Lethal]

So he's suggesting the note passer is a weak vig? Am I reading that correctly?

 

[Lethal]

And people doubted a duellist and vig being of the same alignment, not as one taking the place of the other.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Well, unless I'm reading that wrong. Magic is still technically "dead" regardless. He doesn't count for total players either afaik. So I can see why Rugrat would say this. Scum would have to waste their shot on an already "dead" player to see their flip.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Liek the petrified player doesn't just become unpetrified from what I'm seeing either, so I could buy as it buying the town vig role actually.

edit: that being said, why would they also be a note passer is beyond me. that part is a bit tougher to swallow.

goddamit lol

 

[Smart Marx]

I’d like to know why you think CP is scum based on what we’ve seen so far?

Alco and Banez always look lazy / strange so not really interested in them atm

This just doesn’t feel like an engaged town CP to me. Most of his posts are very flippant and trolly the very few that he made on day one. I also don’t like the whole he claimed his town character thing in the edited out and then I was like oh don’t mod kill me sir.

Claiming Dawson also feels like a crutch he’s using to get by because he knows he can use it. Especially if we can give him a pool the players with possibly a town choice in there so he can go I’ll be this is the guys you gave me guys. I don’t know I just I know I just feel like he’s worth pursuing. I mean he might not be scum but I think he might be so I don’t know I think it’s a good direction.

 

[Smart Marx]

So he's suggesting the note passer is a weak vig? Am I reading that correctly?

That’s what’s been suggested but I don’t see it from what I’m seeing right now.

 

[Rugrat]

I'm really starting to not like Rugrat today.

Ok

I’m not so sure about that. For one the duelist could take place in front of the vigilante but I don’t believe that’s what’s happening if you pick up on what may or may not have been said today. Unless I’m way off base on that. As for the the petrifying I don’t think that could be town why would a town player ever give their flip specifically to the scum team?

If they are petrified they player cannot vote, post or use roles which isn’t much dissimilar to what happens to a dead player hence me thinking it’s a weak vig. The petrifier not being a full vig or the player’s flip being revealed only to scum is just a handicap to town to weaken it. Since we have limited setup knowledge I don’t think we should be deciding they are scum already

 

[Comrade Khan]

This just doesn’t feel like an engaged town CP to me. Most of his posts are very flippant and trolly the very few that he made on day one. I also don’t like the whole he claimed his town character thing in the edited out and then I was like oh don’t mod kill me sir.

Claiming Dawson also feels like a crutch he’s using to get by because he knows he can use it. Especially if we can give him a pool the players with possibly a town choice in there so he can go I’ll be this is the guys you gave me guys. I don’t know I just I know I just feel like he’s worth pursuing. I mean he might not be scum but I think he might be so I don’t know I think it’s a good direction.

wtf is a dawson

 

[Smart Marx]

Dawson supposed to be duelist I don’t know why that AutoCorrect it to that.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Ok



If they are petrified they player cannot vote, post or use roles which isn’t much dissimilar to what happens to a dead player hence me thinking it’s a weak vig. The petrifier not being a full vig or the player’s flip being revealed only to scum is just a handicap to town to weaken it. Since we have limited setup knowledge I don’t think we should be deciding they are scum already

Look at Tweet's post. literally says "temporarily dead". It's a reversable kill shot imo

 

[Comrade Khan]

Dawson supposed to be duelist I don’t know why that AutoCorrect it to that.

 

[Odo]

Eh I was expecting something more concrete

vote stands

 

[Smart Marx]

Ok



If they are petrified they player cannot vote, post or use roles which isn’t much dissimilar to what happens to a dead player hence me thinking it’s a weak vig. The petrifier not being a full vig or the player’s flip being revealed only to scum is just a handicap to town to weaken it. Since we have limited setup knowledge I don’t think we should be deciding they are scum already

Seems more like a kill shot for scum to me because I don’t see why a town week vig any kind would ever give their kills flip only to the scum team it doesn’t make sense to me.

 

[Rugrat]

Look at Tweet's post. literally says "temporarily dead". It's a reversable kill shot imo

We’ve seen town arsonists and poisoners so I’m not taking that for guaranteed