Evans I'm not about to requote your case on me cause it's huge, so lemme respond to points you make from top to bottom.
Understandable - apologies for shit formatting / any noob errors involved
First off I'm not about to make sense of anything Sky did or didn't do, I'm just telling you how her posts look to me, her not being on Brutus at the end of the phase is something she'd have to explain herself.
You said it was literally impossible for them to be aligned, now you're not going to try and make sense of it? That's contradictory.
If you think OMB and I tried to set up a mislynch on Alco, you're not taking into account that a) there wasn't particularly much to set up there, Alco was headed for a lynch without us pushing anything, and b) we never actually did push a mislynch on him but rather quickly accepted the fact that Alco going nowhere n1 looks good for him. Not to mention it was OMBs info that turned out to conform with Alcos claimed action and went a good way towards most people now thinking that they're probably both legit. If anything you could perhaps make a case that it's OMB and Alco who are faking usages to synergize with one another, but then I have to wonder what role I am playing in that entire ordeal. Also Alco has a proven kill so he's most definitely legit.
Agree 100% on Alco being town and OMB faking usage. I think there's more to the eye with OMBs claim. Alco wouldn't be a hard mislynch target at that point as a lot of people were reading him scum for inactivity. I think OMBs usage claim was a gamble to make himself look good whilst a nothing result wouldn't clear Alco (in the situation he didn't claim to shoot Magic that is).
As for Brutus, I was preoccupied with doing my own stuff during d1, and lately I've adopted this mentality that during the early phases the one I can trust most is myself when it comes to honest intentions behind pushing people. You've only just begun to play with us again, but I can definitely tell you that me being wrong on stuff is anything but rare lately, I'm more wrong about stuff than I am right and this game just continues that trend.
Fair enough.
I used the role I stole from Brutus to clear someone who was in everybodys POE, seems perfectly normal to do and change your opinion according to the results. You gotta ask yourself if it's really a good idea for me as scum to clear Rugrat who was super mislynchable at that point instead of just going for that mislynch, because if you look at towns current POE you'll find that mislynches seem to be hard to find in the current field.
I didn't realize we were randomly mass claiming that day, if we weren't there wouldn't have been any reason for Rugrat to claim since I could confirm that he's town.
Changing your view based on results makes sense. Unless Rugrat is scum with you
I don't really buy the last part unfortunately - it may be the case but I don't agree with it. Mass claim had been discussed for a while. You jumping the gun ahead of N0M to clear Rugrat as he looks so mislynchable is what bothers me when I partner it with the other suspicions of you.
It just didn't sit right with me and apologies again that I can't quite put it into a comprehensive post.
I wanted to claim last because Grave Digger is one of the more common go-to scum fakes and if someone else claims that role I can instantly CC and catch scum. It was a low percentage play and probably not necessary but you know, small gains.
I never really defended Chrisv2 from getting lynched, the point I was trying to make is that I thought the "Chimp held up night by not submitting his role" theory was very thin to begin with and not really worth considering.
I'm not too familiar with the GD role, so I can't really dispute this part.
2012 GOAT BAYBAYYYYYYY
