WS Mafia: Reloaded - GAME THREAD

[Showtime]

@Showtime who would have been your main shooting targets if you were scum last night?

phen0m i guess?

this would vary based on who your teammates are and if they're under suspicion or not/who has right and wrong reads.

 

[Showtime]

1. XENUS #1 - obvious scum
2. Haza - I'm feeling pretty good on Haza, playing completely different from last game
3. Rugrat - feeling good on Rugrat
4. Barry (Grimhail Gorbachev) E-V v2 - I'm putting null only due to the fact that I feel E-V could be indy
5. PHEN0M
7. Jeff - feeling confident that Jeff is town
9. CP - null on CP, leaning town though
10. Mitch - i know I'm town
11. Skybox/OMB - I'm feeling better on Sky/OMB, the fact that OMB came in asking what's happening makes me think OMB is town
12. Tweet - null on Tweet
13. Lethal - as annoying as he has been I feel Lethal is town
14. Magic - I feel Magic is scum, his posting pattern has been different from games he's been town
15. Alco - null on Alco
16. Laughable Chimpy Chris v2 - null but we will see now that a more active person is in
18. BANEZY - feeling pretty good on Banez
20. Odo - null on Odo, really hard to read this game

why do you have me as scum?

this seems like a combination of rugrat and big man's reads lol.

 

[Comrade Khan]

phen0m i guess?

this would vary based on who your teammates are and if they're under suspicion or not/who has right and wrong reads.

Yea thats fair. Forget it for now, not enough info outed to make enough conclusions about the kill count

 

[RDK]

1. XENUS #1 - obvious scum
2. Haza - I'm feeling pretty good on Haza, playing completely different from last game
3. Rugrat - feeling good on Rugrat
4. Barry (Grimhail Gorbachev) E-V v2 - I'm putting null only due to the fact that I feel E-V could be indy
5. PHEN0M
7. Jeff - feeling confident that Jeff is town
9. CP - null on CP, leaning town though
10. Mitch - i know I'm town
11. Skybox/OMB - I'm feeling better on Sky/OMB, the fact that OMB came in asking what's happening makes me think OMB is town
12. Tweet - null on Tweet
13. Lethal - as annoying as he has been I feel Lethal is town
14. Magic - I feel Magic is scum, his posting pattern has been different from games he's been town
15. Alco - null on Alco
16. Laughable Chimpy Chris v2 - null but we will see now that a more active person is in
18. BANEZY - feeling pretty good on Banez
20. Odo - null on Odo, really hard to read this game

Why is Xenus obvious scum?

 

[Mitch Buchannon]

Why is Xenus obvious scum?

He has to be, everything he's done especially the Brutus shit reeks of scum

 

[Showtime]

He has to be, everything he's done especially the Brutus shit reeks of scum

can you give me a specific?

 

[RDK]

Thanks Mitch, Magic will be concluding this interview

 

[Big Man]

i town read 6/18 people(not including myself and evans who had already died and not including phen0m who was confirmed without me knowing). so yes, town reading 6/17 unconfirmed people/not including myself when the scum team is like 5/6 people is a big deal as it's leaving little else on the option.

haza was being pushed, i made a point that we're not lynching him multiple times. i told barry/jeff/etc that playing with a grudge was stupid and would cost us. i read them as strong town well before others, not just weak town leans. i made a point to strongly town read jeff that was also being pushed. i did not object to brutus being pushed once you brought up his stuff to me and included him in people im fine with being lynched.

i do town read my scum teammates, that's Blue. you dont just leave them as null/scum reads as that's obvious.

well can't really take out PHEN0M if you didn't know he was confirmed because for all you knew he was still an option but fair point on the other 2. I still think that's enough options as you kill the obvious townies at Night. idetfying the obvious townies is something I'd expect you to be able to do as scum, I don't think Haza was being lynched even if you hadn't said anything, I had already said the wagon is shit before you arrived. not saying you never town read your teammates but when you do do it you're going to town read them if they've done something to make themselves look good which again is something you're good enough to identify yourself even though you're scum with them. my reads are just reads and they might not all be correct.

this isn't enough to dissuade my opinion on you.

Vote Magic

you chose to go after Chris based on the first 15 pages because he wasn't adding much which I noted was weak but you were adamant on lynching him even post claim and now he's flipped town, Brutus was also in the first 15 pages who actively looked bad which I still find hard to believe you missed, and you only acknowledged it after I asked for your opinion on him twice. you're awkward around your teammates because you know your vote holds value which we saw in that game with Jeff as your teammate. I'd expect you to learn from that but this situation was a bit different as you were in the thread a lot later on and there was no discussion on Brutus at the time which again puts you in an awkward spot. and yes I will mention the chimp post even if you think it should be completely dismissed. it was a random post to make, he's inactive as scum yes but why not point that out rather than asking where he is?

 

[Rugrat]

because im confident in my town reads and the wagons are never always one alignment on day 1.

never. ever.

ever.

so it's good spec and works.

Well no, its not good spec. As in this case it hinges on accusing players who have reasonable cases of innocence and helped facilitate a scum lynch.

your theory of NEVER one alignment has been disproved here at the very bottom

Odo's correct on the strongman, Magic and Rugrat are wrong

The fact that the role PM specifies what the role does (bypasses protective roles) means it can be blocked, otherwise it's misleading. And no, roleblocker is not a protective role, jesus H at that.

a roleblocker is a protective role

 

[Big Man]

who do you think out of rugrat/mitch/banez would be scum?


everyone is feel free to answer, ty.

probably rugrat is more likely than mitch, and I'm town reading banez. are you going to give your own opinion?

 

[Big Man]

Mitch copied and pasted my reads list and left me out because I left myself out of my own

 

[Rugrat]

I’d like to see someone with a case come at me

vote Magic

 

[Mitch Buchannon]

Mitch copied and pasted my reads list and left me out because I left myself out of my own

guilty I copied your reads list because it was the first one I saw when I got onto my laptop

@Magic Xenus was completely shitty with the whole Brutus thing when Brutus was clearly scum

I think you're scum because the way you've been posting is very different from when I've played with town Magic. I was feeling okay on you being scum but you being so defensive on me scumreading you and Xenus ups it for me

Vote Magic

 

[RDK]

guilty I copied your reads list because it was the first one I saw when I got onto my laptop

@Magic Xenus was completely shitty with the whole Brutus thing when Brutus was clearly scum

I think you're scum because the way you've been posting is very different from when I've played with town Magic. I was feeling okay on you being scum but you being so defensive on me scumreading you and Xenus ups it for me

Vote Magic

Shouldn't you be voting for the person that is obvious scum and hasn't claimed yet?

 

[PHEN0M]

Vote: Xenus