WS Mafia: Reloaded - GAME THREAD

[Tweet]

I'd still prefer Banez but will settle for Brutus if Banez absolutely isn't happening

 

[Poyser]

Day 1 Vote Count

Banez (2) - Tweet, Chris
Jeff (2) - Haza, Sky
Brutus (2) - Barry, Mitch
Lethal (1) - Brutus
Haza (7) - Jeff, Xenus, Banez, Alco, Odo, PHEN0M
Chris (1) - Magic
Mitch (1) - Lethal
Rugrat (1) - CP
CP (1) - Rugrat

With 19 alive, it’s 10 to lynch. You have ~13 hours remaining.

​

 

[Rugrat]

You should literally write Oh My God You Suck when making a vote like this next time

It is. I don't know why it's frowned upon to question the alignment of someone questioning yours. As long as it's not Skybox-esque

 

[CraigPelton]

I can acknowledge that a case has fair reasoning - but in this case the reasoning is weak.

Voting someone for not making town reads early, when they made town reads five minutes into their readback and it's something that's NAI anyway is poor.

I wouldn't be town reading you just for making town reads lists, it just doesn't feel to me like you've been trying to clear people as much as usual or inserting yourself as a voice of reason. like I said, you usually give me strong town vibes early on in recent games and that's not been the case here

 

[CraigPelton]

you can say it's because you haven't read much or whatever and that's fine but I have no reason to believe it from my perspective

 

[Showtime]

this isn't very convincing as even if you convince people of every one of your town reads (which is unlikely) every one of the other players has the same chance of being scum and your case on Chris is a bit weak.

I'll ask again what are your thoughts on Brutus? you said you read the first 15 pages and other than the Jeff wagon Brutus fucking up and jumping off the Jeff wagon because he saw him as no selling the wagon was the main thing that happened and a lot of people thought it looked bad.

every other player does have the same chance at being scum, but not every other player has been around as much.

did that happen in the first 15 pages? i mostly saw him saying he'd keep an eye on xenus because xenus said he spends a lot of time staying up as scum opposed to town.

I think there’s definitely merit to what he’s doing
Remember those questions I asked earlier? That’s what I think is going on rn. Have we weighed out that he could have a powerful role that he doesn’t want to out so early?
Could he be going about this is a different way? Absolutely.

I don’t feel the need to park my vote on anybody rn. It’s Day 1, am I not allowed to switch votes and see how people react?

^^this reaction?

i guess it's over-explaining and it appears he dipped since claiming beloved princess so i dont mind a wagon there either i guess. haza is going to flip town tho and im rather positive of that so not going there would be ideal.

 

[Rugrat]

You should literally write Oh My God You Suck when making a vote like this next time

Since you wish to engage on the matter, what are your thoughts on the actual foundations of the case?

 

[Rugrat]

I wouldn't be town reading you just for making town reads lists, it just doesn't feel to me like you've been trying to clear people as much as usual or inserting yourself as a voice of reason. like I said, you usually give me strong town vibes early on in recent games and that's not been the case here

I wasn't saying you should be town reading me for making read lists, since it's a meta that's easy to replicate. I just thought it's odd you were scum reading me for it, despite the fact that I was giving reads any way.

I don't think the second part of your post is unfair

Unvote

 

[Chris]

I think Tweets has made a very solid case on Banez that I he hasn't provided an explanation for yet, so I'm unsure where CP is coming from on that really, disregarding it as Tweet hunting on loved/dv spec when that's clearly not the case. The lack of votes on Banez is kinda surprising too since I feel it's a decent case and it's been talked about decently but with no one else dropping a vote on him today except Odo I believe.

 

[Odo]

Alco can we pleeeease lynch Banez?

 

[Tweet]

Since you wish to engage on the matter, what are your thoughts on the actual foundations of the case?

I made the same observations regarding you as CP, but didn't think it was worth pushing. My take is if you're scum you definitely have to start playing at some point, and I'm not a believer in policing when and to what capacity players need to get involved in the game to begin with.

 

[Rugrat]

has Banez had a meltdown yet? 100% of the time he has meltdowns he's town

 

[Comrade Khan]

has Banez had a meltdown yet? 100% of the time he has meltdowns he's town

he has not. the most pushing ive seen him do (from memory before i get shat on) is him trying to force me to read him. i told him i still had him as null. i dont think he had any further thoughts about that after, but i was also busy dealing with haztard

 

[RDK]

he has not. the most pushing ive seen him do (from memory before i get shat on) is him trying to force me to read him. i told him i still had him as null. i dont think he had any further thoughts about that after, but i was also busy dealing with haztard

 

[CraigPelton]

I made the same observations regarding you as CP, but didn't think it was worth pushing. My take is if you're scum you definitely have to start playing at some point, and I'm not a believer in policing when and to what capacity players need to get involved in the game to begin with.

so your plan is if rugrat is scum to just let him coast for a few phases rather than try and get him more involved early so you can actually read him.

guess we have different approaches! my approach got jeff more involved and I'm hoping it will do the same for rugrat, as this allows people to read him. I like mine better.