WS Mafia: Reloaded - GAME THREAD

[Comrade Khan]

I would add the read list of my scum game which was two games ago (Nintendo) containing three other town reads which I made within my first 20 or so posts, but I don't know how to quote archived games.

me neither, but yo ucould just copy paste the past i g

 

[CraigPelton]

I have a very different view on Tweet actually which is that he tried to make his d1 about pushing a very null player who is hard for people to read and is unlikely to give him much pushback. then Evans happened and he had to change his plan so now he's settling on this lame DV/Beloved set-up spec stuff

not town-reading him at all

 

[Comrade Khan]

I meant they're probably not both scum, bad wording there

 

[Rugrat]

I’m sitting tight on that just for the moment re: Xenus, I can use him to help me regardless of his alignment

who is this directed at?

 

[CraigPelton]

I would add the read list of my scum game which was two games ago (Nintendo) containing three other town reads which I made within my first 20 or so posts, but I don't know how to quote archived games.

the thing about being scum is sometimes you (not you personally, just anyone in general) can replicate your town game and sometimes you can't, so the fact you've done it as scum before doesn't mean you aren't messing it up now

 

[Tweet]

But if Banez and Brutus are both town I'm 0/3

CANNOT DELIVER THE GOODS

 

[Rugrat]

me neither, but yo ucould just copy paste the past i g

It's just a read list I think, with colour coded names.

 

[Odo]

who is this directed at?

magic

 

[Rugrat]

the thing about being scum is sometimes you (not you personally, just anyone in general) can replicate your town game and sometimes you can't, so the fact you've done it as scum before doesn't mean you aren't messing it up now

well I did make town reads literally five minutes into my read back here, so I'd disagree it's not replicating my meta of early town reads. I wasn't active last night.

 

[Big Man]

out of everyone that was posting in the first 15 pages he was the only one around but not at all involved. I wasn't aware he claimed strongman but lol I don't think that's a reason to town read him either if scum have no fakes. Has he fake claimed since my first game and was it at all good?

1) I think Jeff is very likely town(post activity aside saying something about haza to the effect of "I don't care if he's town we are still removing a detriment from the game" is something I only see a town player saying and not scum.

2) I think Barry is town. Again his aggression to haza seemed personal opposed to "scum wanting to fit his meta" like people were saying. It was about the last game and basically carrying a vendetta. More likely from town Barry than scum, ya?

3) Haza looks like town too for 2 reasons 1) his posts don't read like how he forces thoughts as scum 2) his interactions and response to Barry, which he could have ignored rather than responding with "I can be an irritant if you want" 3) pretty much no one else is on his side I'm imagining and the thoughts of a blind happening is more typical against a town player than a scum one 4) trying to lynch the previous games scum mvp game that multiple people are annoyed with doesn't turn out well and is easy for scum to hop on and then point at those same town players blaming them i.e. I think it would be Jeff and Barry in this scenario

4) I like big man's play and responding questioning of Jeff's town read in Xenus as I had the same thought. Not positive he's town but a town read.

5) similarly feel tweet is town for the reasons I brought up earlier. Vibes town and the "gut town read on Barry" bit he has before saying we should read him on play was unnecessary by scum imo. they would just leave it as "barry should be read on play" as others were kinda hinting at barry being town just for having a pr. GUT part wasnt necessary.

6) i didnt like xenus initially because of his town read on banez, but his explanation did make me feel better about him because i think as scum he would probably go for banez throat for not voting me. obviously this changes if banez himself is scum cause it could be scum/scum interaction.

so including me this would be 7/19 people left.

that leaves 12. scum probably has 5/6 people so id give myself a 40-50% chance of being right on chris(im most positive about those first three town reads). if you include the people that were only active in those 15 pages opposed to everyone then that would be an even higher percentage. i think there's a very good chance chris is scum.

other person im fine with is banez as i thought he was weird too and he said he just needed to prove his vote as a double voter and it didnt matter who he voted, but like i said last time i played with him and he voted me and said "i should know youre town now" he was also the double voter in that game im pretty sure.

this isn't very convincing as even if you convince people of every one of your town reads (which is unlikely) every one of the other players has the same chance of being scum and your case on Chris is a bit weak.

I'll ask again what are your thoughts on Brutus? you said you read the first 15 pages and other than the Jeff wagon Brutus fucking up and jumping off the Jeff wagon because he saw him as no selling the wagon was the main thing that happened and a lot of people thought it looked bad.

 

[Rugrat]

@Nikita Chrischev

you need to state your number of shots

 

[Tweet]

I have a very different view on Tweet actually which is that he tried to make his d1 about pushing a very null player who is hard for people to read and is unlikely to give him much pushback. then Evans happened and he had to change his plan so now he's settling on this lame DV/Beloved set-up spec stuff

not town-reading him at all

I think you'll find I'm pushing Banez for his play, not his role. And Brutus has just been swallowed by the earth after being very active for his standards in the early hours if this phase and that could have been an attempt to get meta-based town leans. His actual play hasn't wowed anybody though and his play around Jeff in particular looked pretty scummaaaay.

 

[Big Man]

@Nikita Chrischev

you need to state your number of shots

he already said he only has 1 shot.

 

[Chris]

@Nikita Chrischev

you need to state your number of shots

I already did and got chastised for it

 

[Rugrat]

Actually, Chris would presumably need to prove his shots at some stage which he'd have a lot of difficulty faking on account of not being able to claim to be blocked etc