Match of the year: The Shield's match against Cena/Sheamus/Ryback at Elimination Chamber. Even though there were matches that told better stories, you know what those are. Really enjoyed the utter chaos in this match, and after a year of bitching about superbooking it was so cathartic to see these guys job to really good talent.
Promo/segment of the year: Mark Henry's "retirement" speech. We'll be talking about that one for years, unlike any other promo this year.
Superstar of the year: It's Daniel Bryan and not even close. He's the first babyface that the crowd is 100% behind since Punk in 2011, so of course he'll be turning heel soon ;_;
Diva of the year: Summer Rae. Have been loving her heel work in NXT, although it's really hard to not go Emma here. There was a week where Kaitlyn and AJ was a good feud, but other than that the Divas have had such terrible chauvinistic writing that it's unintentionally making Emma awesome.
Manager/valet of the year: Heyman. He's being used to progress storylines and not just yell stuff for no reason, so he's being productive. Most of them don't get heat on the guy they're managing, but just associating himself with Heyman has done wonders for Curtis Axel
Arena of the year: idc
Crowd of the year: Was definitely the Raw after Mania. Best crowd ever, not just tonight. They need a Hall of Fame spot.
Pay-per-view of the year: It was definitely Payback. Best PPV since MITB 2011. Almost every match was good to great, the booking was both memorable and specacular... Yeah. No complaints
Rivalry of the year: Lol'ed at Lockard's answer, but have to go Cena and Henry. Henry's so damn good in this role that it's sad to know he's probably another guy in Cena's path. Please give him the belt, WWE.
Something you've really liked: I love the new, fresh booking we're getting nowadays. It's not perfect, but the show feels refreshed and nowhere near as stale. And just in a few months it seems like they've went from little ME caliber talent to having too much to feature effectively. That's a good problem to have. All the right people are being pushed the right way.
Something you've really disliked: WWE still thinking 3 hour Raw is a good idea. At least 4 members of this forum agreed Raw was really good this week but still had trouble staying awake since it was just too damn long. Also the Ryback heel turn.
Debut of the year: Follow the buzzards...
Attire of the year: Summer Rae wearing the skimpiest Divas' attire we've seen in a while, good grief. Does that even count as attire? Not complaining though.
Commentator of the year: JBL. He's so entertaining, and doing his best to carry the commentary on his back right now. Wish they had a two-man announce team so he can speak up more.
Pre-show/kickoff of the year: Sheamus vs Sandow, because watching Sheamus get kicked off the card was fucking glorious. Yay smiley. No surprise, the best PPV in 2 years was the one without Sheamus on it.
Move of the year: Does "the Yes Lock with the kendo stick" count? Since that's the one that comes to mind.
Show of the year: NXT. It's had like 2 bad episodes all year, you always feel good by the end of it. Aww yeah.
RAW of the year: Raw after Mania. You might say "oh, it was only because of the crowd", but it made the show so damn entertaining. That's part of it.
SmackDown of the year: The one where Daniel Bryan snapped and destroyed the Shield all by his lonesome.
Return of the year: Jericho at the Rumble, we all orgasmed over that one.