WS Mafia: Reloaded - GAME THREAD

[Rugrat]

I think we can rule out the chance of Alco being scum, because both the rolecop and the roleblocker are yet to flip - when both would have used their role on D1 and he was tracked to nowhere.

 

[Odo]

By that logic we can prob clear Banez too

 

[Alco]

 

[Odo]

Unless he’s the godfather I guess

 

[RDK]

I actually wanted Odo's chart, can you still do that. I'll get you my reads now

 

[Evans]

2012 GOAT Theory Incomin' - might be a bit WIFOM, might be a conspiracy theory, might just be flat out wrong BUT could it be right?

According to Tweet, Sky/OMB is impossible to be scum - why? Because of the Brutus wagon. I address this here, this just reinforces my thoughts about SkyMB being scum and now I'm starting to think Tweets is too.

But Sky wasn't on the final wagon and already acknowledged that there has to be bussing involved in his wagon.

Not sure how that's impossible.
2012 GOAT readback denies your "impossible" claim.

So, we can see that SkyMB was playing town against Brutus - Sky acknowledged that there is definitely bussing happening with Brutus and then didn't even end up on on the lynch wagon despite her feelings about Brutus being scum and typical town Sky who'd jump on a lynch of someone she vehemently believes to be scum - especially with a strong investigative role like OMB has claimed.

I don't want to comment too much on Sky's reasoning for leaving the game, that'd be unfair. So I will avoid posts of hers about this.

OMB's entrance is just nonsensical as he tries to catch up, fair enough and all he's done since is ask people how they feel and then refusal to go through D1 is questionable especially considering the shit Magic got about catching up.

OMB's claim on usage has me questioning whether it's bs or not. He came in right during mass claim and waited before dropping his usage that was a "no result" on Jeff's bus drive of himself and Alco. OMB's target seemed to be Alco, with a directed post straight at him and then asking Tweet about his thoughts on Alco. This reeks of setting up a mislynch as the direction was going that way as Alco wasn't about and he was POE. Mitch also came in targeting Alco.

I'd hazard a guess that OMB didn't consider Alco could have a shooting role and thought that his usage claim would keep him safe and a 'no result' for Alco would still see him lynched.

Now what strikes me as odd is the interactions between Sky/Tweets.

Ah yes, he's obnoxious which is a town thing with him. Which is the reason your vote is on him. Makes sense.
...hang on

You may be on to something here

Vote Barry

Sky sheeping onto Barry from a Tweets opinion isn't an outlandish thing. Sky & Barry constantly argue - this just felt disingenuous.

Now, Tweets.

D1 - said he'd absolutely use a daykill shot on N0M who turned out to prove to be confirmed town. This was always a point.

Tweets entry to the Brutus wagon was realising that Brutus was done for and no-one was joining him on a mislynch for Banez.

Lol at that fucking vote count. Can we pick a wagon?

unvote
vote Brutus

Yes I realize I'm now voting with Banez.

This is my case on Banez.

As for the claims, DV and Loved are NAI but I'd like to think they're not both scum. Strongman is a claim and I'm interested in Odo in particular accepting it immediately, which is to say if Chris is scum I'd look at Odo next.

Banez has been a commonly accepted town read since D1. Chris turned out to be town strongman and now Tweet has just cleared Odo. I get it, mistakes happen. But Tweet has been incorrect on his reads all game and Tweets is a pretty good player. I think this is unlikely that he's this wrong, this much.

I said I think Magic is town and Rugrat is in my POE.

Because I used my role on him and know he's town now

Interesting switch and clearing Rugrat with claimed role.

I jumped in cause I didn't realize you had a play like that in mind and wanted to cut the wagon short before Rugrat claims when he doesn't have to.

Crossed wires, it happens.

We were on route to a mass claim, why wouldn't you want him to claim? Because you ID'd him as town through your result?

I'd prefer to have Alco and Mitch claim and then the rest can follow suit.

vote Mitch

Why wouldn't you claim and back up your proof to why you know Rugrat is 100% town after you had jumped straight in previously? These two have been considered scum reads, sure - but in retrospect, this doesn't sit right with your previous behaviour around confirming Rugrat.

If Chimp is scum, his team would have submitted his action for him, so the only way night went 24 hours because of Chimp is if he's town.

You make a few posts like this trying to stop Chris being lynched/shot then just switched onto him?

Call me a tard for setup speccing but I'm thinking town doesn't have three protective roles and I'm clearing Haza for choosing to lynch Brutus over anyone else d1 so

unvote
vote Chris

Sleepums

This is something I can't wrap my head around if you were to turn out scum. Why bus Chris after trying so hard to save him? But why try so hard to save him if you had a scum read?




Honestly, I'm having a difficult time trying to explain my reasoning behind my suspicion of Tweets but things just aren't adding up for certain behaviours throughout the game and interactions with people I'm scum reading.

I think OMB is the most likely scum and Tweets with him.

I actually think Mitch is town this game, he and Alco have been targeted by scum players all game for easy lynches due to shit activity but I think Alco's usage/claim really stopped them in their place and once Odo caught onto Chris he was a goner and he got bussed.

 

[RDK]

2. Haza
3. Rugrat
4. Barry (Grimhail Gorbachev) E-V v2
5. PHEN0M
9. CP
10. Mitch
11. Skybox OMB
12. Tweet
13. Lethal
15. Alco
18. BANEZY
20. Odo

 

[RDK]

Does anyone have a full claims list on hand?

 

[RDK]

I'm mostly interested in the claims that include kill shots

 

[Rugrat]

Unless he’s the godfather I guess

but there's still a roleblocker and role cop yet to flip. Banez isn't the Godfather or that'd mean we'd be working on a potential split of 12/6/2, with a double voter mafia member.

 

[RDK]

but there's still a roleblocker and role cop yet to flip. Banez isn't the Godfather or that'd mean we'd be working on a potential split of 12/6/2, with a double voter mafia member.

Where on earth are you getting that split from. Only 3 Maf have flipped...

 

[Rugrat]

2. Haza - Jailkeeper
3. Rugrat - VT
4. Barry (Grimhail Gorbachev) E-V v2 - PR
5. PHEN0M - Gunsmith
9. CP - VT
10. Mitch - VT
11. Skybox OMB - Tracker
12. Tweet - Gravedigger
13. Lethal - Skitzo
15. Alco - 1 shot vig
18. BANEZY - Double voter
20. Odo - Reporter

 

[RDK]

2. Haza - Jailkeeper
3. Rugrat - VT
4. Barry (Grimhail Gorbachev) E-V v2 - PR
5. PHEN0M - Gunsmith
9. CP - VT
10. Mitch - VT
11. Skybox OMB - Tracker
12. Tweet - Gravedigger
13. Lethal - Skitzo
15. Alco - 1 shot vig
18. BANEZY - Double voter
20. Odo - Reporter

so we don't have any kill shots left presumably ?

 

[Rugrat]

Where on earth are you getting that split from. Only 3 Maf have flipped...

Odo said that Banez may be the godfather, I was just pointing out that would be incredibly unlikely as those would be the numbers for it to follow.

 

[Odo]

2. Haza O
3. Rugrat X
4. Barry (Grimhail Gorbachev) E-V v2 X
5. PHEN0M O
9. CP O
10. Mitch XXX (I think he might be traitor)
11. Skybox OMB
12. Tweet ?
13. Lethal O
15. Alco X
18. BANEZY ?
20. Odo O

X means I think are maf O are town

Did you just copy Alcos read list here lmao