Ys Origin Mafia - Game Thread

[Smart Marx]

why do I feel like you've been trolling all game?

Nah, that post on second look clearly shows a man that knows HOL will flip scum and you need to discredit me early because you know of the implication when he does. If you wanna assume I'm trolling, feel free.

 

[Rugrat]

I'd rather lynch an inactive than HOL because he's actually been posting but even then it's meh because it's a total guess when people don't post much

magic was who I wanted to lynch today but the petrify complicates things since only scum would get his flip right now

which one? just saying "an inactive" has little precision so won't convince people of your direction.

 

[CraigPelton]

no I readily accept that if HOL flips scum people are gonna lynch me, that's fine

what I'm saying is you're not making any sense

 

[Smart Marx]

I also have most everyone else in my town reads column. Other than CP and HOL, maybe Big Man, maybe Juice, maybe Rugrat if he lied.

 

[CraigPelton]

which one? just saying "an inactive" has little precision so won't convince people of your direction.

read the whole sentence mate I'm not really keen on randomly lynching an inactive either but we might end up having to

 

[Smart Marx]

no I readily accept that if HOL flips scum people are gonna lynch me, that's fine

what I'm saying is you're not making any sense

Put it this way, I have only 6 people left in my POE and you and HOL are the only two I want to lynch that isn't a let's lynch inactive POE.

 

[Rugrat]

I also have most everyone else in my town reads column. Other than CP and HOL, maybe Big Man, maybe Juice, maybe Rugrat if he lied.

lied about what?

 

[CraigPelton]

you just made up that reason right now tho, you didn't say this before

 

[Smart Marx]

lied about what?

People think you lied about being a VT cop. I'm not one of them, hence me listing it last.

 

[Rugrat]

read the whole sentence mate I'm not really keen on randomly lynching an inactive either but we might end up having to

I did. There's no point lynching a player who can't vote, post or use roles for the time being though - and in addition we won't even know it's an accurate read.

 

[Smart Marx]

you just made up that reason right now tho, you didn't say this before

I've mentioned my long town reads many, many times. When I first followed Odo on you I even said it.

Odo was also the one who wanted to go for you and I just followed that first day because I didn't want to go for a town read.

 

[CraigPelton]

I'd be down to lynch PHEN0M for confidently saying there's no vt cop as I could see him saying that independent of Rugrat's alignment but I'm not sure town PHEN0M would be that confident about a scum read or that antagonistic as to cause a mislynch

town PHEN0M is often useless but I don't think he's malignant

 

[Rugrat]

People think you lied about being a VT cop. I'm not one of them, hence me listing it last.

it's just Phenom (I believe) who is PoE fodder. Maybe some other mongs hopped on that spec idk

 

[CraigPelton]

I did. There's no point lynching a player who can't vote, post or use roles for the time being though - and in addition we won't even know it's an accurate read.

that's my stated position on lynching magic too tho

 

[CraigPelton]

I've mentioned my long town reads many, many times. When I first followed Odo on you I even said it.

Odo was also the one who wanted to go for you and I just followed that first day because I didn't want to go for a town read.

you had the game POE'd down on day 1 before most people had claimed anything or anyone had flipped? dang what a legend