2. Big Man
3. Jeffatron
4. Juice Tearjerker#2
5. Char Aznable
7. Odo Laughable Chimp
8. Alco
9. Darth Lethal
10. TheRedPrince
12. Showtime
13. Sexpun T'Come
15. Hohenheim of Light
16. Rugrat
Starting to come around to CP, actually. From memory he did seem hesitant to duel at first. I don't know why some are acting as if he was super trigger happy. He even posted "why the rush for dueling" or something along those lines. He's by no means a town leader this game though, which he's been in the past. If I believe Rugrat to be town, then Barry should be town too, unless he's the GF.
Magic's probably town because no way is petrifier a town role by this point.
HoL by the looks of it, was in a duel with Smark 1 and then completely changed that when Smark 2 came around, which doesn't make a ton of sense since both are actually different players, in-game wise.
I can't decide between Odo/Chimp and Big Man who would complete the team.