Ys Origin Mafia - Game Thread

[Rugrat]

Still mesmerised as to why people are reading Barry town to be honest.

because Smark is supposedly good at reading him

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Still mesmerised as to why people are reading Barry town to be honest.

Unlike you, I had to earn my town reads.

 

[Odo]

Think about it, a role that can railroad town into effectively lynching scum balanced with a role that can turn the vote in scum's favour. Or a role with strong voting power counteracted with the ability to create situations where there is no good vote.

Those aren’t reliable examples

 

[Smart Marx]

I’m fairly certain Barry is town if you take any credence from my reads on him. Both play and his soft claim.

 

[Odo]

So er, seems magic gave up the ghost right?

 

[Rugrat]

So er, seems magic gave up the ghost right?

He’s been caught out. He was lying about his reasons for CP’s town read

 

[Showtime]

If it isn’t immediately clear, I think CP is likelier town than magic based on current conversations

if you think im scum then no one should bother listening to you anyways so that's swell cause god that's an awful read.

 

[Showtime]

People quiz others on reads. Surely giving the third best player of the last decade a town lean after five posts - of which only three had content is prematurw



No. I think he’s town myself.



the claim section you’ve just tacked on now. You’re initial point was that he was “genuine”.

CP should duel you tomorrow tbhtbh

nah, im the goat. there's no such thing as premature.


the claim section and post is the only post i read, do you want me to refuse this?


how fucking bad are yall actually playing? do you think this is hard to prove? one of my posts pretty much comes directly after cp's posts. i hadn't read any of his other posts, so it could only come from that claiming post. what other post would come off as genuine to me? the ones i didn't read? do you want me to show this?

 

[Leon TrotSky]

if you think im scum then no one should bother listening to you anyways so that's swell cause god that's an awful read.

So

How does that make you town?

 

[Odo]

if you think im scum then no one should bother listening to you anyways so that's swell cause god that's an awful read.

Huh

 

[Showtime]

I’ve never had an actual read on him, based on there being virtually nothing to read him off (I didn’t notice the claim), so no, you’re wrong on that

If your read of him is based on the claim (which if true would make him almost certainly town as scum won’t have redundant character fakes), why is it only a ‘weak’ town read?

idk cause that's a wifom reason to read someone town and not really play based/meta based. if someone strongly pings as town you give them a strong town read, if they don't they don't.

 

[Odo]

It’s a no from me

 

[Showtime]

read the last few pages, magic seems like scum lol

I don't believe him

the last time i was scum and in a game you three(odo/rugrat/cp) got spanked so hard that cp retired. it was a sweep and it wasn't close. "you were the confirmed godfather" wah wah wah, like poyser was the next game and i got him myself so again, dont bother

if yall wanna lose this game on day 2 thinking you can suddenly read me now and my reasons, which are entirely legit, then go for it. ima keep reading back at my own pace tho. i think my reads are pretty good thus far so even if im not fully caught up ill be doing fine finding enough town.

 

[Tweet]

~10 hours remaining in Night 1.
Friendly reminder to send your roles in or notify me if you're not going to use them.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

This Magic guy seems disingenuous.