WS Mafia: Reloaded - GAME THREAD

[Lethal]

Brutus's Odo read was self-contradictory and the main thing that stood out to me

I think all of his town reads are actually town though

PHEN0M, Jeff, Chris, Banez and Odo all town. Noted. You later sussed Odo for indy, not sure if a genuine suss or not.

 

[Lethal]

Gonna go ahead and say it, I should probably stop playing Mafia for a long while. This is the game that made me understand that. It's not enjoyable anymore.

Reason being that when I draw town I keep giving it my best to help town but it's completely pointless as it seems some people just want to view me with suspicion regardless of their own alignment. This game, just when I feel I've finally gotten on the right track of "being useful to town AND not drawing suspicion", not one or the other, imagine my shock when I'm pivoted on. There's absolutely scum recommending I be vigged, and I'd be inclined to say it's Jeff.

Thinking of asking to rep out but we're struggling for players as it is so guess I just suffer on.

 

[Lethal]

it stuck me as odd as well, I wasn't aware they were feuding as brutus has been away from the discord until just recently.

Was Brutus just roleplaying as KIF actually since him and Lethal had a feud in the last few games

I'm not feuding with anybody so Brutus can keep his idiocy to himself, for all I care. 20+ tags calling me a coward. Coming from the guy who hardly posts in the thread as scum because of how easily he gets caught

 

[Lethal]

Kinda ambivalent about killing Chimp, if this was any other player I'd say don't randomly shoot unclaimed roles, but since it's him we'd actually be better off not letting him use the role most of the time. Like if he's the vig for example, getting rid of him means no stray shots flying in the direction of confirmed townies. Vig Chimp makes Vig Lethal look like fucking Lucky Luke.

Oi ease up Hitler's youth, last time around I shot the SK and Godfather. Fucking BP vests

 

[Evans]

Sometimes there's reasons for things that you can't understand D1 and that's a fine thing for there to be. No one needs to know everything straight away.

Could you please provide a read on Magic? I'll assume you missed it the first time than willingly ignored it

Preferably, using examples from the GOAT 2012 era!

 

[Lethal]

Given Brutus' role, I've analysed the voting patterns.

Barry voted Haza, Banez, Brutus, then hopped off to Sky (although Evans unvoted on entry)
CP went Jeff, Brutus, Rugrat, Sky, Big Man (avoiding a vote on Brutus come crunch time)
Skybox went Barry, Jeff, Brutus, Chris, Brutus, Jeff. Puts a whole lot of shade on being 'correct' but wasn't on the wagon and hopped off to go for Jeff. However, she did advocate the lynch for quite some time and it would be suicidal to test the fake claim.
Myself I found Mitch scum and went to bed, went to work, took kids to the youth centre. Would've voted Brutus if I had time.
Magic, Alco, Odo don't put a vote on him at all.
Chimp doesn't vote once.

CP looks the worst coming out of it for mine.

All this speculation could drive a man mental. I'm going to make a cuppa, maybe someone will be on to interact and shoot the breeze re: these thoughts.

 

[Banez]

Nice post Xenus. I liked reading it. About time we get more of people who build up a case or contribute within readback instead of likes of me and few others who just drop insults when getting sussed.

Given Brutus' role, I've analysed the voting patterns.

Barry voted Haza, Banez, Brutus, then hopped off to Sky (although Evans unvoted on entry)
CP went Jeff, Brutus, Rugrat, Sky, Big Man (avoiding a vote on Brutus come crunch time)
Skybox went Barry, Jeff, Brutus, Chris, Brutus, Jeff. Puts a whole lot of shade on being 'correct' but wasn't on the wagon and hopped off to go for Jeff. However, she did advocate the lynch for quite some time and it would be suicidal to test the fake claim.
Myself I found Mitch scum and went to bed, went to work, took kids to the youth centre. Would've voted Brutus if I had time.
Magic, Alco, Odo don't put a vote on him at all.
Chimp doesn't vote once.

CP looks the worst coming out of it for mine.

All this speculation could drive a man mental. I'm going to make a cuppa, maybe someone will be on to interact and shoot the breeze re: these thoughts.

How do you feel about everyone wanting to shoot Chimp?

It just feels like people want Vig to take over someone who's flip would give town VERY little information. Which is why i didn't like CP suggesting it, nor Rugrat.

While i understand he may have a role and may not be around much, shooting him N1 is worst thing vig can do imo. When he could pick someone who's actually been contributing into the thread so we could get some reads and whatnot.

 

[Xenus]

Could you please provide a read on Magic? I'll assume you missed it the first time than willingly ignored it

Preferably, using examples from the GOAT 2012 era!

No it was willingly ignored.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Nice post Xenus. I liked reading it. About time we get more of people who build up a case or contribute within readback instead of likes of me and few others who just drop insults when getting sussed.



How do you feel about everyone wanting to shoot Chimp?

It just feels like people want Vig to take over someone who's flip would give town VERY little information. Which is why i didn't like CP suggesting it, nor Rugrat.

While i understand he may have a role and may not be around much, shooting him N1 is worst thing vig can do imo. When he could pick someone who's actually been contributing into the thread so we could get some reads and whatnot.

Nah we just don't want to waste a dayphase having to wagon him n get nothing out of it anyways.

 

[Evans]

Given Brutus' role, I've analysed the voting patterns.

Barry voted Haza, Banez, Brutus, then hopped off to Sky (although Evans unvoted on entry)
CP went Jeff, Brutus, Rugrat, Sky, Big Man (avoiding a vote on Brutus come crunch time)
Skybox went Barry, Jeff, Brutus, Chris, Brutus, Jeff. Puts a whole lot of shade on being 'correct' but wasn't on the wagon and hopped off to go for Jeff. However, she did advocate the lynch for quite some time and it would be suicidal to test the fake claim.
Myself I found Mitch scum and went to bed, went to work, took kids to the youth centre. Would've voted Brutus if I had time.
Magic, Alco, Odo don't put a vote on him at all.
Chimp doesn't vote once.

CP looks the worst coming out of it for mine.

All this speculation could drive a man mental. I'm going to make a cuppa, maybe someone will be on to interact and shoot the breeze re: these thoughts.

Feeling better about Lethal from this post. Mitch promised activity today but he's disappeared again - coincidentally after the character of Chimp was identified as a "traitor" - Mitchs entrance is identical to last game.

Terrible entry, IRL problem, disappearance. I'm conscious that IRL is IRL and I hope everything is well in the Mitch household but the exact same behaviour and same pattern in two games strikes me as more than coincidence. Not GOAT 2012 era worthy town play tbh.

No it was willingly ignored.

Good to know.

 

[Banez]

Nah we just don't want to waste a dayphase having to wagon him n get nothing out of it anyways.

Nah, the direction is bad. Based purely on the fact that if they take out someone who actually has played the game a bit would give us something more to look back for.

 

[Banez]

I wouldn't oppose you guys wanting to shoot him if there was somekind of direction that he's scummy. But he has very little amount of posts which would rather get repped out onto an active player rather than waste a vig shot.

And what if he's a town protection role? You'd rather not have a possible protection role just to get rid of a player?

 

[Banez]

protection role gone*

 

[Rugrat]

Well I doubt he’d use it properly

 

[Evans]

I wouldn't oppose you guys wanting to shoot him if there was somekind of direction that he's scummy. But he has very little amount of posts which would rather get repped out onto an active player rather than waste a vig shot.

And what if he's a town protection role? You'd rather not have a possible protection role just to get rid of a player?

I like this thinking, very 2012 era and that was the best era.

Magic is really pushing for Chimp to be shot, absolutely certain of Chimps meta as always being inactive as D1 scum.
We shouldn't be rushing to waste a vig shot, especially on someone who isn't active in the game.

What I find weird is that those pushing to shoot Chimp D1 don't really seem to care about examining the wagon on Brutus at all and they tend to people who didn't vote for him.